Loading...
2022/02/24 Planning Commission Resolution 2022-051 PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION NO. 2022-05 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF ROHNERT PARK RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY COUNCIL AMEND THE NORTHWEST SPECIFIC PLAN AND WILFRED DOWDELL SPECIFIC PLAN, SECTION 17.06.840 (PERMITTED LAND USES) AND GLOSSARY TO CHAPTER 17.06, ARTICLE XV.A (SONOMA MOUNTAIN VILLAGE PLANNED DEVELOPMENT ZONING DISTRICT) OF THE ROHNERT PARK MUNICIPAL CODE; AND SECTION 17.07.020 (FOOTNOTES) OF THE ROHNERT PARK MUNICIPAL CODE TO PROHIBIT NEW OR EXPANDED FUELING FACILITIES WHEREAS, Article XI, Section 7 of the California Constitution authorizes cities to adopt local police, sanitary, and other ordinances not in conflict with general laws; and WHEREAS, the United States Environmental Protection Agency (“EPA”) has classified gas stations and fuel storage locations as uses that may result in a brownfield site. Brownfield sites are properties, the expansion, redevelopment, or reuse of which may be complicated by the presence or potential presence of a hazardous substance, pollutant, or contaminant; and WHEREAS, common contaminants found at gas station sites include gasoline, diesel, and petroleum oil, volatile organic compounds and solvents, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, and lead. Exposure to the types of contaminants present, or potentially present, at gas stations threatens the public health, safety or welfare of neighboring communities; and WHEREAS, the California Legislature, in enacting regulations for underground storage tanks commonly used by gas stations, has made legislative findings that such underground tanks, when used for the storage of hazardous substances and wastes, are potential sources of contamination of the ground and underlying aquifers, and may pose other dangers to public health and the environment; and WHEREAS, with increased fuel economy standards for motor vehicles, an increase in electric vehicles being used for transportation, and competition from large discount retailers, the number of operating gas stations is expected to decline, and it is expected that there may be a rise in the number of abandoned gas stations, which pose a direct threat to public health and safety due to abandoned underground storage tanks, create public nuisances in the community, and increase incidents of blight; and WHEREAS, Governor Newsom’s Executive Order B-48-18, adopted in 2018, noted that the transportation sector resulted in 50 percent of California’s total greenhouse gas emissions and 80 percent of the smog-forming oxides of nitrogen, and directed all state entities to work with local government and the private sector to ensure at least 5 million zero-emissions vehicles on California roads by 2030 and the creation of 250,000 zero emission vehicle charging stations to support such vehicles; and WHEREAS, Governor Newsom’s Executive Order N-79-20, sets a goal to eliminate new gasoline-powered vehicle sales by 2035; and Reso 2022-05 2 WHEREAS, the City of Rohnert Park is a member of the Sonoma County Regional Climate Protection Authority (RCPA), which has recommended that all member agencies consider the adoption on prohibition of new gas station infrastructure by all of their member agencies; and WHEREAS, the City of Rohnert Park has adopted a resolution recognizing the existence of a climate emergency , and the need to reduce and eventually eliminate harmful greenhouse gas emissions, including those created by motor vehicle transportation; and WHEREAS, the City of Rohnert Park supports the implementation of the RCPA Climate Mobilization Strategy which includes “EV Access for All” provisions intended to decarbonize the transportation sector by significantly reducing the reliance on fossil fuels and significantly increasing the use of electric vehicles (EVs) charged with clean, carbon free power; and WHEREAS, on October 12, 2022, the City Council reviewed a draft Climate Change Element for the Rohnert Park General Plan, which documents that 67% of the greenhouse gas emissions in Rohnert Park are associated with the transportation sector; and WHEREAS, the draft Climate Change Element for Rohnert Park sets forth goals and policies to reduce the City’s greenhouse emissions which include support for broader adoption of electric vehicles (EVs) and expansion of EV charging infrastructure; and. WHEREAS, changes to the Rohnert Park Municipal Code that reduce fossil fuel use in the transportation sector, and promote expansion of EV charging infrastructure and greater adoption of electric vehicles are consistent with the Climate Mobilization Strategy and the City’s developing General Plan; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission finds that, in general, businesses involving gasoline and motor fuel vehicle sales may result in serious harmful effects, including but not limited to , increases in the greenhouse emissions that contribute to climate change, increases in air pollution, increases in vehicle traffic congestion, impacts on water quality, and other negative environmental or secondary effects; and WHEREAS, banning new petroleum-based fueling stations supports the larger goal of electrifying the vehicle fleet; and WHEREAS, existing provisions of the Rohnert Park Municipal Code authorize and regulate the operation of “automobile service stations,” defined as “any business or premises engaged in the sale of gasoline and other fuels and/or light maintenance activities such as engine tune-up, lubrication and minor repairs,” in specified commercial and industrial zoning districts; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission recommends that the City prohibit new or expanded automobile service station uses involved in the sale of gasoline, diesel or similar motor vehicle fuel products for internal combustion engine vehicles, while continuing to regulate the location and operation of other automobile service stations; Reso 2022-05 3 WHEREAS, on January February 24, 2022 the Planning Commission held a public hearing at which time interested persons had an opportunity testify either in support of or opposition to the proposal; WHEREAS, pursuant to California State Law and the Rohnert Park Municipal Code, a public notice was published in the Community Voice a minimum of 10 days prior to the first public hearing; and WHEREAS; the Planning Commission has reviewed and considered the information contained in Planning Application No. PLMC22-0001 for the proposed amendments to Title 17 Zoning of the Municipal Code. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Planning Commission of the City of Rohnert Park makes the following findings, determinations and recommendations with respect to the proposed amendments: Section 1. The above recitations are true and correct. Section 2. Environmental Review. The Planning Commission finds the approval of this ordinance is exempt under Sections 15060(c)(2) of the CEQA Guidelines, as the activity will not result in a direct or reasonable foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment, and also exempt under Section 15061(b)(3) of the CEQA Guidelines because it can be seen with certainty that there is no possibility that the adoption of this ordinance may have a significant effect on the environment, because the effect of this ordinance is to prohibit any new, not already approved automobile service station uses that involve the sale of fuels for combustion engine vehicles, and to prohibit the expansion of those features of already existing automobile service stations related to the sale of such fuels. In the alternative, the Planning Commission determines that the basic purpose of this action is to prohibit development or expansion of gasoline stations in the City in order to protect the public health, safety, and general welfare, and therefore is an action for the protection of the environment and is categorically exempt pursuant to CEQA Guidelines section 15307 (protection of natural resources) and 15308 (actions by regulatory agencies for the protection of environment). Section 3. Findings for Amendment of Northwest and Willfred-Dowdell Specific Plans. With respect to the findings required under section 17.06.390 of the Rohnert Park Municipal Code and Government Code section 65454 for amendment of the Willfred-Dowdell Specific Plan and Northwest Specific Plan, having considered the materials in the staff report, the testimony of the public and staff, the Planning Commission finds with respect to the proposed amendments to each specific plan as follows: 1. Each specific plan amendment is consistent with the City's general plan. Criteria Satisfied: Each of the specific plan amendments are consistent with both the current 2020 General Plan and the proposed Climate Change policies with the draft 2040 General Plan. The majority (67%) of greenhouse gas emissions in Rohnert Park are associated with the transportation sector and the draft Climate Change Element sets forth goals and policies to reduce the City’s greenhouse emissions, which include support for Reso 2022-05 4 broader adoption of electric vehicles (EVs) and expansion of EV charging infrastructure. Changes to the specific plans that reduce fossil fuel use in the transportation sector, and promote expansion of EV charging infrastructure and greater adoption of electric vehicles are consistent with the draft General Plan. The amendments are also consistent the following goals in the current 2020 General Plan. o CD-A Create pedestrian-oriented activity centers that serve as community focal points. Gas stations are not conducive to the creation of pedestrian oriented activity centers and banning new fueling facilities will increase the likelihood that more pedestrian friendly activity areas are created. o EC-F Enhance the quality of surface water and groundwater resources and prevent their contamination. Underground tanks are a source of groundwater pollution as they age and leak. Prevention the installation of new underground tanks will reduce this risk. o EC-K Continue to work toward improving air quality and meeting all federal and State ambient air quality standards and by reducing the generation of air pollutants both from stationary and mobile sources where feasible. Automobile emissions from internal combustion engines is a known source of air pollutants. Preventing the installation of new petroleum fueling stations will reduce pollutants over time. 2. Each specific plan amendment will not adversely affect the public health and safety or result in incompatible land uses. Criteria Satisfied: The intent of the amendments to each specific plan is to improve the city’s response to climate change which would result in the long-term benefit to public health. Common contaminants found at gas station sites include gasoline, diesel, and petroleum oil, volatile organic compounds and solvents, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, and lead. Exposure to the types of contaminants present, or potentially present, at gas stations threatens the public health, safety or welfare of neighboring communities. Underground tanks, when used for the storage of hazardous substances and wastes, are potential sources of contamination of the ground and underlying aquifers, and may pose other dangers to public health and the environment. In addition, as the number of operating gas stations is expected to decline, the number of abandoned gas stations is expected to increase, posing a direct threat to public health and safety due to abandoned underground storage tanks, create public nuisances in the community, and increase incidents of blight. 3. Each specific plan amendment provides the framework to phase and pace growth within the specific plan area so as to ensure completion of all necessary public facilities concurrently with completion of the specific plan. Criteria Satisfied: Each amendment does not impact the phasing of the respective specific plans. The amendments do not impact the phasing of growth in the specific plan, the Reso 2022-05 5 specific plan requirements under each plan with respect to phasing and pacing of growth remain in place. 4. Each specific plan amendment identifies adequate financing mechanisms for the infrastructure and public facilities required to support the development. Criteria Satisfied: Each proposed amendment does not impact the financing mechanisms of the respective specific plan. 5. Each proposed specific plan amendment will not create internal inconsistencies within the specific plan and is consistent with the purpose and intent of the specific plan it is amending. Criteria Satisfied: Each specific plan amendment does not create internal inconsistences, and is being adopted to maintain consistency with the municipal code. Amending the specific plans and the municipal code at the same time will impose a uniform ban on all petroleum fueling facilities throughout the City, and does not conflict with the purpose and intent of the specific plan. Section 4. Amendment of Wilfred-Dowell Specific Plan. Table 3.3-1: “Permitted and Conditionally Permitted Uses*” of the Wilfred-Dowell Specific Plan is amended to read in its entirety as set forth in Exhibit A. Section 5. Amendment of Northwest Specific Plan. Table 5-1: “Permitted Uses” of the Northwest Specific Plan is amended to read in its entirety as set forth in Exhibit B. Section 6. Amendment of Rohnert Park Municipal Code section 17.06.840 (Permitted Land Uses) – Table 1, “Land Uses” is amended to read in its entirety as follows: Table 1. Land Uses T3 T4 T5 T6 CS CP CB T7 A. RESIDENTIAL Accessory Building P P P Dwelling, Multifamily P P1 P1 Dwelling, Single Family P P Guest House P P Legend P – Permitted CUP – Conditional Use Permit Required A – Administrative Use Permit Required * - Uses marked with an asterisk are subject to the applicable provisions of Rohnert Park Municipal Code Chapter 17.07 Reso 2022-05 6 Home Occupancy A A A A Large Family Daycare (9-14) P P P P P Live-Work Unit P P P P Manufactured/Mobile Home A CUP Recreational Courts* P P Row House P P2 P1,2 Small Family Daycare Home (8 or Less) P P P P Temporary Use see Section 17.06.030 for all transects Water Storage Cisterns P P P P P P P B. LODGING Bed & Breakfast Inn (up to 5 rooms) P P P Hotel (no room limit) P P Inn (up to 12 rooms) P P School Dormitory P P P C. OFFICE Office2 CUP P P P P D. RETAIL, GENERAL Alcoholic Beverage Establishment* CUP CUP CUP Cinema CUP P CUP Commercial Recreation - Indoor* A P P CUP Bar/Tavern/Night Club* CUP CUP CUP Farmer's Market (daily or weekly, year-round) A A A A A A Groceries, Specialty Foods A P P P Kiosk A A A A A A Liquor Store* CUP CUP CUP CUP Live-Work Unit P P P P CUP Mobile Home, RV and Boat Sales Market Hall3 P P P P Outdoor and Sidewalk Cafes* A P P P A Paraphernalia Store CUP4 CUP5 Plant Nursery CUP A P Push Cart P P P P A Restaurant, Cafe, Coffee Shop A P P CUP A Retail, General A P P CUP A Smoking/Tobacco Store CUP5 CUP7 CUP Theater/Performing Arts (for Movies, see "Cinema") CUP P P P CUP E. CIVIC Art, Public (fountains, statues, kinetic, participatory) P P P P P P P P Amphitheater (outdoor) CUP CUP CUP P/ CUP6 CUP CUP Club, Lodge, Private Meeting Hall P P P CUP Auditorium (indoor) A P P P CUP Library, Museum, Art Gallery A P P P P Parking, Surface Lot P P P P P P P Parking, Structured A P P P P Parks P P P P P P P Recycling Facility A* A* A* A Religious Assembly A A P P P CUP Temporary Use/Event A A A A A A A Reso 2022-05 7 F. AGRICULTURE, FOOD & ANIMALS Beekeeping - Commercial Roof (up to 10 hives)7 P P P P P Beekeeping - Residential Yard (up to 2 hives) P P Chickens (up to 2 hens; no roosters) P P A P Crop Production, Horticulture, Orchard, Vineyard P A A Domestic Animals P P P P Domestic Animal Daycare A P P Animal Rescue CUP CUP Garden, Private or Community (less than 2 acres) P P P P P P P Garden, Private or Community (more than 2 acres) A A A A A Goats (up to 2 females; no males) P P A Green Roof/Green Balcony P P P P P P P P Greenhouse8 (commercial) CUP CUP CUP CUP CUP CUP CUP Kennel CUP CUP Plant Nursery CUP A P P Slaughterhouse not allowed in any transect Trees - Fruit or Nut P P P P P P P P Vertical Garden/Green Wall P P P P P P G. RENEWABLE ENERGY SYSTEMS Solar Photovoltaic System (pole mounted) A P P P P Solar Photovoltaic System (roof mounted) P P P P P P P P Solar Water Heater (roof, wall or ground mounted) P P P P P P P Wind Farm CUP Windmill (horizontal axis - propeller type) P P P P Windmill (vertical axis - cylindrical type) P P P P P P P P H. SERVICES Adult Day Program A P P CUP P Automated Teller Machine (ATM) - no drive-thru P P P P P Bank, Financial Services P A P P P Business Support Services P P P P P Catering P P P P Child Day Care Facility A P P CUP Health Care Facility P A P P P CUP Incinerator (waste, medical waste, cremation) not allowed in any transect Laboratory - Animal Testing not allowed in any transect Laboratory - Medical, Analytical and Research A A P P Laundry, Coin-Operated P A Laundry, Dry Cleaning Plant A A P Maintenance Repair Service - Client Site Services P P P Maintenance Repair Service - Equipment, Appliances P P P Meals Assembly P P P P P Media Production A P P P Medical Service - Major P P CUP CUP Medical Service - Minor CUP P P P P Mortuary, Funeral Home A A A Office - Business, Service, Government P P P P P Office - Professional, Administrative, Processing A P P P Personal Services P A P P P Reso 2022-05 8 Personal Services - Restricted A P P A Printing and Publishing P P P P P Seasonal Services CUP A Storage - Outdoor Storage Yard CUP CUP A P Storage - Warehouse/Indoor A P P Studio - Art, Dance, Martial Arts, Music, etc. P P P P CUP Veterinary Clinic, Animal Hospital CUP P P CUP I. AUTOMOTIVE Auto Vehicle Sales & Rental CUP Car share/ Bicycle share Stations P P P P P P Electric Vehicle Charging Stations P P P P P P Fueling Station (alternative fuels only) CUP CUP Vehicle Services CUP CUP J. CIVIL SUPPORT Cemetery CUP Public Safety Facility A A A A P CUP Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly (RCFE) A A A CUP Residential Care Facilities for the Chronically Ill (RCFCI) A A A CUP Homeless Shelter* CUP CUP P Telecommunication Facility CUP CUP CUP CUP CUP CUP Transitional Housing CUP CUP CUP K. EDUCATION College CUP CUP CUP Elementary School - Private CUP CUP CUP CUP Elementary School - Public P P P P Junior High and High School - Private CUP CUP CUP CUP Junior High and High School - Public P P P P Childcare Center A A A A P A Research and Development (R&D) A P P P School - Specialized Education and Training A A P P P P L. INDUSTRY, MANUFACTURING AND WHOLESALE Commercial Food Processing CUP CUP CUP Furniture/Fixtures Manufacturing, Cabinet Shop P P P Manufacturing/Processing - Light CUP CUP CUP P Manufacturing/Processing - Heavy CUP CUP Wholesale Operations A A P 1 Only allowed on the ground floor where shop front or gallery is not required. 2 For Live-work units, see the Residential category. 3 A single story building with a taller story of up to twenty-five feet is allowed for this use. 4 Paraphernalia stores are subject to Municipal Code 8.33. 5 Smoking/tobacco stores are subject to Municipal Code 8.32. 6 Permitted at Village Center Civic Space only. Requires CUP elsewhere. 7 Minimum twenty feet away from property line. 8 For residential greenhouse, see Accessory Building under Residential. Note that the minimum two-story requirement does not apply to the greenhouse use. Reso 2022-05 9 Section 7. Amendment of Rohnert Park Municipal Code, Chapter 17.06, Article XV.A., Glossary – The Glossary is amended to delete the definition of “Fueling Station,” and add in its place the definition of “Fueling Station (alternative fuels only)” to read in its entirety as follows: "Fueling Station (alternative fuels only)." A retail business selling vehicle fuels, but not including gasoline, diesel, or other motor vehicle fuels for combustion engines, and related products. Hydrogen is an alternative fuel. A fueling station may also include a convenience store of less than four hundred square feet.” Section 8. Amendment of Rohnert Park Municipal Code section 17.07.020 (Footnotes) – Subsection C, “Automobile Service Station,” of Rohnert Park Municipal Code section 17.07.020 (Footnotes) is amended to read in its entirety as follows: C. AUTOMOBILE SERVICE STATION. 1. Service station uses may be permitted in indicated districts only with approval of a conditional use permit and subject to the following provisions. The provisions of this section shall apply to all new service stations. The provisions of this section shall also apply to the expansion of thirty percent or greater in floor area, or a remodeling or any on-site development that would cost more, than fifty percent of the value of the improvements on the parcel at the time of remodeling, excluding land value, except that the provisions prohibiting the expansion, enlargement, reconstruction, or relocation of features related to the sale of gasoline, diesel, or other motor vehicle fuels shall apply to all service stations. The provisions of this section shall also apply to a service station which after being closed for more than one hundred eighty days is to be reopened. 2. Combustion engine fuel sale uses prohibited. a. No automobile service station may be established, or re-established for stations closed in excess of 180 days, that involves the sale or distribution of gasoline, diesel, or other motor vehicle fuels for use in vehicles with combustion engines. Alternative, clean fuels, such as hydrogen are permitted. b. All existing automobile service station uses involving the sale or distribution of gasoline, diesel, or other motor vehicle fuels for combustion engines, shall not be enlarged, extended, or moved to a different portion of the lot or parcel occupied by such use, with respect to the portion of such use dedicated to the sale of gasoline, diesel, or other motor vehicle fuels for use in combustion engines, including those site features such as storage tanks, pumps, and fuel dispensers. 3. Minimum site standards. a. No service station shall be constructed or operated on a lot having a depth or width less than one hundred fifty feet. b. No building or structure (including canopies) shall be located within twenty feet from any curb face, or within ten feet of any interior parcel. No service station building shall be located nearer than thirty-five feet from any street property (such setback shall be measured at the building foundation). c. No facility for dispensing fuel, and no dispenser in which the same is or may be located, shall be nearer than twenty feet from any property line nor nearer than thirty-five feet from any parking space. Further, no dispenser, pump, or facility for dispensing fuel shall be located on a residential street frontage serving as a secondary access to the service station site. d. All outdoor storage shall be screened as provided for in this ordinance, however, a display rack for automobile products no more than four feet wide may be maintained at each dispenser area of a service station. If display racks are not located on dispenser areas, they shall be placed within three feet of the principal building, and shall be limited Reso 2022-05 10 to one per street frontage. The location of display racks and vending machines shall be specified by the use permit. The storage of inoperative vehicles is prohibited. e. Gas tank vent pipes or venting equipment for other fuels shall be incorporated into the structures and concealed from public view. 4. Site Development Standards. a. If a lot upon which a service station is constructed or maintained abuts a residential use or a residentially zoned parcel, a six foot high solid masonry wall shall be constructed along the full length of each property line abutting such properties; provided, however, such wall height shall be reduced to three feet adjacent to the front yard of each adjacent residential property or residentially zoned property. b. All restroom entrances, unless interior to a main building, shall be screened from the view of all adjacent properties and streets by means of decorative screens six feet in height. The bottom of such screens shall be raised no less than twelve inches and no more than eighteen inches above the finished grade for visibility and ventilation. Public restrooms that are accessible to the general public and physically handicapped shall be provided during all hours that the service station is open to the public. c. All outside trash, garbage, refuse and recycling storage areas shall be enclosed by a gated masonry structure not less than six feet in height, ten feet in width (outside dimension), and ten feet in length (outside dimension). Openings to the storage areas shall be designed so as to prevent a view of trash or materials stored from the street or adjacent properties. Provisions for adequate vehicular access for the collection of such trash and materials shall be provided to and from such areas. d. Provisions shall be made in the area where Class II flammable liquids may be spilled to prevent liquids from flowing into the interior of the service station buildings. Such provisions may include grading driveways, raising doorsills, or other equally effective means. Crankcase drainings and flammable liquids shall not be dumped into sewers but shall be stored in tanks or tight drums outside buildings in a designated screened area until removed from the premises by a licensed disposal company. e. Tanks installed for crankcase drainings shall be installed in accordance with the requirements for flammable liquid storage. In addition thereto, drainage lines terminating inside a building shall be equipped with a suitable trap or check valve. f. Service stations constructed in areas that are predominantly of residential character shall be designed to maintain a residential atmosphere. g. A water and air supply station, if provided for public use, shall be located out of traffic flow areas and be shielded so to not create noise audible beyond the property line and shall be kept in working condition. h. Any loudspeaker system shall not be audible above daytime ambient noise levels beyond the property boundaries. The system shall be designed to compensate for ambient noise levels in the immediate area, and shall be directed away from, and not be located within thirty feet of, any residential uses or residential districts. i. Car wash facilities located next to residential uses or residential districts shall not be operated between the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 7:00 a.m. More restrictive time requirements may be established as a condition of any conditional use permit. 5. Landscaping standards. a. Planters shall be installed and maintained adjacent to every street frontage for the full length thereof except for driveways. The street frontage landscaping shall be bermed to be of sufficient height to help screen the dispenser areas from passing motorists. b. A planting area shall be installed and maintained at the intersection of property lines at a street corner to conform to the radius of such corner; provided, however, at no time shall such planting area be less than one hundred fifty square feet. All plants shall respect the visibility triangle provided in this ordinance. c. All planting areas shall be separated from adjacent asphalt paving by concrete curbing at least six inches in height. The site shall be entirely paved, except for buildings and landscaped areas. Reso 2022-05 11 d. Planters shall comply with the parking lot landscaping requirements of this ordinance. e. All plants in any planter adjacent to a perimeter wall shall, when required by the planning commission, be of a variety capable of growing to the height of such wall. f. Permanent underground sprinkler systems shall be installed and maintained for every landscaped area, and all such landscaped areas shall be planted and maintained in a neat, orderly, and healthy manner. 6. Surface drainage. Flow lines shall be shown on all service station plans. Sheet flow shall not be permitted across property lines. Surface runoff shall be carried under sidewalks into the gutter or other drainage facility by means of a drainage structure approved by the city engineer. 7. Utilities. All utilities, including electrical, telephone, C.A.T.V., and similar service wires or cables which provide direct service to the property, shall, within the exterior boundaries of the station property, be installed underground. Related electrical equipment, such as, but not limited to, surface-mounted transformers, pedestal-mounted terminal boxes, and meter cabinets, may be placed above ground if they are enclosed and screened by fencing and/or landscaping as appropriate. 8. Equipment. All hydraulic hoists and pits and equipment for lubrication, greasing, automobile washing, and permitted repairs shall be enclosed entirely within a building. 9. Exterior lighting. All exterior lighting shall be so arranged and shielded as to prevent any glare or reflection upon and cause any nuisance, inconvenience, or hazardous interference of any kind with adjoining streets or properties. 10. Architectural control. All exterior walls should be constructed of rock, brick, stucco, wood, treated metal or any combination thereof. All exterior elevations shall be compatible in design with adjacent structures. Service bays should be oriented to have minimal visibility from adjacent roadways. Service stations within shopping centers/business parks or similar complexes shall be designed to reflect the architectural theme of the complex. Signage and exterior elevations shall be subject to review and approval by the planning commission. 11. Access, parking, and circulation. a. No such site shall have more than two driveways or means of access to any one street. b. Each driveway shall be separated from adjacent residential property by a full height curb extending at least five feet in length from the residential property line. c. No driveway shall exceed a width of twenty feet at the sidewalk. d. No driveway shall be permitted to encroach onto the return or curve of a street corner. A distance of twenty feet, or more if needed for vehicle stacking distance, shall be maintained between the return point and the beginning of the driveway depression. e. Every service station shall have access to a collector or arterial standard street. f. All deliveries shall be made on the service station site itself. g. If a towing service is combined with a service station, a storage area completely screened from public view, by a six foot high solid wall or fence, shall be provided at the rear of the site. The size of the storage area, and extent of screening, shall be determined through the use permit process. This area shall be added to the minimum lot size requirements. h. No vehicles, trailers, or campers on any service station premises may be advertised or offered for sale. There shall be no permanently disabled, junked, or wrecked vehicles stored on site, except in cases of a tow service. Towed permanently disabled, junked, or wrecked vehicles shall be stored on-site no longer than one week and they shall be stored within the designated storage area. Reso 2022-05 13 Exhibit A – Willfred-Dowdell Specific Plan Amendment Automobile Service Stations** ** Subject to requirements forth in Rohnert Park Municipal Code section 17.07.020.C, including prohibitions on sale of gasoline, diesel, and motor vehicle fuels for combustion engines. Reso 2022-05 14 Exhibit B – Northwest Specific Plan Amendment * Subject to requirements forth in Rohnert Park Municipal Code section 17.07.020.C, including prohibitions on sale of gasoline, diesel, and motor vehicle fuels for combustion engines. * Reso 2022-05 15 Reso 2022-05 16 Reso 2022-05 17 Reso 2022-05 18 Reso 2022-05 19 Reso 2022-05 20 Reso 2022-05 21 * Subject to requirements forth in Rohnert Park Municipal Code section 17.07.020.C, including prohibitions on sale of gasoline, diesel, and motor vehicle fuels for combustion engines. * Reso 2022-05 22 Reso 2022-05 23