Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
2026/04/28 City Council Resolution 2026-030
RESOLUTION NO. 2026-030 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ROHNERT PARK, CERTIFYING THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT FOR THE ROHNERT PARK 2040 GENERAL PLAN AND ADOPTING CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT FINDINGS,A STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS AND A MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM WHEREAS,the City of Rohnert Park has completed an update of its General Plan, known as the Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan(the "Project"), which constitutes a"project" under the California Environmental Quality Act("CEQA"); and WHEREAS, CEQA(Public Resources Code Section 21000 et seq.) and the CEQA Guidelines (Cal. Code of Regulations, Title 14, Section 15000 et seq.) require an analysis and determination regarding a project's potential environmental impacts; and WHEREAS,the Project consists of long-term planning policies and standards that will guide future development in the City and does not approve any specific developments, and is therefore appropriately covered by a program-level Environmental Impact Report("EIR") pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15168; and WHEREAS,the City released a Notice of Preparation("NOP") for the EIR to the Office of Planning and Research("OPR") State Clearinghouse and interested agencies and persons on February 26, 2021 for a 33-day review period, during which interested agencies and the public could submit comments about the Project, and convened a scoping meeting on March 11, 2021 to receive public comment; and WHEREAS,the City released a second Notice of Preparation("NOP") for the EIR on February 15, 2022, convened a second scoping meeting on March 10, 2022, and accepted additional comments on the project through March 17, 2022; and WHEREAS, comments on both the first and second NOPs were received and considered during preparation of the Draft EIR; and WHEREAS,the City provided notification to eight California Native American tribes as required by AB 52 and received a request for consultation from the Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria(FIGR) and convened 12 meetings with FIGR, resulting in changes to both the Draft EIR and the Draft 2040 General Plan; and WHEREAS, a Public Review Draft EIR was published on November 21, 2025 and a Notice of Availability ("NOA") was issued concurrently; and WHEREAS,the Draft EIR was filed with the California Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation(LCI, formerly the Office of Planning and Research) on November 21, 2025 and was made available on the City's website, with notification provided to State agencies by LCI, and notification provided by the City to a mailing list of 26 local agencies and a second City mailing list of more than 900 subscribers to the 2040 General Plan website; and WHEREAS, a 57-day period was provided for public review of the EIR, ending on January 16, 2026; and WHEREAS, the Rohnert Park Planning Commission held a public hearing to accept comment on the EIR during the comment period on December 11, 2025, and received public testimony on the EIR; and Resolution 2026-030 Page 1 of 3 WHEREAS, on March 2, 2026,the City published the Final EIR for the Project, attached as Exhibit A of this Resolution, by incorporating: 1)the Draft EIR; 2) comments received about the Draft EIR and responses to those comments; 3) changes, clarifications and corrections to the Draft EIR, in accordance with CEQA and the CEQA Guidelines, and 4) a Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program; and WHEREAS, after notice was lawfully given, a duly noticed public hearing was held before the Rohnert Park City Planning Commission on March 12, 2026 at which all persons interested had the opportunity to appear and comment and at which the Planning Commission considered and made recommendations to the City Council regarding the Final EIR and the merits of the Project, and WHEREAS, at the conclusion of its March 12, 2026 public hearing and discussion, the Planning Commission approved Resolution 2026-03 recommending City Council certification of the Final EIR and adoption of the CEQA Findings and Statement of Overriding Considerations, and the Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program. NOW, THEREFORE,BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Rohnert Park as follows, based on the staff report, Final EIR, oral and written comments and all information in the record: Section 1. The Rohnert Park City Council hereby finds: 1. The above recitations are true and correct and are incorporated by reference into this action. 2. The Final EIR has been completed in compliance with CEQA and includes a Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program ("MMRP")meeting CEQA requirements. 3. The Final EIR was presented to the City Council and the City Council reviewed and considered the information contained in the Final EIR prior to taking action on the Project. 4. The Final EIR reflects the lead agency's independent judgement and analysis. Section 2. On the basis of the evidence contained in the administrative record of the Final EIR, the City Council further finds based on the information submitted following the conclusion of the public comment period on the Draft EIR and following the consultant's responses thereto that the responses to comments, including supplemental policies on groundwater, provide clarification to the information contained in the Draft EIR and do not describe 1) a new substantial environmental impact resulting from the project or from new mitigation measures; 2) a substantial increase in an environmental impact; or 3) a feasible project alternative or mitigation measure that clearly would lessen the environmental impacts of the project that has not been adopted. The new information provided in the Final EIR does not constitute "significant new information" within the meaning of CEQA so as to require recirculation of the Final EIR. (CEQA Guidelines Section 15088.5) and such information does not change the analysis or determinations of significance of potential impact Section 3. After considering the FEIR, Exhibit A of this Resolution, and in conjunction with making the above findings,the City Council hereby finds, as set forth in Exhibit B of this Resolution, that pursuant to Section 15092 of the CEQA Guidelines, approval of the Project will result in significant effects on the environment; however,the City eliminated or substantially lessened these significant effects where feasible, and has determined that the remaining significant effects are found to be unavoidable under Section 15091 and acceptable under Resolution 2026-030 Page 2 of 3 Section 15093. Exhibit B sets forth the findings required under Section 15093 of the CEQA Guidelines relating to accepting adverse impacts of the Project due to overriding considerations. The City has balanced, as applicable, the economic, legal, social, technological, or other benefits, including region-wide or statewide environmental benefits, of the Project against the unavoidable environmental risks that may result, and finds that the specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other benefits outweigh the unavoidable adverse environmental effects. Section 4. The City Council of the City of Rohnert Park does hereby certify the Final EIR, including the Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program (MMRP), attached hereto as Exhibit A, and adopts the MMRP, and the findings and Statement of Overriding Considerations attached hereto as Exhibit B. Section 5. The custodian and location of the documents and other materials which constitute the records of the proceedings upon which this decision is based is the City Clerk of the City of Rohnert Park, Rohnert Park City Hall, 130 Avram Avenue, Rohnert Park, California 94928. DULY AND REGULARLY ADOPTED this 28th day of April, 2026. CITY OF ROHNERT PARK milt' Sanborn, Mayor ATTEST: Sylvia Lopez Cuevas, City Clerk P R A T FORM: - __ c chelle . enyon, City Attorney Attachments: Exhibit A and Exhibit B Ay. ADAMS:A1 S""GIUDICE: RODRIGUEZ:P -ELWARDA' S:1,NBOR. 4y.-- AYES: (c) NOES: (©) ABSENT: (I ) ABSTAIN: (�) Resolution 2026-030 Page 3 of 3 Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Final Environmental Impact Report State Clearinghouse No. 2021020523 prepared by City of Rohnert Park Planning Department 130 Avram Avenue, Second Floor Rohnert Park, California 94928 Contact: Barry Miller, FAICP, Consulting Project Manager prepared with the assistance of Rincon Consultants, Inc. 66 Franklin Street, Suite 357 Oakland, California 94607 February 2026 Exhibit A to Resolution 2026-030 Table of Contents Final Environmental Impact Report i Table of Contents 1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................................... 1-1 1.1 Final EIR Contents ........................................................................................................................ 1-1 1.2 Draft EIR Public Review Process ................................................................................................. 1-1 1.3 EIR Certification Process and Project Approval ......................................................................... 1-2 1.4 Draft EIR Recirculation Not Required .......................................................................................... 1-2 2 Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR ............................................................................................. 2-1 3 Revisions to the Draft EIR ........................................................................................................................ 3-1 3.1 Revisions to the Draft EIR ............................................................................................................ 3-1 3.2 Revisions to Draft EIR Appendices .............................................................................................. 3-7 4 Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program ....................................................................................... 4-1 Tables Table 2-1 Comment Letters Received on the Draft EIR .......................................................................... 2-1 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan ii This page intentionally left blank. Introduction Final Environmental Impact Report 1-1 1 Introduction 1.1 Final EIR Contents This Final Environmental Impact Report (Final EIR) has been prepared by the City of Rohnert Park, Planning Department to evaluate the potential environmental impacts of the proposed Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Project (“proposed project” or “project”). As prescribed by the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines Sections 15088 and 15132, the lead agency (the City) is required to evaluate comments on environmental issues received from persons who have reviewed the Draft EIR and to prepare written responses to those comments. This document, together with the Draft EIR (incorporated by reference) comprise the Final EIR for this project. This Final EIR includes individual responses to each letter received during the public review period for the Draft EIR. In accordance with CEQA Guidelines Section 15088(c), the written responses describe the disposition of significant environmental issues raised. The City has provided a good faith effort to respond to all significant environmental issues raised by the comments. The Final EIR also includes amendments to the Draft EIR consisting of changes suggested by certain comments, as well as minor clarifications, corrections, or revisions to the Draft EIR. The Final EIR includes the following contents: Section 1: Introduction Section 2: Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR, which also includes a list of all commenters and public comment letters Section 3: Revisions to the Draft EIR Section 4: Mitigation Monitoring and Report Program 1.2 Draft EIR Public Review Process The City of Rohnert Park distributed a Notice of Preparation (NOP) of the EIR for a 30-day agency and public review period starting on February 26, 2021, and ending on March 29, 2021. In addition, the city held an EIR Scoping Meeting on March 11, 2021. The meeting, held at 6:00 p.m., was aimed at providing information about the proposed project to members of public agencies, interested stakeholders and residents/community members. The meeting was held in person at Rohnert Park City Hall at 130 Avram Avenue, Second Floor, as well as virtually via Cable Channel 26 and the City of Rohnert Park YouTube channel. The city received comment letters from five agencies and three individuals in response to the NOP during the public review period, as well as various verbal comments during the EIR Scoping Meeting. The NOP is provided in Appendix A of the Draft EIR, along with the NOP responses received. These comments were addressed in the Draft EIR (refer to Table 1-1, beginning on page 1-5 of the Draft EIR). The City published a Notice of Availability (NOA) of the Draft EIR on November 21, 2025, and filed a Notice of Completion (NOC) with the Governor’s Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation (LCI) to begin the 45-day public review period (Public Resources Code Section 21161), which began on November 21, 2025. The City extended the public review period from an initial deadline of January 9, 2026 to January 16, 2026 to provide additional time for comment. The Draft EIR was made available on the City’s project website (https://envisionrp.com/). The NOA was published in the Rohnert Park Community Voice (a local newspaper), filed with the Sonoma County Clerk, and emailed to individuals who requested written notifications related to the project. As a result of these notification efforts, written and verbal comments on the content of the Draft EIR were received, including five comment letters from agencies and verbal public comments at the Planning Commission hearing on City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 1-2 December 11, 2025. Section 2, Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR, identifies these commenting parties, their respective comments, and responses to these comments. None of the comments received, or the responses provided, constitute “significant new information” by CEQA standards (CEQA Guidelines Section 15088.5). 1.3 EIR Certification Process and Project Approval Before adopting the proposed project, the lead agency is required to certify that the EIR has been completed in compliance with CEQA, that the decision-making body reviewed and considered the information in the EIR, and that the EIR reflects the independent judgment of the lead agency. Upon certification of an EIR, the lead agency makes a decision on the project analyzed in the EIR. A lead agency may: (a) disapprove a project because of its significant environmental effects; (b) require changes to a project to reduce or avoid significant environmental effects; or (c) approve a project despite its significant environmental effects, if the proper findings and statement of overriding considerations are adopted (CEQA Guidelines Sections 15042 and 15043). In approving a project, for each significant impact of the project identified in the EIR, the lead or responsible agency must find, based on substantial evidence, that either: (a) the project has been changed to avoid or substantially reduce the magnitude of the impact; (b) changes to the project are within another agency's jurisdiction and such changes have or should be adopted; or (c) specific economic, social, or other considerations make the mitigation measures or project alternatives infeasible (CEQA Guidelines Section 15091). Per Public Resources Code Section 21061.1, feasible means capable of being accomplished in a successful manner within a reasonable period of time, taking into account, economic, environmental, legal, social, and technological factors. If an agency approves a project with unavoidable significant environmental effects, it must prepare a written Statement of Overriding Considerations that sets forth the specific social, economic, or other reasons supporting the agency’s decision and explains why the project’s benefits outweigh the significant environmental effects (CEQA Guidelines Section 15093). When an agency makes findings on significant effects identified in the EIR, it must adopt a reporting or monitoring program for mitigation measures that were adopted or made conditions of project approval to mitigate significant effects (CEQA Guidelines Section 15091[d]). 1.4 Draft EIR Recirculation Not Required CEQA Guidelines Section 15088.5 requires Draft EIR recirculation when comments on the Draft EIR or responses thereto identify “significant new information.” Significant new information is defined as including: A new significant environmental impact would result from the project or from a new mitigation measure proposed to be implemented. A substantial increase in the severity of an environmental impact would result unless mitigation measures are adopted that reduce the impact to a level of insignificance. A feasible project alternative or mitigation measure considerably different from others previously analyzed would clearly lessen the significant environmental impacts of the project, but the project's proponents decline to adopt it. The draft EIR was so fundamentally and basically inadequate and conclusory in nature that meaningful public review and comment were precluded. The comments, responses, and Draft EIR amendments presented in this document do not constitute such “significant new information;” instead, they clarify, amplify, or make insignificant modifications to the Draft EIR. For example, none of the comments, responses, and Draft EIR amendments disclose new or Introduction Final Environmental Impact Report 1-3 substantially more severe significant environmental effects of the proposed project, or new feasible mitigation measures or alternatives considerably different than those analyzed in the Draft EIR that would clearly lessen the proposed project’s significant effects. City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 1-4 This page intentionally left blank. City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report 2 Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR This section includes comments received during public circulation of the Draft Environmental Impact Report (EIR) prepared for the Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan. The Draft EIR was circulated for a 57-day public review period that began on November 21, 2025 and ended on January 16, 2026. The City of Rohnert Park received five written comment letters on the Draft EIR and verbal public comments from the December 11, 2025 Planning Commission hearing, which are summarized herein. The commenters and the page number on which each commenter’s letter appear are listed below in Table 2-1. Table 2-1 Comment Letters Received on the Draft EIR Letter No. and Commenter Page No. 1 Constantin Raether, Program Manager, California Governor’s Office of Emergency Services 2-2 2 Yunsheng Luo, Branch Chief, California Department of Transportation 2-4 3 Erin Chappell, Regional Manager, California Department of Fish and Wildlife 2-15 4 Noah Housh, Community Development Director, City of Cotati 2-37 5 Andy Rodgers, Administrator, and Marcus Trotta, Plan Manager, Santa Rosa Plain Groundwater Sustainability Agency 2-42 Public Hearing Comments 2-47 The comment letters and responses follow. The comment letters are numbered sequentially. Each separate issue raised by the commenter, if more than one, has been assigned a number. The responses to each comment identify first the number of the comment letter, and then the number assigned to each issue (Response 1.1, for example, indicates that the response is for the first issue raised in Comment Letter 1). Where a comment resulted in a change to the Draft EIR text, a notation is made in the response indicating that the text is revised. Changes in text are signified by strikeout font (strikeout font) where text was removed and by underlined font (underlined font) where text was added. These changes in text are also included in Section 3, Revisions to the Draft EIR. 2-1 Aileen Mahoney From:Raether, Constantin@CalOES <Constantin.Raether@CalOES.ca.gov> Sent:Wednesday, December 10, 2025 3:40 PM To:bmiller@rpcity.org Cc:LaMar-Haas, Victoria@CalOES; Aileen Mahoney; CalOES Mitigation Planning; Graulty, William@CalOES Subject:[EXT] City of Rohnert Park General Plan Update CAUTION: This email originated from outside of Rincon Consultants. Be cautious before clicking on any links, or opening any attachments, until you are confident that the content is safe . Good afternoon The California Governor’s Office of Emergency Services (Cal OES) Local Hazard Mitigation Planning Team has taken the time to review the proposed updates/changes to your General Plan. Government Code 65302(g)(8) states “before preparing or revising its Safety Element, each city and county shall consult…. the Office of Emergency Services for the purpose of including information known by and available to the department.” The Cal OES Local Hazard Mitigation Planning Team reviews and compares your current Safety Element hazards against those listed in the most recent Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) approved Rohnert Park Local Hazard Mitigation Plan (LHMP). Our office has reviewed your proposed Safety Element and found no substantive changes to your hazard profiles when compared against the most recent FEMA approved Rohnert Park Local Hazard Mitigation Plan. Please reach out to you our office at mitigationplanning@caloes.ca.gov if you have any further questions or need additional assistance. Regards Constantin Raether, Program Manager I Local Mitigation Planning | Recovery Directorate California Governor’s Office of Emergency Services Office: (916) 328-7778 Cell: (916) 715-9408 www.caloes.ca.gov/HMGP Letter 1 1.1 2-2 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report Letter 1 COMMENTER: Constantin Raether, Program Manager, California Governor’s Office of Emergency Services DATE: December 10, 2025 Response 1.1 The commenter compared the Safety Element to those in the FEMA approved Rohnert Park Local Hazard Mitigation Plan (LHMP). The commenter indicated they found no substantive changes to hazards in the region as those in the Rohnert Park LHMP. This comment is noted and passed on to decision-makers for consideration. 2-3 “Provide a safe and reliable transportation network that serves all people and respects the environment.” January 9, 2026 SCH #: 2021020523 GTS #: 04-SON-2021-01049 GTS ID: 22140 Co/Rt/Pm: SON/101/13.24 Barry Miller, Consulting Project Manager City of Rohnert Park 6750 Commerce Boulevard Rohnert Park, CA 94928 Re: Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan ─ Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) Dear Barry Miller: Thank you for including the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) in the environmental review process for the Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan. The Local Development Review (LDR) Program reviews land use projects and plans to ensure consistency with our mission and state planning priorities. The following comments are based on our review of the November 2025 DEIR. Please note this correspondence does not indicate an official position or approval by Caltrans on this project and is for informational purposes only. Project Understanding The proposed General Plan serves several purposes: Provide the public opportunities for meaningful participation in the planning and decision-making process; Provide a description of current conditions within the city and trends influencing the future of the city; Identify planning issues, opportunities, and challenges that should be addressed in the 2040 General Plan; Explore land use and policy alternatives; Ensure that the General Plan is current, internally consistent, and easy to use; Provide guidance in the planning and evaluation of future land and resource decisions; and Provide a vision and framework for the future growth of Rohnert Park. Travel Demand Analysis With the enactment of Senate Bill (SB) 743, Caltrans is focused on maximizing efficient development patterns, innovative travel demand reduction strategies, and multimodal improvements. For more information on how Caltrans assesses Vehicle Letter 2 DISTRICT 4 OFFICE OF REGIONAL AND COMMUNITY PLANNING P.O. BOX 23660, MS–10D | OAKLAND, CA 94623-0660 www.dot.ca.gov 2.1 2-4 Barry Miller, Consulting Project Manager January 9, 2026 Page 2 “Provide a safe and reliable transportation network that serves all people and respects the environment.” Miles Traveled (VMT) analysis for land use projects, please review Caltrans’ Transportation Impact Study Guide (link). The project VMT analysis and significance determination are undertaken in a manner consistent with the Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation’s (LCI) Technical Advisory. Per the DEIR, this project is found to have a significant and unavoidable VMT impact. Caltrans acknowledges that the General Plan has identified Policy C-3.1, Policy C-3.2 and Policy C-3.3 to help mitigate future developments’ potential VMT impact. We commend the City for working with Sonoma County Transportation Authority (SCTA) to explore developing a VMT mitigation bank alternative which would help further reduce VMT. Please consider including additional measures to further mitigate this impact: - Accelerate implementation of “Complete Streets” upgrades on major corridors and Highway 101 interchanges, in coordination with Caltrans. - Expand and connect Class I and II bikeways and improve pedestrian crossings, especially for first/last mile access to SMART stations and bus stops. - Support and expedite the planned State Farm Drive overcrossing and additional SMART station west of Highway 101. - Enhance transit service frequency, reliability, and integration with active transportation. - Prioritize transit-oriented development and infill and reduce parking minimums near transit. - Section 4.14-36, Implementation Program C-E: Transportation Demand Management Program should also include the implementation of transit priority roadway treatments and improved transit access on the 101 as strategies within the TDM program. These strategies can enhance transit reliability and help achieve VMT reduction goals. Please refer to the Caltrans Local Development Review TDM Toolbox and the Caltrans Bay Area Transit Plan for additional strategies and best practices to reduce VMT through supporting transit priority and access improvements, including parking management and employer- based trip reduction programs. - Project mitigation efforts, goals, policies, and Table 4.14-1 Project Consistency Directives with Caltrans Directives should also align with and incorporate Caltrans Directors Policy-040 Transit and the Caltrans Bay Area Transit Plan and Transit Needs Assessment. These strategies are consistent with Caltrans, SCTA, and regional plans, and can help reduce VMT, support mode shift, and improve transportation equity. The City should 2.1 2.2 2-5 Barry Miller, Consulting Project Manager January 9, 2026 Page 3 “Provide a safe and reliable transportation network that serves all people and respects the environment.” work with Caltrans and regional partners to implement and fund these measures as part of General Plan implementation and project review. Multimodal Transportation Planning Please review and include reference to the Caltrans District 4 Pedestrian Plan (2021) and the Caltrans District 4 Bike Plan (2018) in the DEIR. These two plans studied existing conditions for walking and biking along and across the State Transportation Network (STN) in the nine-county Bay Area and developed a list of location-based and prioritized needs. Please note that any Complete Streets reference should be updated to reflect Caltrans Director’s Policy 37 (link) that highlights the importance of addressing the needs of non-motorists and prioritizing space-efficient forms of mobility, while also facilitating goods movement in a manner with the least environmental and social impacts. This supersedes Deputy Directive 64-R1, and further builds upon its goals of focusing on the movement of people and goods. All goals, policies, and mitigation efforts involving transit within the EIR should be represented in the Transportation and Traffic Section. Thank you again for including Caltrans in the environmental review process. Should you have any questions regarding this letter, please contact Melissa Hernandez, Associate Transportation Planner via LDR-D4@dot.ca.gov. For future early coordination opportunities or project referrals, please visit Caltrans LDR website (link) or contact LDR- D4@dot.ca.gov. Sincerely, YUNSHENG LUO Branch Chief, Local Development Review Office of Regional and Community Planning c: State Clearinghouse 2.3 2.4 2.2 2.5 2-6 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report Letter 2 COMMENTER: Yunsheng Luo, Branch Chief, California Department of Transportation DATE: January 9, 2026 Response 2.1 The commenter summarizes the project and concurs with the VMT analysis methodology provided in the Draft EIR. This comment is noted. The VMT analysis was completed consistent with the OPR Technical Advisory. Response 2.2 The commenter recommends additional mitigation measures to assist in mitigating potential VMT impacts from future developments. The following additional mitigation measures requested by the commenter are similar to already proposed General Plan goals and policies or in some cases already included in the General Plan as noted below: •Accelerate implementation of “Complete Streets” upgrades on major corridors and Highway 101 interchanges, in coordination with Caltrans. o This request is redundant with 2040 General Plan Goals C-4 (Complete Streets, including policies to implement complete streets upgrades), C-6 (Bicycle and Pedestrian improvements, including priority projects), and C-7 (Safety Improvements) and associated policies, subject to funding availability. •Expand and connect Class I and II bikeways and improve pedestrian crossings, especially for first/last mile access to SMART stations and bus stops. o This request is redundant with 2040 General Plan Goal C-6 and related policies, subject to funding availability. •Support and expedite the planned State Farm Drive overcrossing and additional SMART station west of Highway 101. o This request is redundant with Policy C-1.3 (Engage in planning and design and seek outside funding to complete the State Farm Drive overcrossing) and Policy C-8.3 (Investigate a new SMART station on the west side of US 101), subject to funding availability. •Enhance transit service frequency, reliability, and integration with active transportation. o This request is redundant with Goal C-8 (Facilitate transit improvements and connections) and related policies, subject to funding and coordination with local transit providers. •Prioritize transit-oriented development and infill and reduce parking minimums near transit. o This request is redundant with Policy C-9.2, which already states the City’s support for land use plans and building design to support transit and Policy C-10.5, which calls for variable parking standards depending on transit access. •Section 4.14-36, Implementation Program C-E: Transportation Demand Management Program should also include the implementation of transit priority roadway treatments and improved transit access on the 101 as strategies within the TDM program. These strategies can enhance transit reliability and help achieve VMT reduction goals. Please refer to the Caltrans Local Development Review TDM Toolbox and the Caltrans Bay Area Transit Plan for additional strategies and best practices to reduce VMT through supporting transit priority and access improvements, including parking management and employer-based trip reduction programs. 2-7 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report o TDM goals and policies are already incorporated into Goal C-3 and associated policies. Transit- related goals and policies are included in Section 7.6 Transit. The commenter’s request for revisions to Table 4.14-1 regarding Caltrans Directors Policy 40 and the Caltrans Bay Area Transit Plan and Transit Needs Assessment have been made to the Final EIR; however it is noted that 2040 General Plan Goal C-8 (and related policies) are generally consistent with this request. Goal C-8 is to facilitate transit improvements, and its policies seek to encourage and maximize transit opportunities in a manner that is aligned with Caltrans Directors Policy 40. Table 4.14-1 of the Draft EIR has been revised as follows (revised rows only): Caltrans Directives Project Consistency Directors Policy 40: Transit. Public transit provides vital mobility to many Californians daily, central to powering our state’s society and economy. As outlined in the Director’s Complete Streets Policy DP-37, it is California Department of Transportation (Caltrans') organizational priority to encourage and maximize transit as a strategy to not only meet state climate, health, equity, and environmental outcomes but also to foster socially and economically vibrant, thriving, and resilient communities. Furthermore, public transit use results in significant safety benefits for all road users and aid California to achieve its goal of eliminating fatalities and serious injuries, as outlined in Director’s Road Safety Policy DP-36 and the Secretary’s Policy 01-25 on Road Safety. Consistent. The City’s Circulation Element includes goals and policies that prioritize the provision of transit services, including: •Goal C-2: To coordinate with regional agencies on transportation improvements outside the city limits. •Goal C-4 (reproduced above). •Policy C-4.1 (reproduced above). •Policy C-4.2 (reproduced above). •Goal C-5: To encourage alternative travel modes, including transit, driving, biking, and walking by improving the multimodal circulation system •Policy C-5.1: Multimodal Network Strategy and Prioritization. The City shall identify and prioritize components of a multimodal network to increase continuity between pedestrian routes, bicycle routes, and public transit. •Goal C-8: Facilitate transit improvements and connections to create better connections to destinations around the city and between travel modes. •Policy C-8.1: Transit Access. The City shall work with transit providers and private developers and regional partners to improve transit access as follows: o Develop well-designed accessible pick-up and drop- off locations and provide benches, shelters and amenities as appropriate o Focus transit service along corridors to maintain a level of service that is meaningful to the community o Work with paratransit providers to ensure Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) compliant paratransit services are available to eligible residents and visiting clients o Support last-mile solutions (e.g., shuttle service, shared-mobility services, proximity to pedestrian and bicycle path connections) to connect public transit riders to their ultimate destinations. o Encourage transit providers to have adequate bike racks on buses and rail cars to allow for convenient mode transitions for bicyclists. •Policy C-8.2: Regional Transit Connections. The City shall coordinate with SMART, Sonoma County Transit, and Golden Gate Transit to increase public transit service between Rohnert Park and other cities in the Bay Area and to coordinate: 2-8 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report Caltrans Directives Project Consistency o Multi-modal connections for regional trips, o Transit service or infrastructure improvements, o Closure of transit gaps, and o Deployment of information and schedules with real- time information. •Goal C-9: Encourage transit ridership to support a sustainable transportation system. •Policy C-9.1: Maintain and Expand Transit Service. The City shall support levels of transit service that are adequate to meet and encourage ridership demand and work with service providers to adjust train schedules and bus routes to address new potential markets and levels of demand. •Policy C-9.2: Development Designed to Support Transit. The City shall support land use plans and building design that prioritizes higher intensity development close to transit, active frontages, space for bus stop amenities, and safety for people. Caltrans Bay Area Transit Plan and Transit Needs Assessment. The plan includes goals, objectives and performance measures, including for the provision of complete streets, equity in transportation choices, decreasing VMT, and supporting long-term transit projects. Consistent. The City’s Circulation Element includes a specific focus on complete streets. Applicable goals and policies include: •Goal C-4 (reproduced above). •Policy C-4.1 (reproduced above). •Policy C-4.2 (reproduced above). The City’s Racial Social and Environmental Justice Element includes policies regarding the equitable provision of services, including: •Policy RSEJ-4.2 (reproduced above). •Policy RSEJ-4.3 (reproduced above). •Policy RSEJ-5.4 (reproduced above). The City’s Circulation Element includes goals and policies regarding VMT, including: •Goal C-3: To reduce automobile dependency and associated impacts. •Policy C-3.1: Regional VMT Mitigation Bank. The City shall encourage and support the Sonoma County Transportation Authority (SCTA) in establishing a regional VMT mitigation bank and/or regional VMT impact fee program that can be used to fund effective VMT reduction strategies at a regional level, while also establishing a mechanism for private development to offset their VMT impacts. •Policy C-3.2: Development Review Requirements for Vehicle Miles Traveled. The City shall, as part of development project CEQA review, require new development projects to achieve a reduction in vehicle miles traveled (VMT) compared to baseline conditions. The City will support SCTA’s efforts in maintaining the regional travel demand model, which will be used to adjust baseline VMT levels over time and allow the City to establish updated VMT benchmarks for project applicants. 2-9 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report Caltrans Directives Project Consistency •Policy C-5.2: Promote Multimodal Mixed-Use Developments. The City shall promote the development of multimodal mixed-use development. •Policy C-6.3: Bike and Pedestrian Crossings in Central Rohnert Park. The City shall continue to study the feasibility of separated bicycle pedestrian crossings, including crossings over Rohnert Park Expressway at the SMART Multi-Use Path and work with Caltrans, SCTA and SMART to implement feasible projects. The City’s Circulation Element includes goals and policies regarding the provision of transit services, including: •Goal C-5 (reproduced above). •Policy C-5.1 (reproduced above). •Goal C-8: Facilitate transit improvements and connections to create better connections to destinations around the city and between travel modes. •Policy C-8.1: Transit Access. The City shall work with transit providers and private developers and regional partners to improve transit access as follows: o Develop well-designed accessible pick-up and drop- off locations and provide benches, shelters and amenities as appropriate o Focus transit service along corridors to maintain a level of service that is meaningful to the community o Work with paratransit providers to ensure Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) compliant paratransit services are available to eligible residents and visiting clients o Support last-mile solutions (e.g., shuttle service, shared-mobility services, proximity to pedestrian and bicycle path connections) to connect public transit riders to their ultimate destinations. o Encourage transit providers to have adequate bike racks on buses and rail cars to allow for convenient mode transitions for bicyclists. •Policy C-8.2: Regional Transit Connections. The City shall coordinate with SMART, Sonoma County Transit, and Golden Gate Transit to increase public transit service between Rohnert Park and other cities in the Bay Area and to coordinate: o Multi-modal connections for regional trips, o Transit service or infrastructure improvements, o Closure of transit gaps, and o Deployment of information and schedules with real- time information. •Goal C-9: Encourage transit ridership to support a sustainable transportation system. •Policy C-9.1: Maintain and Expand Transit Service. The City shall support levels of transit service that are adequate to meet and encourage ridership demand and work with service providers to adjust train schedules and bus routes to address new potential markets and levels of demand. 2-10 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report Caltrans Directives Project Consistency •Policy C-9.2: Development Designed to Support Transit. The City shall support land use plans and building design that prioritizes higher intensity development close to transit, active frontages, space for bus stop amenities, and safety for people. Additionally, Section 4.14.2 of the Draft EIR has been revised as follows: Caltrans Director’s Policy 40 Transit Director’s Policy 40, a policy regarding public transit, was adopted by Caltrans in February of 2026. The policy reads: Public transit provides vital mobility to many Californians daily, central to powering our state’s society and economy. As outlined in the Director’s Complete Streets Policy DP-37, it is California Department of Transportation (Caltrans') organizational priority to encourage and maximize transit as a strategy to not only meet state climate, health, equity, and environmental outcomes but also to foster socially and economically vibrant, thriving, and resilient communities. Furthermore, public transit use results in significant safety benefits for all road users and aid California to achieve its goal of eliminating fatalities and serious injuries, as outlined in Director’s Road Safety Policy DP-36 and the Secretary’s Policy 01-25 on Road Safety. The policy requires Caltrans to establish metrics to evaluate and measure the performance and need for transit, increase engagement related to transit services, and improve planning and operational analysis for transit. Caltrans Bay Area Transit Plan The Caltrans Bay Area Transit Plan (2025) identifies deficiencies and potential improvements to increase transit reliability and access, and encourage more transit use along the State Transportation Network in the Bay Area. The City of Rohnert Park is identified in the plan as containing equity priority communities. The plan includes goals, objectives and performance measures, including for the provision of complete streets, equity in transportation choices, decreasing VMT, and supporting long- term transit projects. These revisions supplement the existing analysis in the Draft EIR and do not introduce substantial new information to the Draft EIR requiring recirculation. Response 2.3 The commenter suggests a review and reference and addition of the Caltrans District 4 Pedestrian Plan and Bike Plan. The District 4 Pedestrian and Bicycle plans provide a broad overview of pedestrian and bicycle improvements along the State Transportation Network (STN). It is noted that the only STN facility in Rohnert Park is Highway 101, which prohibits bicycle and pedestrian travel. The 2040 General Plan includes Policy C-4.4 and Goal C-6, which will improve safety and mobility for bicyclists and pedestrians, including at freeway ramp terminal intersections, where Caltrans and the City will continue to collaborate on improvements. References to the Caltrans District 4 Pedestrian Plan (2021) and the Caltrans District 4 Bike Plan (2018) have been incorporated into the Final EIR. Page 4.14-12 of the Draft EIR has been revised as follows: 2-11 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report Caltrans District 4 Pedestrian Plan Caltrans’ District 4 Pedestrian Plan identifies and prioritizes pedestrian needs along and across the State Highway System to inform future investments. The Plan notes that pedestrians are prohibited on Highway 101 through the City of Rohnert Park, and thus does not include plans for pedestrian improvements along the segment of Highway 101 in the Plan Area. Caltrans District 4 Bike Plan The Caltrans District 4 Bike Plan identifies infrastructure improvements that can enhance bicycle safety and mobility throughout District 4 and remove some of the barriers to bicycling in the region. The Plan notes that bicyclists are prohibited on Highway 101 through the City of Rohnert Park, and thus does not include plans for bicycle improvements along the segment of Highway 101 in the Plan Area. This addition supplements the existing analysis in the Draft EIR and does not introduce substantial new information to the Draft EIR requiring recirculation. Response 2.4 The commenter requests that references to Complete Streets be updated to reflect Caltrans Directors’ Policy 37. Caltrans Director Policy 37 is related to Complete Streets; the reference to Deputy Directive 64-R1 has been replaced by a reference to Director Policy 37. The 2040 General Plan makes a number of references to Complete Streets, including goals and policies within Section 7.3, Complete Streets and Section 7.4, Pedestrian and Bicycle Circulation. Page 4.14-12 of the Draft EIR has been revised as follows: Caltrans Director’s Policy 37 Deputy Directive 64-R1 Complete Streets – Integrating the Transportation System In 2021, Caltrans adopted Director’s Policy 37, prioritizing complete streets throughout the district. The policy states: The California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) recognizes that walking, biking, transit, and passenger rail are integral to our vision of delivering a brighter future for all through a world- class transportation network. Additionally, Caltrans recognizes that streets are not only used for transportation but are also valuable community spaces. Accordingly, in locations with current and/or future pedestrian, bicycle, or transit needs, all transportation projects funded or overseen by Caltrans will provide comfortable, convenient, and connected complete streets facilities for people walking, biking, and taking transit or passenger rail unless an exception is documented and approved. When decisions are made not to include complete streets elements in capital and maintenance projects, the justification will be documented with final approval by the responsible District Director. Opportunities for complete streets exist in all phases of project development from planning and design to construction, operations, and maintenance. Complete streets projects should prioritize underserved communities that have been historically harmed and segmented by the transportation network and should serve people of all ages and abilities. Furthermore, Caltrans commits to removing unnecessary policy and procedural barriers and partnering with communities and agencies to ensure projects on local and state transportation systems improve the connectivity to existing and planned pedestrian, bicycle, and transit facilities, and accessibility to existing and planned destinations, where possible. 2-12 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report In 2001, Caltrans adopted Deputy Directive 64; a policy directive related to non-motorized travel throughout the State. In October 2008, Deputy Directive 64 was strengthened to reflect changing priorities and challenges. Deputy Directive 64-R1 states: The Department views all transportation improvements as opportunities to improve safety, access, and mobility for all travelers in California and recognizes bicycle, pedestrian, and transit modes as integral elements of the transportation system. Providing safe mobility for all users, including motorists, bicyclists, pedestrians and transit riders, contributes to the Department's mission/vision: "Improving Mobility across California.” Successful long-term implementation of this directive is intended to result in more options for people to go from one place to another, less traffic congestion and greenhouse gas emissions, more walkable communities (with healthier, more active people), and fewer barriers for older adults, children, and people with disabilities. Table 4.14-1 on page 4.14-19 of the Draft EIR has been revised as follows (revised row only): Caltrans Directives Project Consistency Caltrans Deputy Directive 64- R1Complete Streets – Integrating the Transportation System. The Department views all transportation improvements as opportunities to improve safety, access, and mobility for all travelers in California and recognizes bicycle, pedestrian, and transit modes as integral elements of the transportation system. Providing safe mobility for all users, including motorists, bicyclists, pedestrians and transit riders, contributes to the Department's mission/vision: "Improving Mobility across California.” Caltrans Director’s Policy 37 Complete Streets. In locations with current and/or future pedestrian, bicycle, or transit needs, all transportation projects funded or overseen by Caltrans will provide comfortable, convenient, and connected complete streets facilities for people walking, biking, and taking transit or passenger rail unless an exception is documented and approved. Complete streets projects should prioritize underserved communities that have been historically harmed and segmented by the transportation network and should serve people of all ages and abilities. Consistent. The City’s Circulation Element includes a specific focus on complete streets. Applicable goals and policies include: •Goal C-4: To support the ongoing development of an integrated transportation network that allows safe and convenient travel along and across streets for all users, including pedestrians, bicyclists, persons with disabilities, motorists, movers of commercial goods, users and operators of public transportation, seniors, youth, and families. •Policy C-4.1: Streets for All Users. The City shall ensure that streets safely serve seniors, youth, those with disabilities, and all members of the community, and provide a network connecting residences, employment areas, services, health care facilities, schools, parks, retail areas, and public facilities. •Policy C-4.2: New Streets Designed as Complete Streets. The City shall design local streets to accommodate all street users with comfortable pedestrian environments as the priority, including street tree planting between the street and sidewalk, minimized curb cuts, sidewalks on both sides of streets, and low impact development features, where feasible These revisions supplement the existing analysis in the Draft EIR and do not introduce substantial new information to the Draft EIR requiring recirculation. 2-13 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report Response 2.5 The commenter requests all goals, policies, and mitigation efforts involving transit within the EIR are displayed in the Transportation and Traffic Section. Transit-related goals, policies, and implementation actions in the General Plan are referenced as appropriate under Impact T-1, beginning on page 4.14-18 of the Draft EIR. 2-14 State of California – Natural Resources Agency GAVIN NEWSOM, Governor DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE VALERIE TERMINI, Acting Director Bay Delta Region 2825 Cordelia Road, Suite 100 Fairfield, CA 94534 (707) 428-2002 www.wildlife.ca.gov Conserving California’s Wildlife Since 1870 January 12, 2026 Barry Miller, FAICP, Consulting Project Manager City of Rohnert Park 130 Avram Avenue Rohnert Park, CA 94928 BMiller@rpcity.org Subject: Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan, Program Environmental Impact Report, SCH No. 2021020523, Sonoma County Dear Barry Miller: The California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) received a Notice of Intent to Adopt a Program Environmental Impact Report (EIR) from the City of Rohnert Park (City) for the Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan (project) pursuant the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and CEQA Guidelines.1 CDFW previously submitted a letter dated March 22, 2021 in response to the EIR Notice to Preparation (NOP) for the project. CDFW is submitting comments on the EIR to inform the City, as the Lead Agency, of our concerns regarding potentially significant impacts to biological resources associated with the project. CDFW ROLE CDFW is a Trustee Agency with responsibility under CEQA (Pub. Resources Code, § 21000 et seq.) pursuant to CEQA Guidelines section 15386 for commenting on projects that could impact fish, plant, and wildlife resources. CDFW is also considered a Responsible Agency if a project would require discretionary approval, such as permits issued under the California Endangered Species Act (CESA), Lake and Streambed Alteration (LSA) Program, or other provisions of the Fish and Game Code that afford protection to the state’s fish and wildlif e trust resources. PROJECT DESCRIPTION SUMMARY Proponent: City of Rohnert Park Objective: The project is a comprehensive update of the City’s 2020 General Plan. The project designates land uses defining the type of development that can occur throughout the City through the planning horizon year of 2040. Most of the future 1 CEQA is codified in the California Public Resources Code in section 21000 et seq. The “CEQA Guidelines” are found in Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations, commencing with section 15000. DocusignEnvelopeID:0F20C610-18F1-4D59-B10A-40DF7C6BA3C0 3.1 Letter 3 2-15 Barry Miller City of Rohnert Park January 12, 2026 Page 2 development capacity in the City is within specific plan areas, planned developments, and the Central Rohnert Park Priority Development Area, especially for residential development. Development capacity in the rest of the City will be through strategic infill sites. The project would include the rezoning of two sites on Snyder Lane from Public Institutional to High Density Residential to ensure consistency with the Housing Element. Location: The approximately 7.3-square-mile planning area, which includes the City of Rohnert Park and its Sphere of Influence, with an approximate center at 38.348326°N, 122.701654°W. REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS California Endangered Species Act Please be advised that a CESA Incidental Take Permit (ITP) must be obtained if the project has the potential to result in “take” of plants or animals listed or candidates under CESA, either during construction or over the life of the project. The project has the potential to result in take of California tiger salamander (Ambystoma californiense), which is CESA listed as threatened, and Sonoma sunshine (Blennosperma bakeri), Sebastopol meadowfoam (Limnanthes vinculans), and Burke’s goldfields (Lasthenia burkei), which are CESA listed as endangered species, and burrowing owl (Athene cunicularia) and Crotch's bumble bee (Bombus crotchii), which are CESA candidate species, as further described below. Thank you for including a requirement for the project to conduct preconstruction surveys and obtain a CESA ITP for take of Crotch’s bumblebee if the surveys result in positive detection. Issuance of a CESA ITP is subject to CEQA documentation; the CEQA document must specify impacts, mitigation measures, and a mitigation monitoring and reporting program. If the project will impact CESA listed species, early consultation is encouraged, as significant modification to the project and mitigation measures may be required in order to obtain a CESA ITP. CEQA requires a Mandatory Finding of Significance if a project is likely to substantially restrict the range or reduce the population of a threatened or endangered species. (Pub. Resources Code, §§ 21001, subd. (c) & 21083; CEQA Guidelines, §§ 15380, 15064, & 15065.). Impacts must be avoided or mitigated to less-than-significant levels unless the CEQA Lead Agency makes and supports Findings of Overriding Consideration (FOC). The CEQA Lead Agency’s FOC does not eliminate the project proponent’s obligation to comply with CESA. Lake and Streambed Alteration An LSA Notification, pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 1600 et seq., is required for project activities affecting lakes or streams and associated riparian habitat. DocusignEnvelopeID:0F20C610-18F1-4D59-B10A-40DF7C6BA3C0 3.1 2-16 Barry Miller City of Rohnert Park January 12, 2026 Page 3 Notification is required for any activity that may substantially divert or obstruct the natural flow; change or use material from the bed, channel, or bank including associated riparian or wetland resources; or deposit or dispose of material where it may pass into a river, lake, or stream. Work within ephemeral streams, washes, watercourses with a subsurface flow, and floodplains are subject to LSA Notification requirements. Project activities may impact streams or lakes, therefore an LSA Notification may be warranted, as further described below. CDFW would consider the CEQA document for the project and may issue an LSA Agreement. CDFW may not execute the final LSA Agreement until it has complied with CEQA as a Responsible Agency. Raptors and Other Nesting Birds CDFW has jurisdiction over actions that may result in the disturbance or destruction of active nest sites or the unauthorized take of birds. Fish and Game Code sections protecting birds, their eggs, and nests include sections 3503 (regarding unlawful take, possession or needless destruction of the nests or eggs of any bird), 3503.5 (regarding the take, possession or destruction of any birds-of-prey or their nests or eggs), and 3513 (regarding unlawful take of any migratory nongame bird). Migratory birds are also protected under the federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act (MBTA). California Fully Protected Species Fully protected species may not be taken or possessed at any time and no licenses or permits may be issued for their take except as follows: • Take is for necessary scientific research; • Efforts to recover a fully protected, endangered, or threatened species, live capture and relocation of a bird species for the protection of livestock; or • They are a covered species whose conservation and management is provided for in a Natural Community Conservation Plan (Fish & G. Code, §§ 3511, 4700, 5050, & 5515). Specified types of infrastructure projects may be eligible for an ITP for unavoidable impacts to fully protected species if certain conditions are met (Fish & G. Code § 2081.15). Project proponents should consult with CDFW early in the project planning process. The project has the potential to impact white-tailed kite (Elanus leucurus), which is a California fully protected species. COMMENTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS CDFW offers the comments and recommendations below to assist the City in adequately identifying and/or mitigating the project’s significant, or potentially significant, DocusignEnvelopeID:0F20C610-18F1-4D59-B10A-40DF7C6BA3C0 3.1 3.2 2-17 Barry Miller City of Rohnert Park January 12, 2026 Page 4 direct and indirect impacts on fish and wildlife (biological) resources. Attachment 1 includes CDFW’s below recommended mitigation measures in a Draft Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program. I. Project Description and Related Impact Shortcoming COMMENT 1: Program Environmental Impact Report Subsequent Project Review The EIR is a Program EIR but does not include a checklist for subsequent project review. As described in CDFW’s letter response to the NOP, while Program EIRs have a necessarily broad scope, CDFW recommends providing as much information related to anticipated future activities as possible. CDFW recognizes that, pursuant to CEQA Guidelines section 15152, subdivision (c), if a Lead Agency is using the tiering process in connection with an EIR or large-scale planning approval, the development of detailed, site-specific information may not be feasible and can be deferred, in many instances, until such time as the Lead Agency prepares a future environmental document. This future environmental document would cover a project of a more limited geographical scale and is appropriate if the deferred information does not prevent adequate identification of significant effects of the planning approval at hand. The CEQA Guidelines section 15168, subdivision (c)(4) states, “Where the later activities involve site specific op erations, the agency should use a written checklist or similar device to document the evaluation of the site and the activity to determine whether the environmental effects of the operation were within the scope of the program EIR.” Based on CEQA Guidelines section 15183.3 and associated Appendix N Checklist, and consistent with other program EIRs (e.g., California Vegetation Treatment Program Environmental Impact Report and associated checklist in Appendix PD-3 - Project- Specific Analysis at: https://bof.fire.ca.gov/projects-and-programs/calvtp-homepage-and storymap/#:~:text=The%20CalVTP%20Program%20Environmental%20Impact,with %20the%20CalVTP%20Program%20EIR), CDFW recommends creating a procedure or checklist for evaluating subsequent project impacts on biological resources to determine if they are within the scope of the Program EIR or if an additional environmental document is warranted. This checklist should be included as an attachment to the EIR. Future analysis should include all special-status species and sensitive habitat including, but not limited to, species considered rare, threatened, or endangered species pursuant to CEQA Guidelines, section 15380. When used appropriately, the checklist should be accompanied by enough relevant information and reasonable inferences to support a “within the scope” of the EIR conclusion. For subsequent project activities that may affect sensitive biological resources, a site-specific analysis should be prepared by a Qualified Biologist to DocusignEnvelopeID:0F20C610-18F1-4D59-B10A-40DF7C6BA3C0 3.2 2-18 Barry Miller City of Rohnert Park January 12, 2026 Page 5 provide the necessary supporting information. In addition, the checklist should cite the specific portions of the EIR, including page and section references, containing the analysis of the subsequent project activities’ significant effects and indicate whether it incorporates all applicable mitigation measures from the EIR. II. Environmental Setting and Related Impacts Shortcomings Mandatory Findings of Significance: Does the project have the potential to substantially reduce the number or restrict the range of a rare or endangered plant or animal? And, Would the project have a substantial adverse effect, either directly or through habitat modifications, on any species identified as a candidate, sensitive, or special-status species in local or regional plans, policies, or regulations, or by CDFW or U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)? COMMENT 2: Deferred Mitigation Issue, specific impacts, why they may occur and be potentially significant: If the project may result in physical changes in the environment, such as facilitating development, then the project could: 1) reduce the number or restrict the range of an endangered, rare, or threatened species, or 2) have a substantial adverse effect, either directly or through habitat modifications, on candidate, sensitive, or special- status species. The EIR documents 70 special-status plant species and 37 special- status animal species either within or in the vicinity of the City of Rohnert Park (D-1 through D-7). The project area has potential to support special-status species including, but not limited to, Sonoma sunshine, Sebastopol meadowfoam, and Burke’s goldfields, CESA listed as endangered ; California tiger salamander, a CESA listed as threatened species; and burrowing owl, a CESA candidate species and California Species of Special Concern, in addition to the other species mentioned above, however, the EIR does not include mitigation measures for impacts to CESA- listed species, other than Crotch’s bumblebee. As described in CDFW’s letter response to the NOP, California tiger salamander may be directly or indirectly impacted by the project resulting in mortality of individuals from direct impacts or indirect impacts from degradation of habitat adjacent to ground disturbance and other factors. Additionally, the project may result in the permanent and temporary loss of California tiger salamander habitat. The EIR indicates that wetlands may be present within project sites. As described in CDFW’s letter response to the NOP, wetlands in the Santa Rosa Plain may support Sonoma sunshine, Sebastopol meadowfoam, and Burke’s goldfields, and loss of DocusignEnvelopeID:0F20C610-18F1-4D59-B10A-40DF7C6BA3C0 3.2 3.3 2-19 Barry Miller City of Rohnert Park January 12, 2026 Page 6 wetland habitat may result in in mortality of individuals and/or indirect impacts from degradation of habitat adjacent to ground disturbance due to altering hydrological conditions or other factors may occur. The project could result in burrowing owl injury or mortality of adults, and permanent wintering (i.e., non-nesting) habitat loss. Additionally, the project may result in a permanent reduction of burrowing owl foraging habitat in Sonoma County. Burrowing owl is a special-status species and was approved as a candidate species under CESA because the species’ population viability and survival are adversely affected by risk factors such as precipitous declines from habitat loss, fragmentation, and degradation; evictions from wintering sites without habitat mitigation; and human disturbance (Shuford and Gardali 2008; Department of Fish and Game Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (2012); personal communication, CDFW Statewide Burrowing Owl Coordinator Esther Burkett, May 13, 2022, CDFW Petition for Western Burrowing Owl (Athene cunicularia hypugaea), 2024). Based on the foregoing, if burrowing owls are wintering on or within 500 meters (1,640 feet) of the project site, or if burrowing owl foraging habitat is removed, project impacts to burrowing owl would be potentially significant. The EIR states that projects facilitated by the EIR will follow existing local government policies and applicable protective measures in the Santa Rosa Plain Conservation Strategy (SRP CS) (EIR pages 4.3-18). However, the SRP CS is a guidance document that was developed several years ago and conditions for some species have deteriorated since it was developed, therefore the SRP CS conservation measures may not adequately mitigate impacts to special-status species to less-than-significant. Additionally, the SRP CS does not cover all special- status species in the Project area. Therefore, while the SRP CS is a useful reference, the EIR should not rely on the SRP CS’s measures to mitigate impacts to less-than-significant and should instead conduct a current evaluation of impacts and appropriate mitigation measures. The EIR states that impacts to biological resources would be less-than-significant in part because of a requirement for the City to “...complete a site-specific biological resource assessment prepared by a qualified biologist that establishes the existing resources present, potential impacts on the resources, and mitigation measures for these impacts” (see EIR page 4.3-18). However, the proposed biological resource assessments inappropriately defer formulating mitigation measures and may not appropriately identify special-status species that may be impacted and measures reducing such impacts to less-than-significant. Further, the proposed biological resource assessments would not be subject to public review under CEQA, thereby circumventing key purposes of CEQA including informing the public and governmental decision makers about the potential, significant environmental effects of a proposed project and identifying ways that environmental damage can be avoided or significantly reduced (CEQA Guidelines, § 15002). CEQA Guidelines DocusignEnvelopeID:0F20C610-18F1-4D59-B10A-40DF7C6BA3C0 3.3 2-20 Barry Miller City of Rohnert Park January 12, 2026 Page 7 section 15126.4, subdivision (b) states: “Formulation of mitigation measures shall not be deferred until some future time. The specific details of a mitigation measure, however, may be developed after project approval when it is impractical or infeasible to include those details during the project's environmental review provided that the agency (1) commits itself to the mitigation, (2) adopts specific performance standards the mitigation will achieve, and (3) identifies the type(s) of potential action(s) that can feasibly achieve that performance standard and that will considered, analyzed, and potentially incorporated in the mitigation measure. Compliance with a regulatory permit or other similar process may be identified as mitigation if compliance would result in implementation of measures that would be reasonably expected, based on substantial evidence in the record, to reduce the significant impact to the specified performance standards.” No specific mitigation measures relating to take of CESA-listed species other than Crotch’s bumblebee are included in the biological resources section of the EIR. The lead agency (the City) has therefore not committed itself to mitigation, nor does the EIR adopt specific performance standards for mitigation goals, nor does it identify types of actions that could meet these standards. It is conceivable based on the lack of mitigation measures that California tiger salamander, Sonoma sunshine, Sebastopol meadowfoam, Burke’s goldfields, burrowing owl, and other special-status species would: 1) not be appropriately evaluated in subsequent biological surveys, or 2) that future environmental review pursuant to CEQA would not require appropriate mitigation measures to reduce impacts to less-than-significant. Therefore, if special-status species occur on or adjacent to project sites, impacts to special-status species would be potentially significant, and impacts to species considered threatened, endangered, or rare may be considered a mandatory finding of significance (CEQA Guidelines, §§ 15065 & 15380). Recommended Mitigation Measures: To reduce potential impacts to less-than- significant and comply with CESA, CDFW recommends including mitigation measures in the EIR which evaluate such foreseeable potentially significant impacts. Where future site-specific impacts may not be presently foreseeable based on the project’s broad scope, the checklist discussed in Comment 1 above should be used to determine if a future CEQA environmental document is required. CDFW would appreciate the opportunity to review a revised EIR and may have further comments once more specific species information is provided. For example, CDFW recommends including the mitigation measures below in this EIR: DocusignEnvelopeID:0F20C610-18F1-4D59-B10A-40DF7C6BA3C0 3.3 2-21 Barry Miller City of Rohnert Park January 12, 2026 Page 8 MM-BIO-1. Prior to commencing construction-related activities on grassland or wetland habitat suitable to support California tiger salamander, the project shall obtain a CESA ITP from CDFW for impacts to California tiger salamander and comply with the ITP. Copies of the ITP shall be provided to the City prior to the commencement of construction-related activities. The project shall obtain authorization from USFWS for impacts to California tiger salamander and comply with the authorization. The project shall also provide habitat compensation for California tiger salamander in accordance with the ITP, SRP CS, and the USFWS’ Reinitiation of Formal Consultation on Issuance of Clean Water Act, Section 404 Permits by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers on the Santa Rosa Plain, Sonoma County, California (2020 PBO). Please note that the CESA ITP habitat compensation requirements are often consistent with the SRP CS and 2020 PBO but may differ based on site specific conditions. MM-BIO-2. Prior to ground disturbance, the project shall submit a wetland assessment and an evaluation of potential direct and indirect impacts to any on- site or adjacent off-site wetland habitat, such as modification of hydrological conditions or construction related sedimentation into occupied wetland habitat, to CDFW for review and obtain CDFW’s written acceptance of the assessment and evaluation. If direct or indirect impacts to potentially suitable wetlands for special-status plant species including, but not limited to, Sonoma sunshine, Sebastopol meadowfoam, and Burke’s goldfields may occur, the project shall submit to CDFW two years of completed botanical survey results and obtain CDFW’s written approval of the results prior to project construction. The botanical survey results should follow CDFW’s 2018 Protocols for Surveying and Evaluating Impacts to Special-Status Native Plant Populations and Sensitive Natural Communities (https://wildlife.ca.gov/Conservation/Survey-Protocols#377281280- plants) and the Santa Rosa Plain Conservation Strategy, Appendix D: Guidelines for Conducting and Reporting Botanical Inventories for Federally Listed Plants on the Santa Rosa Plain (https://www.fws.gov/library/collections/santa-rosa-plain- conservation-strategy). If CDFW is unable to accept the survey results, the project shall conduct additional surveys prior to initiation of project activities or may assume presence of special-status plants, such as Sonoma sunshine, Burke’s goldfields, and Sebastopol meadowfoam. Please be advised that for CDFW to accept the results, they should be completed in conformance with the above survey protocols and guidelines, including, but not limited to conducting surveys during appropriate conditions, utilizing appropriate reference sites, and evaluating all direct and indirect impacts such as altering off-site hydrological conditions where the above species may be present. Surveys should include the entire extent of any directly or indirectly impacted suitable wetland habitat, including portions of the wetland on adjacent parcels or not directly impacted, as impacts to part of a wetland often affects the entire wetland. Evaluation of indirect DocusignEnvelopeID:0F20C610-18F1-4D59-B10A-40DF7C6BA3C0 3.3 2-22 Barry Miller City of Rohnert Park January 12, 2026 Page 9 impacts may necessitate a thorough hydrological assessment that fully analyzes existing and post-project conditions to seasonal wetland habitat. Surveys conducted during drought conditions may not be acceptable. If the botanical surveys result in the detection of the above CESA listed plants that may be impacted by the project, or the presence of these species is assumed, the project shall obtain a CESA ITP from CDFW prior to construction and comply with all requirements of the ITP including but not limited to providing habitat compensation. In addition, the project shall consult with the USFWS for any impacts to suitable habitat for plants listed under the federal Endangered Species Act (e.g., wetlands) and provide compensatory habitat mitigation as required. MM-BIO-3. If the project occurs during the burrowing owl wintering season from September 1 to January 31, prior to project activities a Qualified Biologist shall conduct a burrowing owl habitat assessment within 1,640 feet of the project area pursuant to the California Department of Fish and Game (now CDFW) 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (CDFW 2012 Staff Report, available here: https://wildlife.ca.gov/Conservation/Survey-Protocols#377281284-birds), unless otherwise approved in writing by CDFW. The Qualified Biologist shall have a minimum of two years of experience implementing the CDFW 2012 Staff Report habitat assessment and survey methodology. The habitat assessment shall focus on searching the California Natural Diversity Database (CNDDB) and potentially other sources for any burrowing owl records on or within one mile of the project area, vegetation type and height, suitable burrows (with an opening of greater than 11 centimeters in diameter and a depth of greater than 150 centimeters), burrow surrogates (culverts, piles of concrete rubble, piles of soil, burrows created along soft banks of ditches and canals, pipes, and similar structures), and presence of burrowing owl sign (tracks, molted feathers, cast pellets, prey remains, egg shell fragments, owl white wash, and nest burrow decoration material), and the presence of burrowing owl individuals or pairs. If the habitat assessment does not identify suitable habitat and surveys are not conducted as described below, an additional habitat assessment shall be conducted within 14 days prior to construction and if new potentially suitable burrowing owl refugia are present surveys shall be conducted as described below, unless otherwise approved in writing by CDFW. The results of the habitat assessment shall be emailed to CDFW and the project shall obtain CDFW’s written approval of the habitat assessment prior to starting project activities. If suitable burrowing owl habitat is observed, four surveys shall be conducted to detect the presence of burrowing owl pursuant to the CDFW 2012 Staff Report, and shall begin on August 1. The site visits shall be spread evenly throughout August and the non-breeding season, unless otherwise approved in writing by CDFW. The survey results shall be emailed to CDFW and the project shall obtain CDFW’s written approval of the survey results prior to starting project activities. In addition, a take avoidance survey shall be completed within 14 days prior to DocusignEnvelopeID:0F20C610-18F1-4D59-B10A-40DF7C6BA3C0 3.3 2-23 Barry Miller City of Rohnert Park January 12, 2026 Page 10 the start of construction, as described in the CDFW 2012 Staff Report. Time lapses of more than 14 days between project activities may trigger subsequent surveys including but not limited to a final survey conducted within 24 hours prior to ground disturbance. If burrowing owl is detected, the project shall immediately notify CDFW. The project shall avoid impacts to the burrowing owl and implement a 1,640-foot buffer area around the owl site in which no project activities shall occur, unless otherwise approved in writing by CDFW. A Qualified Biologist or Biological Monitor shall monitor any detected owl to ensure it is not disturbed. If the surveys result in the detection of the burrowing owl that may be impacted by the project, or the presence of this species and impacts to it are assumed, the project shall obtain and comply with an ITP from CDFW. Habitat compensation for impacts to occupied wintering burrowing owl habitat (habitat known to have been occupied by wintering burrowing owl within the last three years) shall also be provided at a minimum 3:1 mitigation to impact ratio prior to project construction, unless otherwise approved by CDFW. Habitat mitigation shall include permanent preservation of high-quality burrowing owl wintering habitat through a conservation easement and implementing and funding a long-term management plan in perpetuity, to be finalized before project construction, unless otherwise approved in writing by CDFW. The burrowing owl mitigation plan shall be submitted to CDFW for approval before project construction and include a review of suitability of mitigation lands for burrowing owl as confirmed by a Qualified Biologist. The project shall obtain CDFW’s written approval of the burrowing owl mitigation plan. Please be advised that an ITP obtained for burrowing owl may have additional requirements to achieve full mitigation. COMMENT 3: White-tailed Kite and other Nesting Birds Issue, specific impacts, why they may occur and be potentially significant: The project may impact nesting birds such as white-tailed kite, which is a California fully protected species. Nesting birds are also protected by Fish and Game Code section 3500 et seq. and the federal MBTA. Human activity and removal of habitat has contributed to the loss of a significant proportion of the total number of birds in the United States and Canada since the 1970s (Rosenburg et al. 2019). Nesting birds may be disturbed by habitat removal or noise and visual disturbances above ambient levels, which could result in active nest loss or abandonment or reduced health and vigor of young, resulting in a potentially significant impact. Recommended Mitigation Measure: To reduce potential impacts to white-tailed kite and other nesting birds to less-than-significant and comply with Fish and Game DocusignEnvelopeID:0F20C610-18F1-4D59-B10A-40DF7C6BA3C0 3.3 3.4 2-24 Barry Miller City of Rohnert Park January 12, 2026 Page 11 Code section 3500 et seq. and federal MBTA, CDFW recommends including the below mitigation measure in the EIR. MM-BIO-4. If construction, grading, vegetation removal, or other project-related activities are scheduled during the avian nesting season, February 1 to August 31, a Qualified Biologist shall conduct a survey for active bird nests within 7 days prior to the beginning of project-related activities. The survey shall cover the entire project area and a minimum 500-foot buffer or the distance necessary as determined by a Qualified Biologist. If a lapse in project-related work of seven days or longer occurs, another survey shall be conducted before Project work can be reinitiated. If an active nest is found during surveys, the Qualified Biologist shall immediately notify CDFW and establish site- and species-specific no-work buffers to ensure the nest is not disturbed. The buffer distances shall be specified to protect the bird’s normal behavior to prevent nesting failure or abandonment and comply with Fish and Game Code section 3500 et seq. and the federal MBTA. Abnormal nesting behaviors which may cause reproductive harm include, but are not limited to, defensive flights/vocalizations directed towards project personnel, standing up from a brooding position, and flying away from the nest. The Qualified Biologist shall have authority to order the cessation of all nearby project activities if the nesting birds exhibit abnormal behavior which may cause reproductive failure (nest abandonment and loss of eggs and/or young) until an appropriate buffer is established. The Qualified Biologist shall monitor the behavior of the birds (adults and young, when present) at the nest site to ensure that they are not disturbed by project work. Nest monitoring shall continue during project work until the young have fully fledged (have completely left the nest site and are no longer being fed by the parents), as determined by the Qualified Biologist, unless otherwise approved in writing by CDFW. III. Would the Project have a substantial adverse effect on any riparian habitat or other sensitive natural community identified in local or regional plans, policies, regulations or by CDFW or USFWS? COMMENT 4: Riparian Habitat, Wetlands, Sensitive Natural Communities, and Lake and Streambed Notification Issue, specific impacts, why they may occur and be potentially significant: If the project may result in physical changes in the environment, then the project could result in potentially significant impacts to riparian habitat, wetlands, or other sensitive natural communities such as Northern Vernal Pools (https://wildlife.ca.gov/Data/VegCAMP/Natural-Communities#sensitive). DocusignEnvelopeID:0F20C610-18F1-4D59-B10A-40DF7C6BA3C0 3.4 3.5 2-25 Barry Miller City of Rohnert Park January 12, 2026 Page 12 Recommended Mitigation Measure: If impacts to riparian habitat, wetlands, or other sensitive natural communities may occur, to reduce potential impacts to less- than-significant and comply with Fish and Game Code section 1600 et seq., CDFW recommends including the mitigation measure below. MM-BIO-5. The project shall submit an LSA notification for any direct on-site or indirect off-site impacts to streams or lakes. For project activities that may substantially alter the bed, bank, or channel of any streams (including ephemeral or intermittent streams), an LSA Notification shall be submitted to CDFW pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 1602 prior to project construction. If CDFW determines that a LSA Agreement is warranted, the project shall comply with all required measures in the LSA Agreement, including, but not limited to requirements to mitigate impacts to the streams and riparian habitat. Permanent impacts to the stream and associated riparian habitat shall be mitigated by restoration of riparian habitat at a 3:1 mitigation to impact ratio based on acreage and linear distance as close to the project area as possible and within the same watershed and year as the impact, unless otherwise approved in writing by CDFW. Temporary impacts shall be restored on-site in the same year as the impact. The project shall also consult with the Regional Water Quality Control Board and Army Corps of Engineers to impacts to waters such as streams, lakes, and wetlands, and obtain permits if necessary pursuant to the Clean Water Act and Porter Cologne Water Quality Control Act. MM-BIO-6. The Project shall implement restoration on-site or off-site to mitigate temporary or permanent impacts to sensitive natural communities at a minimum 1:1 (restore on-site temporary impacts) or 3:1 (permanent impacts) mitigation to impact ratio for acres and linear feet of impacts, and trees, if applicable, shall be replaced at an appropriate ratio based on size and species, and temporal habitat loss, or provide habitat compensation including permanent protection of habitat at the same ratio through a conservation easement and preparing and funding implementation of a long term management plan, unless otherwise approved in writing by CDFW. ENVIRONMENTAL DATA CEQA requires that information developed in environmental impact reports and negative declarations be incorporated into a database which may be used to make subsequent or supplemental environmental determinations. (Pub. Resources Code, § 21003, subd. (e).) Accordingly, please report any special-status species and natural communities detected during project surveys to the CNDDB. The CNDDB field survey form can be filled out and submitted online at the following link: https://wildlife.ca.gov/Data/CNDDB/Submitting-Data. The types of information reported to CNDDB can be found at the following link: https://www.wildlife.ca.gov/Data/CNDDB/Plants-and-Animals. DocusignEnvelopeID:0F20C610-18F1-4D59-B10A-40DF7C6BA3C0 3.5 3.6 2-26 Barry Miller City of Rohnert Park January 12, 2026 Page 13 ENVIRONMENTAL DOCUMENT FILING FEES The project, as proposed, would have an impact on fish and/or wildlife, and assessment of environmental document filing fees is necessary. Fees are payable upon filing of the Notice of Determination by the Lead Agency and serve to help defray the cost of environmental review by CDFW. Payment of the environmental document filing fee is required in order for the underlying project approval to be operative, vested, and final. (Cal. Code Regs, tit. 14, § 753.5; Fish & G. Code, § 711.4; Pub. Resources Code, § 21089.) CONCLUSION CDFW appreciates the opportunity to comment on the EIR to assist the City in identifying and mitigating project impacts on biological resources. Questions regarding this letter or further coordination should be directed to Nick Wagner, Senior Environmental Scientist (Specialist), at (707) 428-2075 or Nicholas.Wagner@wildlife.ca.gov; or Melanie Day, Senior Environmental Scientist (Supervisory), at (707) 210-4415 or Melanie.Day@wildlife.ca.gov. Sincerely, Erin Chappell Regional Manager Bay Delta Region Attachment 1: Draft Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program ec: Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation, State Clearinghouse, Sacramento (SCH No. 2021020523) Vincent Griego, USFWS - Vincent_Griego@fws.gov REFERENCES California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW, formerly California Department of Fish and Game). 2012. Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation. Available online at: https://nrm.dfg.ca.gov/FileHandler.ashx?DocumentID=83843&inline CDFW. 2024. Petition Evaluation for Western Burrowing Owl (Athene cunicularia hypugaea). Report to the Fish and Game Commission. California Department of Fish and Wildlife, P.O. Box 944209, Sacramento, CA. DocusignEnvelopeID:0F20C610-18F1-4D59-B10A-40DF7C6BA3C0 3.7 2-27 Barry Miller City of Rohnert Park January 12, 2026 Page 14 Klute, D. S., L. W. Ayers, M. T. Green, W. H. Howe, S. L. Jones, J. A. Shaffer, S. R. Sheffield, and T. S. Zimmerman. 2003. Status Assessment and Conservation Plan for the Western Burrowing Owl in the United States. U.S. Department of Interior, Fish and Wildlife Service, Biological Technical Publication FWS/BTPR6001-2003, Washington, D.C. Rosenburg, Kenneth V.; Dokter, Adriaan M.; Blancher, Peter J.; Sauer, John R.; Smith, Adam C.; Smith, Paul A.; Stanton, Jessica C.; Panjabi, Avrind; Helft, Laura; Parr, Michael; and Marra, Peter P. 2019. Decline of the North American Avifauna. Science: 120-124. Shuford, W. D., and Gardali, T., editors. 2008. California Bird Species of Special Concern: A ranked assessment of species, subspecies, and distinct populations of birds of immediate conservation concern in California. Studies of Western Birds 1. Western Field Ornithologists, Camarillo, California, and California Department of Fish and Game, Sacramento. DocusignEnvelopeID:0F20C610-18F1-4D59-B10A-40DF7C6BA3C0 2-28 Barry Miller City of Rohnert Park January 12, 2026 Page 15 ATTACHMENT 1 Draft Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program Biological Resources (BIO) Mitigation Measure (MM) Description Implementation Schedule Responsible Party MM-BIO-1. Prior to commencing construction-related activities on grassland or wetland habitat suitable to support California tiger salamander, the project shall obtain a CESA ITP from CDFW for impacts to California tiger salamander and comply with the ITP. Copies of the ITP shall be provided to the City prior to the commencement of construction-related activities. The project shall obtain authorization from USFWS for impacts to California tiger salamander and comply with the authorization. The project shall also provide habitat compensation for California tiger salamander in accordance with the ITP, SRP CS, and the USFWS’ Reinitiation of Formal Consultation on Issuance of Clean Water Act, Section 404 Permits by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers on the Santa Rosa Plain, Sonoma County, California (2020 PBO). Please note that the CESA ITP habitat compensation requirements are often consistent with the SRP CS and 2020 PBO but may differ based on site specific conditions. Prior to and during ground disturbance Project Applicant MM-BIO-2. Prior to ground disturbance, the project shall submit a wetland assessment and an evaluation of potential direct and indirect impacts to any on-site or adjacent off-site wetland habitat, such as modification of hydrological conditions or construction related sedimentation into occupied wetland habitat, to CDFW for review and obtain CDFW’s written acceptance of the assessment and evaluation. If direct or indirect impacts to potentially suitable wetlands for special- status plant species including, but not limited to, Sonoma sunshine, Sebastopol meadowfoam, and Burke’s goldfields may occur, the project shall submit to CDFW two years of completed botanical survey results and obtain CDFW’s written approval of the results prior to project construction. The botanical survey results should follow CDFW’s 2018 Protocols for Surveying and Evaluating Impacts to Special-Status Native Plant Populations and Sensitive Natural Communities (https://wildlife.ca.gov/Conservation/Survey-Protocols#377281280- plants) and the Santa Rosa Plain Conservation Strategy, Appendix D: Guidelines for Conducting and Reporting Botanical Inventories for Federally Listed Plants on the Santa Rosa Plain (https://www.fws.gov/library/collections/santa-rosa-plain-conservation- strategy). If CDFW is unable to accept the survey results, the project shall conduct additional surveys prior to initiation of project activities or may assume presence of special-status plants, such as Sonoma sunshine, Burke’s goldfields, and Sebastopol meadowfoam. Please be advised that for CDFW to accept the results, they should be completed Prior to and during ground disturbance Project Applicant DocusignEnvelopeID:0F20C610-18F1-4D59-B10A-40DF7C6BA3C0 2-29 Barry Miller City of Rohnert Park January 12, 2026 Page 16 in conformance with the above survey protocols and guidelines, including, but not limited to conducting surveys during appropriate conditions, utilizing appropriate reference sites, and evaluating all direct and indirect impacts such as altering off-site hydrological conditions where the above species may be present. Surveys should include the entire extent of any directly or indirectly impacted suitable wetland habitat, including portions of the wetland on adjacent parcels or not directly impacted, as impacts to part of a wetland often affects the entire wetland. Evaluation of indirect impacts may necessitate a thorough hydrological assessment that fully analyzes existing and post- project conditions to seasonal wetland habitat. Surveys conducted during drought conditions may not be acceptable. If the botanical surveys result in the detection of the above CESA listed plants that may be impacted by the project, or the presence of these species is assumed, the project shall obtain a CESA ITP from CDFW prior to construction and comply with all requirements of the ITP including, but not limited to providing habitat compensation. In addition, the project shall consult with the USFWS for any impacts to suitable habitat for plants listed under the Endangered Species Act (e.g., wetlands) and provide compensatory habitat mitigation as required. MM-BIO-3. If the project occurs during the burrowing owl wintering season from September 1 to January 31, prior to project activities a Qualified Biologist shall conduct a burrowing owl habitat assessment within 1,640 feet of the project area pursuant to the California Department of Fish and Game (now CDFW) 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (CDFW 2012 Staff Report, available here: https://wildlife.ca.gov/Conservation/Survey-Protocols#377281284- birds), unless otherwise approved in writing by CDFW. The Qualified Biologist shall have a minimum of two years of experience implementing the CDFW 2012 Staff Report habitat assessment and survey methodology. The habitat assessment shall focus on searching the CNDDB and potentially other sources for any burrowing owl records on or within one mile of the project area, vegetation type and height, suitable burrows (with an opening of >11 cm in diameter and a depth of >150 cm), burrow surrogates (culverts, piles of concrete rubble, piles of soil, burrows created along soft banks of ditches and canals, pipes, and similar structures), and presence of burrowing owl sign (tracks, molted feathers, cast pellets, prey remains, egg shell fragments, owl white wash, and nest burrow decoration material), and the presence of burrowing owl individuals or pairs. If the habitat assessment does not identify suitable habitat and surveys are not conducted as described below, an additional habitat assessment shall be conducted within 14 days prior to construction and if new potentially suitable burrowing owl refugia are present surveys shall be conducted as described below, unless otherwise approved in writing by CDFW. The results of the habitat assessment shall be emailed to CDFW and the project shall obtain CDFW’s written approval of the habitat assessment prior to starting project activities. If suitable burrowing owl habitat is observed, four surveys shall be conducted to detect the presence of burrowing owl pursuant to the Prior to and during ground disturbance Project Applicant DocusignEnvelopeID:0F20C610-18F1-4D59-B10A-40DF7C6BA3C0 2-30 Barry Miller City of Rohnert Park January 12, 2026 Page 17 CDFW 2012 Staff Report, and shall begin on August 1. The site visits shall be spread evenly throughout August and the non-breeding season, unless otherwise approved in writing by CDFW. The survey results shall be emailed to CDFW and the project shall obtain CDFW’s written approval of the survey results prior to starting project activities. In addition, a take avoidance survey shall be completed within 14 days prior to the start of construction, as described in the CDFW 2012 Staff Report. Time lapses of more than 14 days between project activities may trigger subsequent surveys including, but not limited to a final survey conducted within 24 hours prior to ground disturbance. If burrowing owl is detected, the project shall immediately notify CDFW. The project shall avoid impacts to the burrowing owl and implement a 1,640-foot buffer area around the owl site in which no project activities shall occur, unless otherwise approved in writing by CDFW. A Qualified Biologist or Biological Monitor shall monitor any detected owl to ensure it is not disturbed. If the surveys result in the detection of the burrowing owl that may be impacted by the project, or the presence of this species and impacts to it are assumed, the project shall obtain and comply with an ITP from CDFW. Habitat compensation for impacts to occupied wintering burrowing owl habitat (habitat known to have been occupied by wintering burrowing owl within the last 3 years) shall also be provided at a minimum 3:1 mitigation to impact ratio prior to project construction, unless otherwise approved by CDFW. Habitat mitigation shall include permanent preservation of high-quality burrowing owl wintering habitat through a conservation easement and implementing and funding a long-term management plan in perpetuity, to be finalized before project construction, unless otherwise approved in writing by CDFW. The burrowing owl mitigation plan shall be submitted to CDFW for approval before project construction and include a review of suitability of mitigation lands for burrowing owl as confirmed by a Qualified Biologist. The project shall obtain CDFW’s written approval of the burrowing owl mitigation plan. Please be advised that an ITP obtained for burrowing owl may have additional requirements to achieve full mitigation. MM-BIO-4. If construction, grading, vegetation removal, or other project-related activities are scheduled during the avian nesting season, February 1 to August 31, a Qualified Biologist shall conduct a survey for active bird nests within 7 days prior to the beginning of project-related activities. The survey shall cover the entire project area and a minimum 500-foot buffer or the distance necessary as determined by a Qualified Biologist. If a lapse in project-related work of 7 days or longer occurs, another survey shall be conducted before Project work can be reinitiated. If an active nest is found during surveys, the Qualified Biologist shall immediately notify CDFW and establish site- and species-specific no-work buffers to ensure the nest is not disturbed. The buffer distances shall be specified to protect the bird’s normal behavior to prevent nesting failure or abandonment and comply with Fish and Game Code section 3500 et seq. and the federal MBTA. Prior to and during ground disturbance Project Applicant DocusignEnvelopeID:0F20C610-18F1-4D59-B10A-40DF7C6BA3C0 2-31 Barry Miller City of Rohnert Park January 12, 2026 Page 18 Abnormal nesting behaviors which may cause reproductive harm include, but are not limited to, defensive flights/vocalizations directed towards project personnel, standing up from a brooding position, and flying away from the nest. The Qualified Biologist shall have authority to order the cessation of all nearby project activities if the nesting birds exhibit abnormal behavior which may cause reproductive failure (nest abandonment and loss of eggs and/or young) until an appropriate buffer is established. The Qualified Biologist shall monitor the behavior of the birds (adults and young, when present) at the nest site to ensure that they are not disturbed by project work. Nest monitoring shall continue during project work until the young have fully fledged (have completely left the nest site and are no longer being fed by the parents), as determined by the Qualified Biologist, unless otherwise approved in writing by CDFW. MM-BIO-5. The project shall submit an LSA notification for any direct on-site or indirect off-site impacts to streams or lakes. For project activities that may substantially alter the bed, bank, or channel of any streams (including ephemeral or intermittent streams), an LSA Notification shall be submitted to CDFW pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 1602 prior to project construction. If CDFW determines that a LSA Agreement is warranted, the project shall comply with all required measures in the LSA Agreement, including, but not limited to requirements to mitigate impacts to the streams and riparian habitat. Permanent impacts to the stream and associated riparian habitat shall be mitigated by restoration of riparian habitat at a 3:1 mitigation to impact ratio based on acreage and linear distance as close to the project area as possible and within the same watershed and year as the impact, unless otherwise approved in writing by CDFW. Temporary impacts shall be restored on-site in the same year as the impact. The project shall also consult with the Regional Water Quality Control Board and Army Corps of Engineers to impacts to waters such as streams, lakes, and wetlands, and obtain permits if necessary pursuant to the Clean Water Act and Porter Cologne Water Quality Control Act. Prior to and during ground disturbance Project Applicant MM-BIO-6. The Project shall implement restoration on-site or off-site to mitigate temporary or permanent impacts to sensitive natural communities at a minimum 1:1 (restore on-site temporary impacts) or 3:1 (permanent impacts) mitigation to impact ratio for acres and linear feet of impacts, and trees, if applicable, shall be replaced at an appropriate ratio based on size and species, and temporal habitat loss, or provide habitat compensation including permanent protection of habitat at the same ratio through a conservation easement and preparing and funding implementation of a long-term management plan, unless otherwise approved in writing by CDFW. Prior to and during ground disturbance Project Applicant DocusignEnvelopeID:0F20C610-18F1-4D59-B10A-40DF7C6BA3C0 2-32 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report Letter 3 COMMENTER: Erin Chappell, Regional Manager, California Department of Fish and Wildlife DATE: January 12, 2026 Response 3.1 The commenter provides a summary of the project, CDFW’s role, and regulatory requirements, including the California Endangered Species Act (CESA), lake and streambed alteration, raptors and other nesting birds, and California fully-protected species. This comment is noted. The EIR provides a summary of CESA, the California Fish and Game Code, the Migratory Bird Treaty Act, Natural Community Conservation Plans, and other regulatory requirements in Section 4.3.2, Regulatory Setting, and provides a summary of potential special-status and protect species that may be found in the project area in Section 4.3.1, Setting. Species with the potential to occur in the Plan Area are listed in Appendix D to the Draft EIR, including white-tailed kite. Section 4.3.1b, Special-Status Species, of the Draft EIR lists CESA listed species that are known to occur or may possibly be found in the Plan Area. Impact BIO-1, beginning on page 4.3-16 includes the following statement on page 4.3-17: “All development under the proposed project would be subject to the provisions of the various federal and State natural resources regulations (discussed in Section 4.3.1, Setting) and their respective permitting processes.” Mitigation Measure BIO-3, provided on page 4.3-20 of the Draft EIR, also includes the following requirement: “Further, consultation with the CDFW will be necessary in the event Crotch’s bumble bee was observed within a project site and an Incidental Take Permit, in accordance with the California Endangered Species Act, may be required prior to initiating any ground disturbance on the site.” Section 4.3.1a, Definitions, includes a description of wetlands and waters mapped by the National Wetland Inventory within the Plan Area. Impact BIO-2, beginning on page 4.3-21, includes the following statement on page 4.3-21: The issuance of a grading permit by the City Engineer for ministerial and discretionary projects requires obtaining other permits required by State or federal agencies. These include but are not limited to streambed alteration permits from the CDFW and permits for grading in the vicinity of wetlands and certain watercourses from the USACE. These permit clearances may also be required as conditions of approval for grading work to commence. Approval of permits also requires findings that the proposed grading will not result in erosion, stream sediment, or other adverse off-site effects to riparian habitat. Additionally, Section 4.3.1b Special-Status Habitats includes Drainages, wetlands and associated riparian vegetation under the jurisdiction of CDFW or the Regional Water Quality Control Board (RWQCB)as waters of the State or USACE (USACE) as waters of the U.S. These requirements noted in the Draft EIR address the concerns raised by the commenter regarding compliance with regulations and protection of special-status species. Response 3.2 The commenter recommends the creation of a checklist to evaluate expected project-specific biological resource impacts to determine if they are within the scope of the EIR or if additional environmental review is needed. The General Plan includes goals and policies that require project‑level biological resource evaluations be conducted, ensuring that future development undergoes the type of site‑specific analysis required by the CEQA Guidelines. In particular, Policy RC‑4.3: Biological Resource Assessment requires that future development occurring in or near sensitive biological resources be evaluated with a site-specific biological resource assessment. This policy ensures that special‑status species and sensitive habitats 2-33 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report are evaluated at the project level. Furthermore, General Plan policies RC‑4.1: Habitat Preservation, RC‑4.5: Special Status Species Protection and RC‑4.6: Active Construction Assessment, also protect special- status species by requiring the preservation of wetlands and sensitive habitats, protection of special- status species in cooperation with State and Federal agencies, and stop work requirements if any special- status species are discovered on an active construction area . Collectively, these policies establish a procedural framework for evaluating biological resources during City review of individual development projects. This framework serves the same function as a formal checklist; therefore, in this case a checklist is not necessary. Response 3.3 The commenter states that there may be deferred mitigation and provides three mitigation measures that would reduce potentially significant biological impacts. The commenter expresses concern related to potential impacts to California tiger salamander, Sonoma sunshine, Sebastopol meadowfoam, Burke’s goldfields, wetland habitat, and burrowing owl. Because the Draft EIR provides a programmatic analysis, it evaluates potential biological resource impacts at a broad scale based on existing regional data. It does not, and cannot, determine site‑specific effects for future individual development projects. Because a project-level analysis cannot be completed at this time for projects facilitated by the proposed General Plan in the future, Policy RC‑4.3: Biological Resource Assessment is included in the proposed General Plan, so that future development occurring in or near sensitive biological resources be evaluated with a site-specific biological resource assessment. These project‑level analyses will identify current site conditions, conduct appropriate surveys, and apply mitigation measures tailored to the specific resources present. These requirements ensure that future projects undergo detailed biological evaluation under current conditions and that any potentially significant impacts are fully addressed through project‑level CEQA review and inform the requirements for regulatory permitting. Accordingly, the Draft EIR accurately discloses the potential for significant impacts while relying on established tiering provisions to ensure appropriate future analysis. The proposed General Plan includes goals and policies (RC‑4.3: Biological Resource Assessment, RC‑4.1: Habitat Preservation, RC‑4.5: Special Status Species Protection and RC‑4.6: Active Construction Assessment) to conduct a project specific site assessment and avoid impacts to special-status species (including California tiger salamander, burrowing owl, Sonoma sunshine, Sebastopol meadowfoam, and Burke’s goldfield), and their habitats. The EIR also includes mitigation measures BIO-1, Pre-Construction Bird Surveys, Avoidance, and Notification; BIO-2, Roosting Bats; and BIO-3, Conduct Pre-construction Crotch’s Bumble Bee Surveys and Implement Avoidance Measures to protect nesting birds, roosting bats and Crotch’s bumble bee, which provide sufficient mitigation to protect these species during development of specific projects under the program EIR. Additionally, the proposed General Plan policy for a project specific site assessment (Policy RC-4.3) conducted by a qualified biologist at the time of project development is intended to allow for changing conservation strategies and agency recommendations, and the impact conclusion in Section 4.3.3 Impact Analysis, threshold 1 in the EIR is not solely reliant on the Santa Rosa Plain Conservation Strategy. The Draft EIR’s reliance on a tiered project‑level Biological Resources Assessment (Policy RC-3) is not improper deferral because the General Plan includes a clear, and enforceable policy requiring site‑specific biological evaluation for any future project with the potential to affect sensitive habitats or special‑status species. The EIR lists all species currently known to occur within the Plan Area which may be affected by projects facilitated by the General Plan. Because specific development sites and individual project designs are not yet known, project‑level impacts cannot be meaningfully disclosed at this stage. The General Plan’s requirement for a project‑level Biological Resources Assessment ensures that future projects will undergo site‑specific analysis under current conditions. Please refer to Response to Comment 3.1 regarding performance standards for CESA species. 2-34 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report The project‑level Biological Resources Assessment (Policy RC-3) would be prepared by a qualified biologist that establishes the existing resources present, potential impacts on the resources, and mitigation measures for these impacts. Any protocol level-survey requirements would be identified during this assessment and would follow the most current agency recommendations and industry standards at the time of the assessment. The commenter’s assertion that the future Biological Resources Assessments would not be conducted adequately is speculative. The commenter’s recommended example mitigation measures requiring an incidental take permit for California salamander; wetland assessment to be submitted to CDFW for review and evaluation of potential impacts to Sonoma sunshine, Sebastopol meadowfoam, and Burke’s goldfields, and subsequent incidental take permitting; and burrowing owl habitat assessment, protocol surveys and subsequent incidental take permitting; are noted. New mitigation measures and revisions to the Draft EIR are not required because the General Plan requires project-specific Biological Resources Assessments (Policy RC-3), which would identify existing resources present on an individual project site, potential impacts to the biological resources for a specific project, and mitigation measures for these impacts applicable to that project. Additionally, project-specific analysis would use CDFW recommendations, if applicable. Response 3.4 The commenter recommends the inclusion of a mitigation measure that addresses potential impacts to white-tailed kite and other nesting birds. The Draft EIR includes Mitigation Measure BIO-1: Pre-Construction Bird Surveys, Avoidance, and Notification, provided beginning on page 4.3-18 of the Draft EIR. This measure requires a nesting bird survey within a 500-foot buffer of an individual project site, where construction would occur during the nesting season (February 1 to August 31). The recommended mitigation measure MM-BIO-4 includes notifying CDFW for consultation on avoidance buffers if active nests are found during nesting bird surveys. CDFW does not have jurisdiction to approve, modify, or enforce buffer distances for nesting birds where the department does not have permitting authority over a project. CEQA requires mitigation measures to be fully enforceable by the lead agency, and measures that depend on approval or discretionary input from an outside agency without permitting authority are considered improper deferral and may not be enforceable. Mitigation Measure BIO-1 has been revised as follows: For construction activities initiated during the bird nesting season (February 1 – August 31) involving removal of vegetation or other nesting bird habitat, including abandoned structures and other manmade features, a pre-construction nesting bird survey shall be conducted no more than three days prior to initiation of ground disturbance and vegetation removal activities. If a lapse in project- related work of seven days or longer occurs, another survey shall be conducted before project work can be reinitiated. The nesting bird preconstruction survey shall be conducted on foot and shall include a 500-foot buffer around the construction site… This revision adds clarity and timing to the need for a follow-on nesting bird survey if work pauses during construction, and does not constitute a substantial change to the Draft EIR. Response 3.5 The commenter recommends the inclusion of two mitigation measures that address potentially significant impacts to riparian habitats, wetlands, and sensitive natural communities. As noted in Response 3.1, the Draft EIR acknowledges regulatory permitting would be required where projects would affect jurisdictional areas, including riparian habitats. Proposed General Plan policies under Goal RC-5 (To preserve, enhance, and restore creeks and riparian corridors), would also protect riparian habitats, as described in Impact BIO-2, beginning on page 4.3-21 of the Draft EIR. 2-35 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report New mitigation measures or revisions to Draft EIR are not required because proposed General Plan Policy RC-3 requires Biological Resources Assessment for individual development projects, which would require the identification of existing resources present on individual project sites, potential impacts to the identified resources, and mitigation measures for these impacts. Additionally, project-specific analysis would use CDFW recommendations, if applicable. Response 3.6 The commenter requests that any special-status species and natural communities detected during surveys be reported to the California Natural Diversity Database. This comment is noted. All special-status species and natural communities observed during surveys are listed in Appendix D, Potential to Occur Species Tables. In accordance with Public Resources Code Section 21003(e), qualified biologists that conduct future pre-construction surveys of individual project sites in the Plan Area will report special-status species and natural communities detected during project surveys to the California Natural Diversity Database. Response 3.7 The commenter notes that payment of filing fees will be required when filing the Notice of Determination for the EIR. This comment is noted. Should the City certify the Final EIR and approve the project, the City will pay filing fees as required. 2-36 City of Cotati Sonoma County, California ________________________________________________________________ 201 W. Sierra Ave, Cotati, CA 94931 | (707) 792-4600 | www.cotaticity.org | @cityofcotati January 15, 2026 Barry Miller, FAICP City of Rohnert Park, Planning Department 130 Avram Avenue, 2nd Floor Rohnert Park, CA 94928 RE: City of Cotati comments on the Draft EIR for the Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Dear Mr. Miller: Thank you for the opportunity to provide comments on Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) for the Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan, a project of area-wide significance under Section 15206 of CEQA. The primary concern of the City of Cotati continues to be the impact of development projects within the City of Rohnert Park on roadway and intersection function and safety within the City of Cotati. Ongoing development and expected buildout of Rohnert Park (most notably SOMO Village, the Southeast Specific Plan (Willowglen), and the University District) are causing significant impacts on the level of traffic congestion, Vehicle Miles Travelled (VMT), and Greenhouse Gas (GHG) emissions in Cotati. Further, the orderly evacuation of residents during times of emergency and/or the provision of emergency services via shared roadway and circulation networks has the potential to be similarly impacted by increased development and density. Obviously, these impacts are expected to worsen as development occurs without effective and timely mitigation. Unfortunately, the DEIR does not adequately analyze the potential impacts associated with this future development and as a result adequate mitigation is not proposed to address these impacts. The DEIR instead appears to rely on a single agreement between Rohnert Park and Cotati for a single project (SOMO Village) as adequate mitigation for these foreseeable and expected significant impacts within Cotati but does not provide analysis to support such a conclusion. The City of Cotati respectfully requests that the DEIR be revised to address the following: 1. The analysis should evaluate the proposed project's consistency with the Circulation Element of the City of Cotati's 2015 General Plan. According to Appendix G of the CEQA Guidelines, a project may have a significant transportation impact if it conflicts with an adopted program, plan, ordinance, or policy addressing the circulation system. The City of Cotati maintains policies designed to ensure safe and efficient operating conditions throughout the citywide roadway network. These include the use of Level of Service (LOS) standards and the requirement that new development projects fully mitigate their transportation impacts. Although the Draft EIR identifies East Cotati Avenue as a major arterial, it does not adequately analyze or address the project's potential impacts on Cotati roadways or its consistency with the City's adopted circulation-related programs and policies. 2. The analysis should evaluate Rohnert Park’s contribution to traffic impacts on Cotati roadways. A significant number of Rohnert Park residents travel through Cotati to and from U.S. Highway 101 and 4.3 4.2 4.1 Letter 4 2-37 Highway 116. This occurs particularly along Old Redwood Highway and increasingly via West Sierra Avenue and Commerce Boulevard. In addition, all residents in Rohnert Park’s L Section must use Cotati roadways to access their properties. Although this section of Rohnert Park was previously built out, it is now subject to potential increased development under SB 9 (allowing lot splits and duplexes), accessory dwelling unit (ADU) construction, and ABAG/MTC’s Transit-Oriented Communities (TOC) policies. These changes could generate additional traffic on Cotati’s roadways, significantly beyond levels anticipated in the draft EIR. The Draft EIR should thoroughly examine Rohnert Park’s contribution to traffic volumes on Cotati roadways and propose strategies to mitigate these impacts. Potential mitigation measures include: • Expansion and clarification of the Regional Traffic Impact Fee program (Policy C2.2) as needed to adequately mitigate for impacts associated with the growth anticipated and projected under the draft Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan. • Direct financial or in-kind contributions to roadway and intersection improvements within Cotati, such as the signal at East Cotati Avenue at La Salle and the signal at Old Redwood Highway at William/George Streets. • Support for bicycle and transit improvements to reduce vehicle dependency and address cumulative regional traffic effects, including enhanced and expanded access to the SMART stations serving Rohnert Park. 3. The analysis should be expanded to include adequate evacuation routes and emergency service vehicle access. Ensuring the safe, orderly and adequate evacuation of existing and future residents for both Rohnert park and Cotati is critical to the safety of residents and the orderly management of our communities emergency response. Taking a regional approach will help to ensure that inter-jurisdictional travel impacts are fully analyzed, adequate mitigation is identified and required and that Cotati’s circulation system remains safe and efficient. Again, thank you for the opportunity to comment on the DEIR for the Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan. City of Cotati staff look forward to working with Rohnert Park to mitigate the regional traffic impacts of the projected growth of the City of Rohnert Park and welcome an opportunity to meet to discuss how best to implement these measures. Sincerely, Noah Housh Community Development Director City of Cotati c: Damien O’Bid, Cotati City Manager Craig Scott, Cotati Director of Public Works/City Engineer 4.4 4.3 4.5 2-38 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report Letter 4 COMMENTER: Noah Housh, Community Development Director, City of Cotati DATE: January 15, 2026 Response 4.1 The commenter asserts that the DEIR does not adequately mitigate potential impacts for ongoing development and expected buildout of Rohnert Park that directly impacts the City of Cotati. The commenter asserts that the Draft EIR impact conclusions rely on a single agreement between Rohnert Park and Cotati for the SOMO Village project. This comment is related to the analysis of transportation impacts within the City of Cotati. The comment asserts that a significant CEQA transportation impact will occur due to traffic congestion. A subsequent comment includes a request that Level of Service (LOS) be analyzed. As per CEQA Guidelines Section 15064.3(a) “a project’s effect on automobile delay shall not constitute a significant environmental impact.” City of Cotati Circulation Element Policy CI 1.3 establishes a LOS policy based on intersection delay; however, per CEQA Guidelines Section 15064.3(a), the proposed General Plan’s effect on automobile delay shall not constitute a significant environmental impact. . The addition of project-related traffic to the Cotati roadway system does not constitute a geometric hazard because the 2040 General Plan does not modify the geometry of Cotati roadways or create an incompatible use as the types of vehicles to be generated by new development in Rohnert Park will follow a similar fleet mix as the rest of the background fleet mix. Emergency vehicles retain the ability to preempt traffic signals and bypass vehicles along Cotati roadways, and thus the adequacy of emergency vehicle access is not expected to be significantly impacted versus 2040 Current General Plan conditions. Vehicle miles traveled (VMT) impacts are addressed under Impact T-2, beginning on page 4.14-33 of the Draft EIR, and GHG emission impacts are addressed under Impact GHG-1, beginning on page 4.7-13 of the Draft EIR. VMT and GHG emissions analyses were based on outputs from the SCTA Travel Demand Model, as noted in the Draft EIR. Cumulative impacts were discussed throughout the Draft EIR, including as it relates to transportation and GHG emissions. The cumulative development scenario is described in Section 3.3, beginning on page 3-2 of the Draft EIR, and identifies specific projects identified in the City of Cotati, as well as regional trip estimates as contributing to the cumulative scenario. Cumulative GHG emission impacts are described under Section 4.7.4, beginning on page 4.7-18 of the Draft EIR. As stated therein, the proposed project would result in a considerable contribution to significant cumulative GHG emission impacts. Cumulative VMT impacts are described under Section 4.14.4, beginning on page 4.14-40 of the Draft EIR. As stated therein, the proposed project would result in a considerable contribution to significant cumulative VMT impacts but would not have a considerable contribution to cumulative roadway safety and emergency vehicle access impacts. The City of Rohnert Park is actively working with the City of Cotati to address traffic operations between both cities and potential fees, and will continue to meet regularly with Cotati staff to address the issues raised in the comment letter. Response 4.2 The commenter recommends the project must be evaluated for consistency with the City of Cotati’s 2015 Circulation Element in accordance with Appendix G of the CEQA Guidelines. The commenter asserts the project is not consistent with the City of Cotati’s adopted Circulation Element policies, operating conditions standards and requirements. 2-39 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report Transportation impacts are discussed in Section 4.14, Transportation, of the Draft EIR. Existing Traffic and Year 2040 Traffic Forecasting analysis was completed for East Cotati Avenue; please refer to Appendix C, Tables 5 and 6, of the Draft EIR. It should be noted that congestion (level of service or LOS) is no longer the metric by which transportation impacts are analyzed under CEQA; this is described on page 4.14-10 of the Draft EIR under Senate Bill 743. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15064.3(a) “a project’s effect on automobile delay shall not constitute a significant environmental impact.” City of Cotati Policy CI 1.3 establishes a LOS policy based on intersection delay; however, pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15064.3(a), the project’s effect on LOS shall not constitute a significant environmental impact. The addition of additional traffic generated by the project does not preclude the implementation of Cotati’s General Plan policies related to the circulation system. As noted in Response 4.1, the City of Rohnert Park intends to continue working with the City of Cotati to address traffic operations between both cities. Additionally, as noted in Table 4.14-2 on page 4.14-20 of the Draft EIR, the proposed General Plan includes goals and policies to maintain existing LOS and roadway operations, including Goal C-1, Policy C-1.4, and Policy C-1.5. Response 4.3 The commenter requests an evaluation of Rohnert Park’s traffic impacts on Cotati roadways and relevant highways. The commenter asserts that potentially impacted roadways are within close proximity of sites with potential for development based on local policies and state laws. Please refer to Response 4.2 regarding the CEQA findings of traffic impacts along City of Cotati roadways. Section 2.3.2, General Plan Buildout, of the Draft EIR states: Development projections for the 2040 General Plan were determined by analyzing vacant and underutilized parcels within the City and the reasonable level of development potential that is allowed under the applicable land use designation factoring for known physical and/or regulatory requirements. Most of the future development capacity in Rohnert Park is within specific plan areas, planned developments, and two Priority Development Areas. Development capacity in the rest of the city will be through strategic infill sites. The Draft EIR evaluates reasonably anticipated growth from the proposed project through 2040 and is not a maximum buildout analysis; therefore, it is reasonable to not count potential additional units under SB 9 and ADUs. Response 4.4 The commenter requests an examination of Rohnert Park’s traffic volumes on Cotati and suggests mitigation measures for potential impacts. The proposed mitigation measures support clarification on Policy C2.2, financial contributions for Cotati intersections, and bikeway and transit improvements. Please refer to Response 4.2 regarding the CEQA findings of traffic impacts along City of Cotati roadways. Proposed Policy C-2.2 states: Policy C-2.2: Coordinate with Neighboring Jurisdictions on Regional Improvements. The City shall continue to collect regional traffic mitigation fees and collaborate with adjacent jurisdictions to fund Rohnert Park’s proportional share of regional traffic improvements. The City’s proportional share payment shall be provided when established criteria that ensure construction of improvements have been met. 2-40 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report The commenter’s request to expand this policy is noted; however, this policy already requires coordination with neighboring jurisdictions, such as the City of Cotati, and addresses regional traffic improvements. The commenter’s request for financial contributions for City of Cotati intersection improvements is noted, and addressed by proposed Policy C-2.2. The proposed project supports bikeway and transit improvement projects through proposed Circulation Element Goal C-6 and Policies C-6.1 to C-6.11, which support bicycle infrastructure improvements that reduce vehicle dependency. These policies are provided in Table 4.14-3, beginning on page 4.14-25 of the Draft EIR. For a detailed map of existing and planned bicycle facilities refer to Figure 4.14-2 on page 4.14- 5 of the Draft EIR. The proposed project supports traffic reductions and transit improvements through proposed Circulation Element Policies C-8.2, C-8.3, and C-9.1. These policies are provided in Table 4.14-2 on page 4.14-23 of the Draft EIR. Response 4.5 The commenter requests the analysis include adequate information pertaining to evacuation routes, emergency service vehicle access at a regional level. The commenter urges the regional analysis to provide adequate mitigation and provide consistency with the City of Cotati’s Circulation Element. As noted in Policy HS-2.1 and Implementation Program HS-A, the City intends to undertake an AB 747 and SB 99 evacuation study and constraints analysis, which could include participation in a regional or subregional evacuation study. Other policies are related to emergency planning, management, access and education, as well as enforcing the maintenance of an emergency response plan. The project would also not facilitate urban development within the Fire Hazard Severity Zone. Impacts of the 2040 General Plan to emergency response plans or emergency evacuation plans were analyzed in Impact WFR-1, beginning on page 4.17-11 of the Draft EIR. Additionally, the City of Rohnert Park recently partnered with County of Sonoma in the Multi-Jurisdictional Local Hazard Mitigation Plan (LHMP) which is scheduled to be completed in 2026. The anticipated LHMP will contain adequate information on regional evacuation routes and emergency service vehicle access. The 2018 City of Rohnert Park LHMP contains adequate information pertaining to the evacuation routes. Please refer to LHMP Figure 3.1. 2-41 www.santarosaplaingroundwater.org January 16, 2026 Barry Miller, FAICP City of Rohnert Park Planning Department 130 Avram Avenue Rohnert Park, CA 94928 RE: City of Rohnert Park General Plan 2040 and Draft Environmental Impact Report Comment Letter from the Santa Rosa Plain Groundwater Sustainability Agency Thank you for the opportunity to provide input on the Rohnert Park Draft General Plan 2040 and Draft Environmental Impact Report (EIR), in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). Groundwater Sustainability Agencies (GSAs), formed under California's Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA), play a crucial role in managing local groundwater resources. The Santa Rosa Plain basin is a medium priority basin and is regulated by SGMA. The Santa Rosa Plain GSA was established in 2017, and the City is a member agency of the GSA through a Joint Powers Agreement. Since the GSA’s establishment, the City and GSA have had a positive and close working relationship. Together with our member agencies and partners, the GSA is dedicated to managing the groundwater basin for sustainably. Land use policies and zoning designations will influence land use decisions and future growth and are therefore interconnected with overall water demand and groundwater management. The Department of Water Resources has approved a Groundwater Sustainability Plan (GSP) for the Santa Rosa Plain sub-basin. The GSP can be accessed here, https://santarosaplaingroundwater.org/gsp/ and should be reviewed to ensure the city's updated General Plan aligns with the goals and objectives of the GSP. The most recent groundwater conditions and a status summary of the GSA’s programs and initiatives are described in the Water Year 2024 Annual Report, which can be accessed here: https://santarosaplaingroundwater.org/wp-content/uploads/1- 055_WY_2024-FINAL_ADA.pdf We appreciate the inclusion of General Plan policies promoting conjunctive use water supply management, water use efficiencies, groundwater sustainability, and Board of Directors Susan Harvey City of Cotati, Chair John Nagle Sonoma RCD, Vice-Chair Emily Sanborn City of Rohnert Park Elias Zegarra Gold Ridge RCD Lynda Hopkins Sonoma Water Evan Jacobs Independent Water Systems Sam Salmon Town of Windsor Mark Stapp City of Santa Rosa Neysa Hinton City of Sebastopol Chris Coursey County of Sonoma Letter 5 5.2 5.1 2-42 www.santarosaplaingroundwater.org groundwater recharge and stormwater infiltration. We request that the City consider adding the following policies to General Plan 2040 to reinforce an aligned commitment to sustainable groundwater management and regional collaboration. 1. Policy regarding growth and groundwater demand: The City will review the DWR-approved Groundwater Sustainability Plan (GSP) to ensure that land use and growth assumptions in the General Plan and subsequent amendments are consistent with the 50-year water demand projections in the DWR-approved GSP and that projected groundwater demand will not exceed GSP sustainable management criteria or result in undesirable results in accordance with the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA). 2. Policies regarding regional collaboration: The City shall continue to support cooperative, regional groundwater management planning by local water agencies, water users, and other affected parties to ensure a sustainable, adequate, safe, and economically viable groundwater supply for existing and future uses within the City. The City shall coordinate with the Santa Rosa Plain Groundwater Sustainability Agency, Sonoma County Water Agency, and other appropriate agencies to monitor groundwater resources and to update the Groundwater Sustainability Plan to included policies, programs, and regulations for preserving and enhancing the watershed and surface and groundwater resources. 3. Policies regarding GSP implementation, funding and actions: The City shall cooperate with the Santa Rosa Plain Groundwater Sustainability Agency in planning and implementing programs and projects that improve regional water supply resilience and achieve and maintain groundwater sustainability, consistent with the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act. The City shall coordinate with the Santa Rosa Plain Groundwater Sustainability Agency in seeking any available state or federal assistance to support local groundwater management programs. The City will use its regulatory authority, as appropriate, to implement the requirements of the Groundwater Sustainability Plan. We appreciate the City’s close collaboration on planning and implementing groundwater sustainability programs. Continued coordination helps ensure that local land-use planning decisions support groundwater sustainability goals and minimizes potential conflicts. Thank you for the opportunity to provide input on the Rohnert Park 2024 Draft and EIR. If you have any questions or would like to discuss these comments, please reach out to Andy Rodgers, GSA Administrator, arodgers@santarosaplaingroundwater.org. Sincerely, Andy Rodgers, Administrator Santa Rosa Plain Groundwater Sustainability Agency 5.2 2-43 www.santarosaplaingroundwater.org Marcus Trotta, Plan Manager Santa Rosa Plain Groundwater Sustainability Agency 2-44 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report Letter 5 COMMENTER: Andy Rodgers, Administrator, and Marcus Trotta, Plan Manager, Santa Rosa Plain Groundwater Sustainability Agency DATE: January 16, 2026 Response 5.1 The commenter recommends the Groundwater Sustainability Plan for the Santa Rosa Plain subbasin and 2024 Water Year Annual Report be reviewed for consistency with the proposed General Plan update. The Santa Rosa Plan Groundwater Sustainability Agency (GSA) and associated Groundwater Sustainability Plan (GSP) are discussed beginning on page 4.9-14 of the Draft EIR. The following text has been added to the regulatory setting of the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act, on page 4.9-13 of the Draft EIR: The Santa Rosa Plain GSA provides annual reporting, developed with guidance and recommendations based on California Department of Water Resources Groundwater Sustainability Plan (GSP) and SGMA legislation. The annual report provides an update on hydrogeologic setting, groundwater subbasin status, and GSP implementation progress. This additional information pertains to the purpose of the GSA Water Annual Report, and this revision does not constitute a substantial change to the Draft EIR. The consistency of the proposed project with the established GSP is addressed under Impact HWQ-5, beginning on page 4.9-26. As noted therein, future development facilitated by the project must be consistent with 2040 General Plan goals and policies, and must adhere to state and local regulations. Impact HWQ-5 concluded that impacts were less than significant. Response 5.2 The commenter requests three policies regarding growth and groundwater demand, regional collaboration, and GSP implementation be added to the General Plan update. The City has considered the commenter’s requested additional policies related to sustainable groundwater management and regional collaboration, and has added the policies into the proposed General Plan as Policy PFS-3.10 (Agency Coordination), Policy PFS-3.11 (Groundwater Sustainability), and Program PFS-V (Review Groundwater Sustainability Plan) in the Public Facilities and Services Element. The additional policies and program are listed below, and have also been added to the discussion of groundwater sustainability provided under Impact HWQ-2 on page 4.9-19 and Impact U-2 beginning on page 4.16-15 of the Draft EIR. Policy PFS-3.10: Agency Coordination. The City shall coordinate with the Santa Rosa Plain Groundwater Sustainability Agency, Sonoma County Water Agency, and other appropriate agencies to monitor groundwater resources and to update the Groundwater Sustainability Plan to included policies, programs, and regulations for preserving and enhancing the watershed and surface and groundwater resources. Policy PFS-3.11: Groundwater Sustainability. The City shall cooperate with the Santa Rosa Plain Groundwater Sustainability Agency in planning and implementing programs and projects that improve regional water supply resilience and achieve and maintain groundwater sustainability, consistent with the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act. Program PFS-V: Review Groundwater Sustainability Plan. The City will review the DWR-approved Groundwater Sustainability Plan (GSP) every five years to ensure that land use and growth assumptions in the General Plan and subsequent amendments are consistent with the 50-year water 2-45 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report demand projections in the DWR-approved GSP and that projected groundwater demand will not exceed GSP sustainable management criteria or result in undesirable results in accordance with the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA). Related policies: PFS-3.10, Agency Coordination; PFS-3.11, Groundwater Sustainability Responsible Department: Public Works Timing: 2026-2030. 2031-2035, 2036-2040 2-46 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report Public Hearing Comments DATE: December 11, 2025, Planning Commission Hearing Response PH1 Commenters expressed concern about the Business Park designation in the northeast corner of the city. This comment has been noted and passed on to decision-makers for consideration. The potential environmental impacts of the proposed Business Park land use designations are discussed throughout the Draft EIR. In addition, Section 6, Alternatives, of the Draft EIR, considered project alternatives that would reduce the Business Park land use designations in the northeast portion of the city; in particular, refer to the discussions of Alternative 2, Environmental Conservation, beginning on page 6-11 of the Draft EIR, and Alternative 4, “Missing Middle Housing” West of Highway 101, beginning on page 6-26 of the Draft EIR. Response PH2 Commenters expressed a desire to see more opportunities for single-story single family homes. This comment has been noted and passed on to decision-makers for consideration. The proposed project anticipates the future development of 3,022 single family residential units, as specified in Table 2-1 on page 2-7 of the Draft EIR. As described in Table 2-2, beginning on page 2-11 of the Draft EIR, single-family residential developments are allowed in the following land use designations: Rural Estate Residential, Estate Residential, Low Density Residential, Medium Density Residential, and High Density Residential. As demonstrated on Figure 2-4 on page 2-6 of the Draft EIR, these land use designations allowing for single family development are provided throughout the city as part of the proposed project. For more information, please refer to the Draft EIR Section 2, Project Description, and Section 4.10, Land Use and Planning. Furthermore, Impact PH-1 on page 4.12-5 states: The State requires that all local governments adequately plan to meet the housing needs of their communities (HCD 2021). Given that the State is currently in an ongoing housing crisis due to an insufficient housing supply, the additional units under the proposed project would further assist in addressing the existing crisis and meeting the housing needs of the City’s communities. Therefore, the residential units anticipated to be developed as facilitated by the proposed project address identified housing needs. 2-47 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Responses to Comments on the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report This page intentionally left blank. 2-48 Revisions to the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report 3-1 3 Revisions to the Draft EIR This chapter presents specific text changes made to the Draft EIR since its publication and public review. The changes are presented in the order in which they appear in the original Draft EIR and are identified by the Draft EIR page number. Text deletions are shown in strikethrough, and text additions are shown in underline. The information contained within this chapter clarifies and expands on information in the Draft EIR and does not constitute “significant new information” requiring recirculation. (See Public Resources Code Section 21092.1; CEQA Guidelines Section 15088.5.) 3.1 Revisions to the Draft EIR Executive Summary Page ES-5, Table ES-1, revised row only: Impact Mitigation Measure(s) Residual Impact Biological Resources Impact BIO-1. Development facilitated by the proposed project would have the potential to modify habitat that could affect special-status species during construction and operation. Impacts would be less than significant with mitigation. BIO-1 Pre-Construction Bird Surveys, Avoidance, and Notification For construction activities initiated during the bird nesting season (February 1 – August 31) involving removal of vegetation or other nesting bird habitat, including abandoned structures and other manmade features, a pre-construction nesting bird survey shall be conducted no more than three days prior to initiation of ground disturbance and vegetation removal activities. If a lapse in project-related work of seven days or longer occurs, another survey shall be conducted before project work can be reinitiated. The nesting bird preconstruction survey shall be conducted on foot and shall include a 500-foot buffer around the construction site… Less than significant with mitigation Section 4.3, Biological Resources Page 4.3-18, Mitigation Measure BIO-1: For construction activities initiated during the bird nesting season (February 1 – August 31) involving removal of vegetation or other nesting bird habitat, including abandoned structures and other manmade features, a pre-construction nesting bird survey shall be conducted no more than three days prior to initiation of ground disturbance and vegetation removal activities. If a lapse in project- related work of seven days or longer occurs, another survey shall be conducted before project work can be reinitiated. The nesting bird preconstruction survey shall be conducted on foot and shall include a 500-foot buffer around the construction site… Section 4.9, Hydrology and Water Quality Page 4.9-13, Sustainable Groundwater Management Act: The Santa Rosa Plain GSA provides annual reporting, developed with guidance and recommendations based on California Department of Water Resources Groundwater Sustainability Plan (GSP) and City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 3-2 SGMA legislation. The annual report provides an update on hydrogeologic setting, groundwater subbasin status, and GSP implementation progress. Page 4.9-19, Impact HWQ-2: Policy PFS-3.2: Groundwater Management. The City shall continue to: locally manage groundwater pumping consistent with its Water Policy Resolution; prohibit the construction of new private wells in the City; require the abandonment of existing private wells as a condition of development and comply with the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act. Policy PFS-3.10: Agency Coordination. The City shall coordinate with the Santa Rosa Plain Groundwater Sustainability Agency, Sonoma County Water Agency, and other appropriate agencies to monitor groundwater resources and to update the Groundwater Sustainability Plan to included policies, programs, and regulations for preserving and enhancing the watershed and surface and groundwater resources. Policy PFS -3.11: Groundwater Sustainability. The City shall cooperate with the Santa Rosa Plain Groundwater Sustainability Agency in planning and implementing programs and projects that improve regional water supply resilience and achieve and maintain groundwater sustainability, consistent with the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act. Program PFS-V: Review Groundwater Sustainability Plan. The City will review the DWR-approved Groundwater Sustainability Plan (GSP) every five years to ensure that land use and growth assumptions in the General Plan and subsequent amendments are consistent with the 50-year water demand projections in the DWR-approved GSP and that projected groundwater demand will not exceed GSP sustainable management criteria or result in undesirable results in accordance with the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA). Section 4.14, Transportation and Traffic Page 4.9-11, State of California and Caltrans Regarding Complete Streets: Caltrans Director’s Policy 37 Deputy Directive 64-R1 Complete Streets – Integrating the Transportation System In 2021, Caltrans adopted Director’s Policy 37, prioritizing complete streets throughout the district. The policy states: The California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) recognizes that walking, biking, transit, and passenger rail are integral to our vision of delivering a brighter future for all through a world- class transportation network. Additionally, Caltrans recognizes that streets are not only used for transportation but are also valuable community spaces. Accordingly, in locations with current and/or future pedestrian, bicycle, or transit needs, all transportation projects funded or overseen by Caltrans will provide comfortable, convenient, and connected complete streets facilities for people walking, biking, and taking transit or passenger rail unless an exception is documented and approved. When decisions are made not to include complete streets elements in capital and maintenance projects, the justification will be documented with final approval by the responsible District Director. Opportunities for complete streets exist in all phases of project development from planning and design to construction, operations, and maintenance. Complete streets projects should prioritize underserved communities that have been historically harmed and segmented by the transportation network and should serve people of all ages and abilities. Furthermore, Caltrans commits to removing unnecessary policy and procedural barriers and partnering with communities and agencies to ensure projects on local and state transportation systems improve the connectivity to existing and planned pedestrian, bicycle, and transit facilities, and accessibility to existing and planned destinations, where possible. Revisions to the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report 3-3 In 2001, Caltrans adopted Deputy Directive 64; a policy directive related to non-motorized travel throughout the State. In October 2008, Deputy Directive 64 was strengthened to reflect changing priorities and challenges. Deputy Directive 64-R1 states: The Department views all transportation improvements as opportunities to improve safety, access, and mobility for all travelers in California and recognizes bicycle, pedestrian, and transit modes as integral elements of the transportation system. Providing safe mobility for all users, including motorists, bicyclists, pedestrians and transit riders, contributes to the Department's mission/vision: "Improving Mobility across California.” Successful long-term implementation of this directive is intended to result in more options for people to go from one place to another, less traffic congestion and greenhouse gas emissions, more walkable communities (with healthier, more active people), and fewer barriers for older adults, children, and people with disabilities. Page 4.9-12, preceding Section c., Regional and Local Regulations: Caltrans Director’s Policy 40 Transit Director’s Policy 40, a policy regarding public transit, was adopted by Caltrans in February of 2026. The policy reads: Public transit provides vital mobility to many Californians daily, central to powering our state’s society and economy. As outlined in the Director’s Complete Streets Policy DP-37, it is California Department of Transportation (Caltrans') organizational priority to encourage and maximize transit as a strategy to not only meet state climate, health, equity, and environmental outcomes but also to foster socially and economically vibrant, thriving, and resilient communities. Furthermore, public transit use results in significant safety benefits for all road users and aid California to achieve its goal of eliminating fatalities and serious injuries, as outlined in Director’s Road Safety Policy DP-36 and the Secretary’s Policy 01-25 on Road Safety. The policy requires Caltrans to establish metrics to evaluate and measure the performance and need for transit, increase engagement related to transit services, and improve planning and operational analysis for transit. Caltrans Bay Area Transit Plan The Caltrans Bay Area Transit Plan (2025) identifies deficiencies and potential improvements to increase transit reliability and access, and encourage more transit use along the State Transportation Network in the Bay Area. The City of Rohnert Park is identified in the plan as containing equity priority communities. The plan includes goals, objectives and performance measures, including for the provision of complete streets, equity in transportation choices, decreasing VMT, and supporting long- term transit projects. Caltrans District 4 Pedestrian Plan Caltrans’ District 4 Pedestrian Plan identifies and prioritizes pedestrian needs along and across the State Highway System to inform future investments. The Plan notes that pedestrians are prohibited on Highway 101 through the City of Rohnert Park, and thus does not include plans for pedestrian improvements along the segment of Highway 101 in the Plan Area. Caltrans District 4 Bike Plan The Caltrans District 4 Bike Plan identifies infrastructure improvements that can enhance bicycle safety and mobility throughout District 4 and remove some of the barriers to bicycling in the region. The Plan notes that bicyclists are prohibited on Highway 101 through the City of Rohnert Park, and City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 3-4 thus does not include plans for bicycle improvements along the segment of Highway 101 in the Plan Area. Page 4.9-19, Table 4.14-1, revised rows only: Caltrans Directives Project Consistency Caltrans Deputy Directive 64- R1Complete Streets – Integrating the Transportation System. The Department views all transportation improvements as opportunities to improve safety, access, and mobility for all travelers in California and recognizes bicycle, pedestrian, and transit modes as integral elements of the transportation system. Providing safe mobility for all users, including motorists, bicyclists, pedestrians and transit riders, contributes to the Department's mission/vision: "Improving Mobility across California.” Caltrans Director’s Policy 37 Complete Streets. In locations with current and/or future pedestrian, bicycle, or transit needs, all transportation projects funded or overseen by Caltrans will provide comfortable, convenient, and connected complete streets facilities for people walking, biking, and taking transit or passenger rail unless an exception is documented and approved. Complete streets projects should prioritize underserved communities that have been historically harmed and segmented by the transportation network and should serve people of all ages and abilities. Consistent. The City’s Circulation Element includes a specific focus on complete streets. Applicable goals and policies include: • Goal C-4: To support the ongoing development of an integrated transportation network that allows safe and convenient travel along and across streets for all users, including pedestrians, bicyclists, persons with disabilities, motorists, movers of commercial goods, users and operators of public transportation, seniors, youth, and families. • Policy C-4.1: Streets for All Users. The City shall ensure that streets safely serve seniors, youth, those with disabilities, and all members of the community, and provide a network connecting residences, employment areas, services, health care facilities, schools, parks, retail areas, and public facilities. • Policy C-4.2: New Streets Designed as Complete Streets. The City shall design local streets to accommodate all street users with comfortable pedestrian environments as the priority, including street tree planting between the street and sidewalk, minimized curb cuts, sidewalks on both sides of streets, and low impact development features, where feasible Directors Policy 40: Transit. Public transit provides vital mobility to many Californians daily, central to powering our state’s society and economy. As outlined in the Director’s Complete Streets Policy DP-37, it is California Department of Transportation (Caltrans') organizational priority to encourage and maximize transit as a strategy to not only meet state climate, health, equity, and environmental outcomes but also to foster socially and economically vibrant, thriving, and resilient communities. Furthermore, public transit use results in significant safety benefits for all road users and aid California to achieve its goal of eliminating fatalities and serious injuries, as outlined in Director’s Road Safety Policy DP-36 and the Secretary’s Policy 01-25 on Road Safety. Consistent. The City’s Circulation Element includes goals and policies that prioritize the provision of transit services, including: • Goal C-2: To coordinate with regional agencies on transportation improvements outside the city limits. • Goal C-4 (reproduced above). • Policy C-4.1 (reproduced above). • Policy C-4.2 (reproduced above). • Goal C-5: To encourage alternative travel modes, including transit, driving, biking, and walking by improving the multimodal circulation system • Policy C-5.1: Multimodal Network Strategy and Prioritization. The City shall identify and prioritize components of a multimodal network to increase continuity between pedestrian routes, bicycle routes, and public transit. • Goal C-8: Facilitate transit improvements and connections to create better connections to destinations around the city and between travel modes. • Policy C-8.1: Transit Access. The City shall work with transit providers and private developers and regional partners to improve transit access as follows: Revisions to the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report 3-5 Caltrans Directives Project Consistency o Develop well-designed accessible pick-up and drop-off locations and provide benches, shelters and amenities as appropriate o Focus transit service along corridors to maintain a level of service that is meaningful to the community o Work with paratransit providers to ensure Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) compliant paratransit services are available to eligible residents and visiting clients o Support last-mile solutions (e.g., shuttle service, shared- mobility services, proximity to pedestrian and bicycle path connections) to connect public transit riders to their ultimate destinations. o Encourage transit providers to have adequate bike racks on buses and rail cars to allow for convenient mode transitions for bicyclists. • Policy C-8.2: Regional Transit Connections. The City shall coordinate with SMART, Sonoma County Transit, and Golden Gate Transit to increase public transit service between Rohnert Park and other cities in the Bay Area and to coordinate: o Multi-modal connections for regional trips, o Transit service or infrastructure improvements, o Closure of transit gaps, and o Deployment of information and schedules with real-time information. • Goal C-9: Encourage transit ridership to support a sustainable transportation system. • Policy C-9.1: Maintain and Expand Transit Service. The City shall support levels of transit service that are adequate to meet and encourage ridership demand and work with service providers to adjust train schedules and bus routes to address new potential markets and levels of demand. • Policy C-9.2: Development Designed to Support Transit. The City shall support land use plans and building design that prioritizes higher intensity development close to transit, active frontages, space for bus stop amenities, and safety for people. Caltrans Bay Area Transit Plan and Transit Needs Assessment. The plan includes goals, objectives and performance measures, including for the provision of complete streets, equity in transportation choices, decreasing VMT, and supporting long-term transit projects. Consistent. The City’s Circulation Element includes a specific focus on complete streets. Applicable goals and policies include: • Goal C-4 (reproduced above). • Policy C-4.1 (reproduced above). • Policy C-4.2 (reproduced above). The City’s Racial Social and Environmental Justice Element includes policies regarding the equitable provision of services, including: • Policy RSEJ-4.2 (reproduced above). • Policy RSEJ-4.3 (reproduced above). • Policy RSEJ-5.4 (reproduced above). The City’s Circulation Element includes goals and policies regarding VMT, including: City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 3-6 Caltrans Directives Project Consistency • Goal C-3: To reduce automobile dependency and associated impacts. • Policy C-3.1: Regional VMT Mitigation Bank. The City shall encourage and support the Sonoma County Transportation Authority (SCTA) in establishing a regional VMT mitigation bank and/or regional VMT impact fee program that can be used to fund effective VMT reduction strategies at a regional level, while also establishing a mechanism for private development to offset their VMT impacts. • Policy C-3.2: Development Review Requirements for Vehicle Miles Traveled. The City shall, as part of development project CEQA review, require new development projects to achieve a reduction in vehicle miles traveled (VMT) compared to baseline conditions. The City will support SCTA’s efforts in maintaining the regional travel demand model, which will be used to adjust baseline VMT levels over time and allow the City to establish updated VMT benchmarks for project applicants. • Policy C-5.2: Promote Multimodal Mixed-Use Developments. The City shall promote the development of multimodal mixed-use development. • Policy C-6.3: Bike and Pedestrian Crossings in Central Rohnert Park. The City shall continue to study the feasibility of separated bicycle pedestrian crossings, including crossings over Rohnert Park Expressway at the SMART Multi- Use Path and work with Caltrans, SCTA and SMART to implement feasible projects. The City’s Circulation Element includes goals and policies regarding the provision of transit services, including: • Goal C-5 (reproduced above). • Policy C-5.1 (reproduced above). • Goal C-8: Facilitate transit improvements and connections to create better connections to destinations around the city and between travel modes. • Policy C-8.1: Transit Access. The City shall work with transit providers and private developers and regional partners to improve transit access as follows: o Develop well-designed accessible pick-up and drop-off locations and provide benches, shelters and amenities as appropriate o Focus transit service along corridors to maintain a level of service that is meaningful to the community o Work with paratransit providers to ensure Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) compliant paratransit services are available to eligible residents and visiting clients o Support last-mile solutions (e.g., shuttle service, shared- mobility services, proximity to pedestrian and bicycle path connections) to connect public transit riders to their ultimate destinations. o Encourage transit providers to have adequate bike racks on buses and rail cars to allow for convenient mode transitions for bicyclists. • Policy C-8.2: Regional Transit Connections. The City shall coordinate with SMART, Sonoma County Transit, and Golden Revisions to the Draft EIR Final Environmental Impact Report 3-7 Caltrans Directives Project Consistency Gate Transit to increase public transit service between Rohnert Park and other cities in the Bay Area and to coordinate: o Multi-modal connections for regional trips, o Transit service or infrastructure improvements, o Closure of transit gaps, and o Deployment of information and schedules with real-time information. • Goal C-9: Encourage transit ridership to support a sustainable transportation system. • Policy C-9.1: Maintain and Expand Transit Service. The City shall support levels of transit service that are adequate to meet and encourage ridership demand and work with service providers to adjust train schedules and bus routes to address new potential markets and levels of demand. • Policy C-9.2: Development Designed to Support Transit. The City shall support land use plans and building design that prioritizes higher intensity development close to transit, active frontages, space for bus stop amenities, and safety for people. Section 4.16, Utilities and Service Systems Page 4.16-17, Impact U-2: Policy PFS-3.8: Water Efficiency in Existing Buildings. The City shall encourage renovation of existing buildings to achieve higher levels of water efficiency beyond what is required in the City’s building code. Policy PFS-3.10: Agency Coordination. The City shall coordinate with the Santa Rosa Plain Groundwater Sustainability Agency, Sonoma County Water Agency, and other appropriate agencies to monitor groundwater resources and to update the Groundwater Sustainability Plan to included policies, programs, and regulations for preserving and enhancing the watershed and surface and groundwater resources. Policy PFS -3.11: Groundwater Sustainability. The City shall cooperate with the Santa Rosa Plain Groundwater Sustainability Agency in planning and implementing programs and projects that improve regional water supply resilience and achieve and maintain groundwater sustainability, consistent with the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act. Program PFS-V: Review Groundwater Sustainability Plan. The City will review the DWR-approved Groundwater Sustainability Plan (GSP) every five years to ensure that land use and growth assumptions in the General Plan and subsequent amendments are consistent with the 50-year water demand projections in the DWR-approved GSP and that projected groundwater demand will not exceed GSP sustainable management criteria or result in undesirable results in accordance with the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA). 3.2 Revisions to Draft EIR Appendices No revisions to Draft EIR Appendices have been made. City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 3-8 This page intentionally left blank. Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program Final Environmental Impact Report 4-1 4 Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program CEQA requires that a reporting or monitoring program be adopted for the conditions of project approval that are necessary to mitigate or avoid significant effects on the environment (Public Resources Code 21081.6). This mitigation monitoring and reporting program is intended to track and ensure compliance with adopted mitigation measures during the project implementation phase. For each mitigation measure recommended in the Final Environmental Impact Report (Final EIR), specifications are made herein that identify the action required, the monitoring that must occur, and the agency or department responsible for oversight. City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 4-2 This page intentionally left blank. Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program Final Environmental Impact Report 4-3 Mitigation Measure/ Condition of Approval Action Required Timing Monitoring Frequency Responsible Agency Compliance Verification Initial Compliance Verification Date Compliance Verification Comments Biological Resources BIO-1 Pre-Construction Bird Surveys, Avoidance, and Notification For construction activities initiated during the bird nesting season (February 1 – August 31) involving removal of vegetation or other nesting bird habitat, including abandoned structures and other manmade features, a pre-construction nesting bird survey shall be conducted no more than three days prior to initiation of ground disturbance and vegetation removal activities. If a lapse in project- related work of seven days or longer occurs, another survey shall be conducted before project work can be reinitiated. The nesting bird preconstruction survey shall be conducted on foot and shall include a 500-foot buffer around the construction site. The survey shall be conducted by a biologist familiar with the identification of avian species known to occur in northern California Bay Area communities (i.e., qualified biologist). If nests are found, an avoidance buffer shall be determined by a qualified biologist dependent upon the species, the proposed work activity, and existing disturbances associated with land uses outside of the site, which shall be demarcated by the biologist with bright orange construction fencing, flagging, construction lathe, or other means to demarcate the boundary. All construction personnel shall be notified as to the existence of the buffer zone and to avoid entering the buffer zone during the nesting season. No ground disturbing activities shall occur within the buffer until the biologist has confirmed that breeding/ nesting is completed, and the young have fledged the nest. Encroachment into the buffer shall occur only at the discretion of the qualified biologist on the basis that the encroachment will not be detrimental to an active nest. A report summarizing the pre-construction survey(s) shall be prepared by a qualified biologist and shall be submitted to the City prior to the commencement of construction activities. Proposed project site plans shall include a statement acknowledging compliance with the federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act (MBTA) and California Fish and Game Code (CFGC) that includes avoidance of active bird nests and identification of Best Management Practices to avoid impacts to active nests, including checking for nests prior to construction activities during February 1 to August 31 and what to do if an active nest is found so that the nest is not inadvertently impacted during grading or construction activities. Require project proponents to retain a qualified biologist familiar with avian species in the northern California Bay Area to conduct required surveys, prepare a survey report, and establish an avoidance buffer, if warranted. Review and approve the survey report. Confirm that individual project site plans include a statement acknowledging compliance with the MBTA and CFGC including the Best Management Practices for avoidance of active bird nests. Prior to ground disturbance and vegetation removal activities. Prior to ground disturbance and vegetation removal activities. Prior to site plan approval. Once per project Once per project Once per project City of Rohnert Park Development Services Department, Planning Division BIO-2 Roosting Bats Prior to tree removal, a qualified biologist shall conduct a focused survey of all trees to be removed or impacted by construction activities to determine whether active roosts of special status bats are present on site. If tree removal is planned for the fall, the survey shall be conducted in September to ensure tree removal will have adequate time to occur during seasonal periods of bat activity (March 1 to April 15, September 1 to October 15, or when evening temperatures rise above 45 degrees Fahrenheit and/or no more than 0.5 inch of rainfall within 24 hours occurs, as described below). If tree removal is planned for the spring, then the survey shall be conducted during the earliest possible time in March, to allow for suitable conditions for both the detection of bats and subsequent tree removal. Trees containing suitable potential bat roost habitat features shall be clearly marked or identified. If day roosts are found to be potentially present, the biologist shall prepare a site-specific roosting bat protection plan to be implemented by the contractor following the City’s approval. The plan shall incorporate the following guidance as appropriate: • When possible, removal of trees identified as suitable roosting habitat should be conducted during seasonal periods of bat activity, including the following: 1. Between September 1 and about October 15, or before evening temperatures fall below 45 degrees Fahrenheit and/or more than 0.5 inch of rainfall within 24 hours occurs. 2. Between March 1 and April 15, or after evening temperatures rise above 45 degrees Fahrenheit and/or no more than 0.5 inch of rainfall within 24 hours occurs. • If a tree must be removed during the breeding season (April 15 to August 31) and is identified as potentially containing a colonial maternity roost, then a qualified biologist shall conduct acoustic emergence surveys or implement other appropriate methods to further evaluate if the roost is an active maternity roost. Under the biologist’s guidance, the contractor shall implement measures similar to or better than the following: 1. If it is determined that the roost is not an active maternity roost, then the roost may be removed in accordance with the other requirements of this measure. Require project proponents to retain a qualified biologist to conduct required surveys, and prepare a site-specific roosting bat protection plan, if warranted. Review and approve the site-specific roosting bat protection plan. Prior to tree removal or construction activities that would impact trees. Once per project that requires tree removal or would impact trees during construction activities. City of Rohnert Park Development Services Department, Planning Division City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 4-4 Mitigation Measure/ Condition of Approval Action Required Timing Monitoring Frequency Responsible Agency Compliance Verification Initial Compliance Verification Date Compliance Verification Comments 2. If it is found that an active maternity roost of a colonial roosting species is present, the roost shall not be disturbed during the breeding season (April 15 to August 31). • Potential colonial hibernation roosts shall only be removed during seasonal periods of bat activity. Potential non-colonial roosts that cannot be avoided shall be removed on warm days in late morning to afternoon when any bats present are likely to be warm and able to fly. Appropriate methods shall be used to minimize the potential harm to bats during tree removal. Such methods may include using a two-step tree removal process. This method is conducted over two consecutive days and works by creating noise and vibration by cutting non-habitat branches and limbs from habitat trees using chainsaws only (no excavators or other heavy machinery) on day one. The noise and vibration disturbance, together with the visible alteration of the tree, is very effective in causing bats that emerge nightly to feed to not return to the roost that night. The remainder of the tree is removed on day two. BIO-3 Conduct Pre-construction Crotch’s Bumble Bee Surveys and Implement Avoidance Measures For construction activities located in vacant or undeveloped areas containing open grasslands, shrublands, or chaparral, a habitat assessment for Crotch’s bumble bee shall be performed by a qualified biologist knowledgeable and experienced with Crotch’s bumble bee and the habitat in which they occur. If the biologist determines that suitable habitat for Crotch’s bumble bee is present, a focused survey shall be performed during the species’ active flight period for Crotch’s bumble bee and peak blooming period of nectar and pollen sources (May 1 through July 31). The Crotch’s bumble bee survey shall be conducted on foot and shall encompass the entirety of a project site and focus on areas that allow for the highest probability of detection, such as high abundance nectar or pollen sources and rodent burrows that may be used for breeding and nesting. If Crotch’s bumble bee is determined to be present, the project proponent shall map the locations of the observed bumble bee, areas of abundant nectar or pollen sources, and any active nesting sites. A report summarizing the results of the habitat assessment and focused survey (if required) shall be prepared by the qualified biologist and shall be submitted to the City prior to the commencement of construction activities. Further, consultation with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife will be necessary in the event Crotch’s bumble bee was observed within a project site and an Incidental Take Permit, in accordance with the California Endangered Species Act, may be required prior to initiating any ground disturbance on the site. Require project proponents to retain a qualified biologist to conduct a Crotch’s bumble bee habitat assessment and focused survey (if warranted), and prepare a report. Review and approve the report. Confirm the project proponent conducted consultation with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife, if warranted. Confirm the project proponent obtained an Incidental Take Permit, if warranted. Prior to construction of each individual project. Prior to construction. Prior to construction. Prior to construction. Once per project located in vacant or undeveloped areas containing open grasslands, shrublands, or chaparral. Once per project. Once per project. Once per project. City of Rohnert Park Development Services Department, Planning Division; California Department of Fish and Wildlife Cultural Resources CR-1 Historical, Cultural, and Architectural Resource Database The City shall conduct a study to establish and maintain an archaeological, cultural, historical, and architectural resource database. The study shall be aimed at the protection of buildings, structures, and sites that are more than 50 years old and have demonstrated cultural, historical, or architectural significance. This measure shall be added as an implementation program in the General Plan Resource Conservation Element. Confirm the implementation program has been added into the 2040 General Plan Resource Conservation Element. Conduct a study to establish the resource database. Prior to publication of the final 2040 General Plan Resource Conservation Element. Following adoption of the General Plan and prior to demolition or alteration of buildings, structures, or sites more than 50 years old. Once Once City of Rohnert Park Development Services Department, Planning Division CR-2 Requirement for Archaeological Resources Study The City shall require all discretionary projects to investigate the potential to disturb archaeological resources. If preliminary reconnaissance suggests that archaeological resources may exist on a proposed project site, a Phase I archaeological resources study shall be performed by a qualified professional meeting the Secretary of the Interior’s (SOI) Professional Qualification Standard (PQS) for archaeology (NPS 1983). A Phase I archaeological resources study shall include a pedestrian survey of the project site and sufficient background research and, as necessary, field sampling to determine whether archaeological resources may be present. Archival research shall include a records search at the Northwest Information Center (NWIC) and a Sacred Lands File (SLF) search with the Native American Heritage Commission (NAHC), and consultation with FIGR, including a request to FIGR to conduct a tribal registry records search and an invitation to FIGR to provide a cultural monitor for the survey. The Phase I technical report documenting the study shall include recommendations to avoid or reduce impacts on archaeological resources. The project sponsor shall implement the Confirm the implementation program has been added into the 2040 General Plan Resource Conservation Element. Review and approve archaeological studies for discretionary projects. Prior to publication of the final 2040 General Plan Resource Conservation Element. Following adoption of the General Plan and prior to approval of individual projects. Once Once per project. City of Rohnert Park Development Services Department, Planning Division Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program Final Environmental Impact Report 4-5 Mitigation Measure/ Condition of Approval Action Required Timing Monitoring Frequency Responsible Agency Compliance Verification Initial Compliance Verification Date Compliance Verification Comments recommendations. This measure shall be added as an implementation program in the General Plan Resource Conservation Element. Implementation of this program may require additional recommendations to avoid and/or reduce impacts to archaeological resources which would be determined on a project-by-project basis. CR-3 Sensitive Location of Human Remains For any development facilitated by the project where human remains are expected to be present based on the results of tribal consultation and/or as identified by a qualified archaeologist, the City shall consult with FIGR and other local California Native American tribe(s) as applicable on the decision to employ a canine forensics team. If a canine forensics team is employed, the City shall require the team to attempt to identify human remains in a non-invasive way (e.g., non-excavation). Any requirements for the use of a canine forensics team shall be documented in the tribal cultural resources treatment plan prepared under Mitigation Measure TCR-2. The tribal cultural resources treatment plan may require revisions to the design of development facilitated by the project or an addendum to the treatment plan in the event that human remains are identified, with avoidance as the preferred recommendation, as set forth in Mitigation Measure TCR-1. For any development facilitated by the project, regardless of whether Native American remains or burials are expected to be present, in the event of an inadvertent discovery of tribal cultural resources or Native American remains or burials, the City shall consult with FIGR to determine the appropriate treatment, with a priority for avoidance as set forth in TCR-1. Consult with FIGR and other local California Native American Tribe(s) when development would occur where human remains are expected to be present. Confirm requirements for the use of a canine forensics team is documented in the tribal cultural resources’ treatment plan. Consult with FIGR in the event of an inadvertent discovery of tribal cultural resources or Native American remains or burials. Prior to construction of each individual project. Prior to construction of each individual project. Prior to construction of each individual project. Once per project. Once per project. As needed. City of Rohnert Park Development Services Department, Planning Division. Noise N-1 Construction Noise Reduction Measures The following measures to minimize exposure to construction noise shall be included as standard conditions of approval for applicable projects involving construction: 1. Mufflers. During excavation and grading construction phases, all construction equipment, fixed or mobile, shall be operated with closed engine doors and shall be equipped with properly operating and maintained mufflers consistent with manufacturers’ standards. 2. Stationary Equipment. All stationary construction equipment shall be placed so that emitted noise is directed away from the nearest sensitive receptors. 3. Equipment Staging Areas. Equipment staging shall be located in areas that will create the greatest distance feasible between construction-related noise sources and noise-sensitive receptors. 4. Smart Back-up Alarms. Mobile construction equipment shall have smart back-up alarms that automatically adjust the sound level of the alarm in response to ambient noise levels. Alternatively, back-up alarms shall be disabled and replaced with human spotters to ensure safety when mobile construction equipment is moving in the reverse direction. Revise the City’s standard conditions of approval to include construction noise reduction measures. Prior to approval of a construction project following adoption of the 2040 General Plan. Once City of Rohnert Park Development Services Department, Planning Division N-2 Construction Vibration Reduction Measures The following measures to minimize exposure to construction vibration shall be included as standard conditions of approval for applicable projects involving construction: 1. Building Examination. The pre-existing condition of any buildings within 25 feet of any construction activities shall be recorded in order to evaluate damage from project-related construction. Fixtures and finishes within a 25-foot radius of construction activities susceptible to damage will be documented (photographically and in writing) prior to construction. All damage will be repaired back to its pre-existing condition. 2. Stationary Equipment. All vibratory stationary construction equipment shall be placed as far as possible from the nearest sensitive receptors. 3. Equipment Staging Areas. Equipment staging shall be located in areas that will create the greatest distance feasible between construction-related vibration sources and noise-sensitive receptors. Revise the City’s standard conditions of approval to include construction vibration reduction measures. Prior to approval of a construction project following adoption of the 2040 General Plan. Once City of Rohnert Park Development Services Department, Planning Division City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 4-6 Mitigation Measure/ Condition of Approval Action Required Timing Monitoring Frequency Responsible Agency Compliance Verification Initial Compliance Verification Date Compliance Verification Comments Tribal Cultural Resources TCR-1 Avoidance of Tribal Cultural Resources When feasible, development facilitated by the project shall be designed to avoid known tribal cultural resources. The feasibility of avoidance of tribal cultural resources shall be determined by the City and applicant in consultation with FIGR, as required by State law. Require avoidance of known tribal cultural resources in project design plans. Consult with FIGR on the location of tribal cultural resources. Prior to approval of final design plans. Once per project. City of Rohnert Park Development Services Department, Planning Division TCR-2 Tribal Cultural Resource Plan A Tribal Cultural Resources (TCR) Plan shall be required for development occurring in areas identified as potentially sensitive for tribal cultural resources during consultation with FIGR. If the project includes ground disturbance, the TCR Plan shall include a TCR treatment plan to be implemented in the event an unanticipated archaeological resource that may be considered a tribal cultural resource is identified during construction. In the event of an inadvertent discovery of tribal cultural resources or a Native American remain or burial, the TCR Plan shall require consultation with FIGR. The treatment plan shall include any necessary monitoring requirements, suspension of all earth-disturbing work in the vicinity of the find, avoidance of the resource or, if avoidance of the resource is infeasible, the plan shall outline the appropriate treatment of the resource in consultation with FIGR and, if applicable, a qualified archaeologist. Examples of appropriate treatment for tribal cultural resources include, but are not limited to, protecting the cultural character and integrity of the resource, protecting traditional use of the resource, preservation in place, protecting the confidentiality of the resource, or heritage recovery. The TCR Plan and treatment plan shall be reviewed and approved by the City and FIGR to confirm compliance with this measure prior to construction. Require the preparation of a Tribal Cultural Resources (TCR) Plan in consultation with FIGR. Require the preparation of a treatment plan in consultation with FIGR. Review and approve the TCR Plan and treatment plan. Prior to project approval of individual developments in areas sensitive for TCRs. Prior to construction of ground-disturbing projects in areas sensitive for TCRs. Prior to construction. Once per project Once per project Once per project City of Rohnert Park Development Services Department, Planning Division; Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria (FIGR) TCR-3 Native American Monitoring For development occurring in areas identified as potentially sensitive for tribal cultural resources through consultation with FIGR, the project applicant shall retain a FIGR tribal monitor to observe all ground disturbance, including archaeological excavation, associated with development facilitated by the project. Monitoring methods and requirements shall be outlined in a tribal cultural resources treatment plan prepared as described above under Mitigation Measure TCR-2. In the event of a discovery of tribal cultural resources, the steps identified in the TCR treatment plan prepared under Mitigation Measure TCR-2 shall be implemented. Require project proponents to retain a FIGR tribal monitor to observe all ground disturbance. Prior to and during ground- disturbing activities of each individual project in areas sensitive for TCRs. Once per project. City of Rohnert Park Development Services Department, Planning Division TCR-4 Sensitive Location of Human Remains For any development facilitated by the project where human remains are expected to be present based on the results of tribal consultation and/or as identified by a qualified archaeologist, the City shall consult with FIGR and other local California Native American tribe(s) as applicable on the decision to employ a canine forensics team. If a canine forensics team is employed, the City shall require the team to attempt to identify human remains in a non-invasive way (e.g., non-excavation). Any requirements for the use of a canine forensics team shall be documented in the TCR treatment plan prepared under Mitigation Measure TCR-2. The TCR treatment plan may require revisions to the design of development facilitated by the project or an addendum to the treatment plan in the event that human remains are identified, with avoidance as set forth in TCR-1 as the preferred recommendation. For any development facilitated by the project, regardless of whether Native American remains or burials are expected to be present, in the event of an inadvertent discovery of tribal cultural resources or Native American remains or burials, the City shall consult with FIGR to determine the appropriate treatment, with a priority for avoidance as set forth in TCR-1. Consult with FIGR and other local California Native American Tribe(s) when development would occur where human remains are expected to be present. Confirm requirements for the use of a canine forensics team is documented in the tribal cultural resources’ treatment plan. Consult with FIGR in the event of an inadvertent discovery of tribal cultural resources or Native American remains or burials. Prior to construction of each individual project. Prior to construction of each individual project. Prior to construction of each individual project. Once per project. Once per project. As needed. City of Rohnert Park Development Services Department, Planning Division 4922-9711-1443 v1 CEQA Findings and Statement of Overriding Considerations for the Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Sections 15091 and 15093 and Public Resources Code Section 21081 The Final Environmental Impact Report (EIR) prepared by the City of Rohnert Park (City) for the General Plan Update (collectively referred to as the “2040 General Plan,” “project,” or “proposed project”) consists of the Draft EIR and Response to Comments on the Draft EIR. The Final EIR identifies significant environmental impacts that will result from implementation of the project. The City finds that the inclusion of certain mitigation measures as part of project approval will reduce all impacts to levels that are less than significant, except for construction noise, greenhouse gas emissions, and vehicle miles traveled. No feasible mitigation measures have been identified to reduce construction noise, greenhouse gas emissions, and vehicle miles traveled impacts to a less- than-significant level, or mitigation measures have been identified but would not reduce impacts to a level of less than significant; thus, these impacts will remain significant unavoidable impacts of the project. These impacts will be overridden due to specific considerations that are described within this document. The California Environmental Quality Act (Public Resources Code, Section 21000 et seq.) (CEQA) requires that public agencies shall not approve or carry out a project for which an EIR has been certified that identifies one or more significant adverse environmental effects of a project unless the public agency makes one or more written Findings for each of those significant effects, accompanied by a brief explanation of the rationale for each Finding (CEQA Guidelines [California Code or Regulations Title 14, Section 15000 et seq.] Section 15091). This document presents the CEQA Findings of Fact made by the City and its Statement of Overriding Considerations, in its capacity as the CEQA lead agency, regarding the 2040 General Plan Update, evaluated in the Draft EIR and Final EIR for the project. As required by CEQA, the City, in adopting these CEQA Findings and Statement of Overriding Considerations, also adopts a Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program (MMRP) for the project. The City finds that the MMRP, which is incorporated by reference, meets the requirements of Public Resources Code (PRC) Section 21081.6 by providing for the implementation and monitoring of measures intended to mitigate potentially significant effects of the project. In accordance with CEQA and the CEQA Guidelines, the City adopts these findings as part of the project approval. Pursuant to PRC Section 21082.1(c)(3), the City also finds that the Final EIR reflects the City’s independent judgment as the lead agency for the project. Exhibit B to Resolution 2026-030 Table of Contents Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations i 4922-9711-1443 v1 Table of Contents 1 Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 1 Statutory Requirements for Findings.............................................................................................. 1 Procedural Findings ........................................................................................................................ 2 Findings Required Under CEQA ...................................................................................................... 3 Record of Proceedings .................................................................................................................... 4 Findings ........................................................................................................................................... 4 2 Proposed Project ............................................................................................................................ 5 Project Objectives ........................................................................................................................... 5 Project Description ......................................................................................................................... 6 Alternatives ..................................................................................................................................... 7 3 CEQA Findings of Independent Judgment ...................................................................................... 9 Effects Determined Not to Be Significant ....................................................................................... 9 Less Than Significant with Mitigation Impacts .............................................................................16 Significant and Unavoidable Impacts ...........................................................................................23 4 Findings Regarding Alternatives ...................................................................................................27 Alternative 1: No Project Alternative ...........................................................................................27 Alternative 2: Environmental Conservation .................................................................................28 Alternative 3: Multi-Family Residential Focused ..........................................................................29 Alternative 4: “Missing Middle Housing” West of Highway 101 ..................................................30 5 Statement of Overriding Considerations ......................................................................................32 City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 ii Introduction Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations 1 4922-9711-1443 v1 1 Introduction Statutory Requirements for Findings Public Resources Code (PRC) Section 21002 states that “public agencies should not approve projects as proposed if there are feasible alternatives or feasible mitigation measures available which would substantially lessen the significant environmental effects of such projects”. Section 21002 further states that the procedures required by CEQA “are intended to assist public agencies in systematically identifying both the significant effects of proposed projects and the feasible alternatives or feasible mitigation measures which will avoid or substantially lessen such significant effects.” According to PRC Section 21081 and CEQA Guidelines Section 15091, a public agency may only approve or carry out a project for which an EIR has been completed that identifies any significant environmental effects if the agency makes one or more of the following written finding(s) for each of those significant effects accompanied by a brief explanation of the rationale for each finding: (1) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project which avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the final EIR. (2) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. (3) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible the mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the final EIR. While CEQA requires that lead agencies adopt feasible mitigation measures or alternatives to substantially lessen or avoid significant environmental impacts, an agency need not adopt infeasible mitigation measures or alternatives (PRC Section 21002.1[c] [if “economic, social, or other conditions make it infeasible to mitigate one or more significant effects on the environment of a project, the project may nonetheless be carried out or approved at the discretion of a public agency”]; see also CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.6[a] [an “EIR is not required to consider alternatives which are infeasible”]). CEQA defines “feasible” to mean “capable of being accomplished in a successful manner within a reasonable period of time, taking into account economic, environmental, social, and technological factors” (PRC Section 21061.1). Environmental impacts that are less than significant do not require the imposition of mitigation measures (Leonoff v. Monterey County Board of Supervisors (1990) 222 Cal.App.3d 1337, 1347). For significant effects that cannot be mitigated to a less-than-significant level, the public agency is required to find that specific overriding economic, legal, social, technological, or other benefits of the project outweigh the significant effects on the environment (PRC Section 21081[b]). CEQA Guidelines Section 15093 states: “If the specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other benefits of a proposed project outweigh the unavoidable adverse environmental effects, the adverse environmental effects may be considered ‘acceptable.” City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 2 Procedural Findings The City Council of the City of Rohnert Park finds as follows: Based on the nature and scope of the Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan, State Clearinghouse No. 2021020523, the City determined, based on substantial evidence, that the project may have a significant effect on the environment and prepared an EIR. The EIR was prepared, noticed, published, circulated, reviewed, and completed in full compliance with PRC Sections 21000 et seq., CEQA, and the CEQA Guidelines (14 California Code of Regulations Sections 15000 et. seq.), as follows: ▪ Notice of Preparation. After deciding that an EIR is required, the lead agency (the City) must file a Notice of Preparation soliciting input on the EIR scope to the State Clearinghouse, other concerned agencies, and parties previously requesting notice in writing (CEQA Guidelines Section 15082; PRC Section 21092.2). The NOP must be posted in the County Clerk’s office for 30 days. The City prepared an NOP of the Draft EIR for a 51-day agency and public review period that began on February 6, 2021, and ended on March 29, 2021. The City held a scoping meeting on March 11, 2021. A second NOP was published for a 30-day agency and public review period that began on February 15, 2022, and ended on March 17, 2022, and held a second scoping meeting on March 10, 2022. ▪ Draft EIR Prepared. The Draft EIR must contain a) table of contents or index; b) summary; c) project description; d) environmental setting; e) discussion of significant impacts (direct, indirect, cumulative, growth-inducing, and unavoidable impacts); f) a discussion of alternatives; g) mitigation measures; h) discussion of irreversible changes, and i) any identified areas of controversy. The City prepared a Draft EIR and circulated the Draft EIR for a 57-day public review period that began on November 21, 2025, and ended on January 16, 2026. A corresponding Notice of Availability (NOA) and Updated NOA was published to provide notification when the Draft EIR became available for public review and when the public review period was extended, respectively. ▪ Notice of Completion and Notice of Availability (NOA). The lead agency must file a notice of completion with the State Clearinghouse when it completes a Draft EIR and prepare an NOA. The lead agency must place the NOA in the County Clerk’s office for 30 days and send a copy of the NOA to anyone requesting it (CEQA Guidelines Section 15087). Additionally, public notice of Draft EIR availability must be given through at least one of the following methods: a) publication in a newspaper of general circulation; b) physical signage posting on and off the project site; and c) direct mailing to owners and occupants of contiguous properties. The lead agency must solicit input from other agencies and the public and respond in writing to all comments received (PRC Sections 21104 and 21253). An NOA and Notice of Completion was prepared and submitted to the State Clearinghouse with the Draft EIR on November 21, 2025. The NOA was updated to provide additional time for public comment and the revised NOA was submitted to the State Clearinghouse on December 29, 2025. The NOA was published with the Sonoma County Clerk and published in the Rohnert Park Community Voice on November 21, 2025. ▪ Final EIR. A Final EIR must include a) the Draft EIR; b) copies of comments received during public review; c) list of persons and entities commenting; and d) responses to comments. The City prepared a Final EIR, which was published on the City’s website on March 2, 2026. ▪ Certification of Final EIR. Prior to making a decision on a proposed project, the lead agency must certify that a) the Final EIR has been completed in compliance with CEQA; b) the Final EIR was presented to the decision-making body of the lead agency; and c) the decision-making body Introduction Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations 3 4922-9711-1443 v1 reviewed and considered the information in the Final EIR prior to approving a project (CEQA Guidelines Section 15090). ▪ Lead Agency Project Decision. The lead agency may a) disapprove the project because of its significant environmental effects; b) require changes to the project to reduce or avoid significant environmental effects; or c) approve the project despite its significant environmental effects, if the proper findings and statement of overriding considerations are adopted (CEQA Guidelines Sections 15042 and 15043). ▪ Findings/Statement of Overriding Considerations. For each significant impact of the project identified in the EIR, the lead agency must find, based on substantial evidence, that a) the project has been changed to avoid or substantially reduce the magnitude of the impact; b) changes to the project are within another agency's jurisdiction and such changes have or should be adopted; or c) specific economic, social, or other considerations make the mitigation measures or project alternatives infeasible (CEQA Guidelines Section 15091). If an agency approves a project with unavoidable significant environmental effects, it must prepare a written Statement of Overriding Considerations that sets forth the specific social, economic, or other reasons supporting the agency’s decision. ▪ Mitigation Monitoring Reporting Program. When the lead agency makes findings on significant effects identified in the EIR, it must adopt a reporting or monitoring program for mitigation measures adopted or made conditions of project approval to mitigate significant effects. ▪ Notice of Determination (NOD). The lead agency must file a NOD after deciding to approve a project for which an EIR is prepared (CEQA Guidelines Section 15094). A local agency must file the NOD with the county clerk. The NOD must be posted for 30 days and sent to anyone requesting notice previously. Posting of the NOD starts a 30-day statute of limitations on CEQA legal challenges (PRC Section 21167[c]). Findings Required Under CEQA The City Council (the final decision-making body) of the City of Rohnert Park (the CEQA Lead Agency) will determine whether to certify the EIR for the project. Because the Draft EIR identified a potentially significant environmental impact, the City Council must also make certain “findings” as part of its action to certify that the EIR has been completed in compliance with CEQA and to approve the 2040 General Plan. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15091 and PRC Section 21081, no public agency shall approve or carry out a project for which an environmental impact report has been certified, which identifies one or more significant effects on the environment that would occur if the project is approved or carried out, unless the public agency makes one or more findings for each of those significant effects, accompanied by a brief explanation of the rationale of each finding. The possible findings, which must be supported by substantial evidence in the record, are: ▪ Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project which avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ▪ Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. ▪ Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible the mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR. City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 4 Record of Proceedings For purposes of CEQA and these findings, the record before the City Council includes the following: ▪ The Draft EIR and all appendices to the Draft EIR ▪ The Final EIR, including an errata, comments on the Draft EIR, and responses to comments ▪ Public notices required by CEQA ▪ Studies conducted for the Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan and contained in, or referenced by, the Draft EIR or the Final EIR ▪ Documentary and oral evidence received and reviewed at public hearings, study sessions, and workshops and transcripts and minutes of those hearings related to the Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan. the Draft EIR, and the Final EIR ▪ For documentary and informational purposes, the Findings and Statement of Overriding Conditions, Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program, and other documentation relevant to planned growth in the area ▪ Additional items not listed above if otherwise required by law Findings The Final EIR is incorporated into these findings in its entirety. Without limitation, this incorporation is intended to elaborate on the scope and nature of mitigation measures, the basis for determining the significance of impacts, the comparative analysis of alternatives, and the reasons for approving the Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan despite the potential for associated significant and unavoidable adverse impacts. For the purposes of these findings, the impact discussions include the relevant policies and actions, as well as the separate mitigation measures imposed to reduce the impacts where the policies did not result in a less than significant impact. In the findings that follow, impact numbers are provided. The impact numbers correspond to sections of the Draft EIR that contain an expanded discussion of impacts. Please refer to the referenced impact sections of the EIR for more detail. Proposed Project Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations 5 4922-9711-1443 v1 2 Proposed Project Project Objectives Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15124(b), the EIR project description must include “[a] statement of objectives sought by the proposed project. The statement of objectives should include the underlying purpose of the project.” The Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan is intended to achieve the following project objectives: ▪ Racial, Social, and Environmental Justice Encourage and support efforts to increase participation in the local political process and to improve local conditions relative to racial, social, and environmental justice issues. Create a more equitable and inclusive city for all residents of Rohnert Park, with a focus on members of the community who have not been previously heard. ▪ Community Development Support, foster, and enhance the family-oriented culture of Rohnert Park. Create attractive spaces for residents to gather. Ensure a sustainable Rohnert Park balances growth with community resources. ▪ Economic Development Attract and retain unique local business and other businesses, to contribute to the fiscal sustainability of the City. Build on existing assets. Hold fiscal responsibility as an important factor in City decisions. ▪ Climate Change Emphasize climate resiliency, sustainability and adaptation as an integral part of the community. ▪ Circulation Maintain a safe, efficient, and connected transportation system. Embrace all modes of transportation (e.g., pedestrian, transit, bike, auto) to provide flexibility in transportation options to residents, employees, and visitors in Rohnert Park. Improve connection points between the different modes of transportation, including attention to last-mile connectivity. Use transportation demand management to improve traffic congestion. ▪ Public Facilities and Services Ensure that all Rohnert Park residents have access to well-maintained parks and quality community services and programs. City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 6 ▪ Health and Safety Ensure that the city is prepared for foreseeable local hazards (e.g., earthquake, flood, fire) and associated challenges (e.g., erosion, drainage, stormwater management) through up-to- date emergency management and notification procedures. Promote continued reduction, reuse, and recycling within the city. ▪ Resource Conservation Respect and preserve the historic, archaeological, and biological resources in Rohnert Park. Invest in water and air quality improvement measures and programs. ▪ Housing Provide housing that meets the needs of all current and future residents. Project Description This EIR has been prepared to examine the potential environmental effects of the 2040 General Plan (proposed project). The following is a summary of the full project description, which can be found in Section 2, Project Description, of the Draft EIR. The 2040 General Plan is a comprehensive update of the City’s 2020 General Plan. The 2040 General Plan is made up of nine elements: Racial, Social, and Environmental Justice; Community Development; Economic Development; Climate Change; Circulation; Public Facilities and Services; Health and Safety; Resource Conservation; and Housing. The Community Development Element describes the general distribution, location, and extent of various land uses. Fourteen separate land use designations have been proposed in the 2040 General Plan to provide a mixture of land uses for the City. The 2040 General Plan designates land uses defining the type of development that can occur throughout the City through the planning horizon year of 2040. Most of the future development capacity in Rohnert Park is within specific plan areas, planned developments, and the Central Rohnert Park Priority Development Area, especially for residential development. Development capacity in the rest of the city will be through strategic infill sites. The project would include the rezoning of two sites on Snyder Lane from Public Institutional to High Density Residential to ensure consistency with the Housing Element. Based on the number of new dwelling units projected under buildout of the 2040 General Plan, and an assumed persons per unit rate by unit type, full buildout of the 2040 General Plan would result in an additional estimated 15,844 new residents in Rohnert Park. When combined with the existing 2021 population of 42,484, the total population of Rohnert Park in 2040 would be 58,328 persons in 2040. A total of 2,579,960 square feet of non-residential space could be constructed within Rohnert Park under full buildout of the 2040 General Plan. This additional non-residential space would generate an estimated 6,165 new jobs in the City by 2040 in the retail, service, office, manufacturing, and wholesale trade sectors. Proposed areas for development under the 2040 General Plan include the Central Rohnert Park Priority Development Area which features plans for a new downtown area, the Northwest area, Rohnert Park Expressway Corridor, Southwest Boulevard Commercial Corridor, Stadium Lands area, Dowdell Avenue Corridor, Northeast area, University District, and Sonoma Mountain Village/Willowglen area. Proposed Project Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations 7 4922-9711-1443 v1 Alternatives Based on the project objectives and anticipated environmental consequences, and pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.6, the following project alternatives were selected for analysis: ▪ Alternative 1: No Project. The No Project Alternative involves continued implementation of the City’s current 2020 General Plan, including the land use map and all existing goals and policies, and the current 2023-2031 Housing Element, would remain in place through the horizon year of 2040. Thus, any new development in Rohnert Park would occur consistent with the existing land use designations and the allowed uses within each designation. Similarly, any new infrastructure in Rohnert Park would occur as envisioned in the 2020 General Plan. Development under this alternative compared to the proposed project provides less infill residential development and less dense residential development on infill or undeveloped properties within the City. This alternative would not include the Business Park (B-P) land use designation and the existing Industrial (I-L), and Regional Commercial (C-R) land use designations would remain in the northwest portion of the city, as shown on Figures 2-3 and 2-4 in Section 2, Project Description, of the Draft EIR. This alternative would not modify existing land use designations. Because this alternative would not include the higher density and infill residential development within developed areas of the city or the minor modifications to existing land use designations, overall development and anticipated growth would be reduced compared to the 2040 General Plan. ▪ Alternative 2: Environmental Conservation. Alternative 2 would change the land use designations of property located north of Golf Course Drive West and west of Dowdell Avenue to “Environmental Conservation.” Existing rural residential uses would remain as non- conforming uses. This alternative would result in adoption of the 2040 General Plan; however, the total potential buildout by 2040 under this alternative would be reduced compared to the proposed project. This alternative would result in the following land use modification from the proposed 2040 General Plan land use designations: Add the Environmental Conservation (E-C) land use designation to approximately 33 acres in the northwest portion of the city, which would replace Business Park (B-P) land use designations north of Golf Course Drive West and west of Dowdell Avenue. Under this alternative, development would occur over a smaller area as compared to the proposed project, with a reduced buildout potential of non-residential uses. Alternative 2 would allow for less development potential compared to the proposed project. ▪ Alternative 3: Workforce Housing Program. Alternative 3 includes the proposed 2040 General Plan and associated land use changes described in Section 2, Project Description, of the Draft EIR in addition to a General Plan and Zoning Code change that would implement a Workforce Housing program throughout the City. The program would allow for the development of workforce housing, targeting lower income groups, on any site with a non-residential zoning designation, outside of the approved Specific Plan, Planned Development and Priority Development Areas, with no additional approvals required beyond the standard approvals for development per existing zoning designations. Practically, the City expects this Alternative would result in additional housing developed along Rohnert Park Expressway, west of Highway 101 and along Redwood Boulevard. Development would occur within the same general areas where development would occur under the proposed project, with additional workforce housing units throughout the city in City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 8 existing commercial and industrial areas, as described above. Alternative 3 would allow for increased development potential compared to the proposed project. ▪ Alternative 4: “Missing Middle Housing” West of Highway 101. Alternative 4 would replace the proposed 2040 General Plan land use changes for the Northwest and Wilfred Dowdell Specific Plan Areas (described in Section 2, Project Description, of the Draft EIR) with high density (R-H) residential zoning. The intent of this alternative is to provide additional “missing middle” housing options and to provide more flexibility for meeting the City’s Regional Housing Needs Allocation. Alternative 4 would result in a greater residential unit count and population increase as the proposed project and would result in a reduced non-residential square footage and job count compared to the proposed project. Development would occur within the same general areas where development would occur under the proposed project. Refer to Section 6, Alternatives, of the Draft EIR for the complete alternatives analysis. CEQA Findings of Independent Judgment Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations 9 4922-9711-1443 v1 3 CEQA Findings of Independent Judgment Effects Determined Not to Be Significant CEQA Guidelines Section 15128 requires an EIR to contain a statement briefly indicating the reasons that various possible significant effects of a project were determined not to be significant and were, therefore, not discussed in detail in the EIR. As such, implementation of the project was determined to result in no potentially significant impacts related to the following issues and, consequently, these issues were not discussed in detail in the EIR. Aesthetics (State scenic highways) Compliance with goals and policies of the 2040 General Plan and the City’s Design Guidelines would ensure that new development does not have a substantial adverse effect on views from State scenic highways. Therefore, no impact would occur related to visual resources within scenic highways. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Page 4.18-1 of the Draft EIR. Agricultural Resources (conversion of farmland, forest land, or timberland; conflict with agricultural uses, forest land, timberland, or Williamson Act contracts) The Plan Area does not contain Prime Farmland, Unique Farmland, Farmland of Statewide Importance, forest land, or timberland. The proposed project would not change land use designations of parcels currently in agricultural use. Though there are Williamson Act contract lands within the Plan Area, agriculture production would continue to occur on these parcels and the proposed project would not conflict with agriculture or Williamson Act contract lands. Therefore, no impacts would occur related to agricultural resources. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.18-1 through 4.18-2 of the Draft EIR. Geology and Soils (soil suitability for septic systems) Development facilitated by the proposed project would occur within developed areas containing existing sanitary sewer systems and would require new development to connect to the existing sewer system. Therefore, impacts related to unsuitable soil for septic systems would be less than significant. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Page 4.18-2 of the Draft EIR. City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 10 Hazards and Hazardous Materials (located within an airport land use plan) There are no public or private airports within the Plan Area. Therefore, no impacts would occur related to proximity to airports. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Page 4.18-2 of the Draft EIR. Mineral Resources (loss of availability) There are no mineral resources, existing mines, major mineral deposits, or critical minerals within the Plan Area. Therefore, no impacts would occur related to mineral resources. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Page 4.18-3 of the Draft EIR. Noise (airport noise) There are no public or private airports within the Plan Area. Therefore, no impacts would occur related to airport noise. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Page 4.18-3 of the Draft EIR. Less Than Significant Impacts The City Council of Rohnert Park finds that, based upon substantial evidence in the record, including information in the Final EIR, the following impacts have been determined be less than significant and no mitigation is required pursuant to PRC Section 21081(a) and CEQA Guidelines Section 15091(a). Aesthetics (scenic vistas, visual character, and light and glare) Compliance with goals and policies of the 2040 General Plan and the City’s Design Guidelines would ensure that new development does not have a substantial adverse effect on scenic vistas, visual character and quality, views from State scenic highways. Adherence to existing ordinances that regulate light and glare for new development would ensure that new development does not have a substantial adverse effect related to light and glare. FINDING The City Council of Rohnert Park finds that, based upon substantial evidence in the record, the project’s aesthetics impacts related to scenic vistas, visual character, and light and glare would be less than significant, and no mitigation measures are required. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.1-8 through 4.1-18 of the Draft EIR. CEQA Findings of Independent Judgment Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations 11 4922-9711-1443 v1 Biological Resources (riparian habitat and sensitive natural communities, protected wetlands, wildlife movement corridors, conflicts with local policies or ordinances, and conflicts with a Habitat Conservation Plan or Natural Community Conservation Plan) Compliance with federal, State, and local regulations and policies would reduce potential impacts to riparian habitat or other sensitive natural communities in the Plan Area. Through conservation of natural areas as directed by the 2040 General Plan, impacts to wildlife movement corridors would be reduced. Through compliance with goals and policies of the 2040 General Plan and conservation strategies of the Santa Rosa Plain Conservation Strategy, impacts related to conflicts with local policies or ordinances and adopted Habitat Conservation Plan or Natural Community Conservation Plan would be reduced to less than significant. Therefore, impacts would be less than significant related to these biological resources. FINDING The City Council of Rohnert Park finds that, based upon substantial evidence in the record, the project’s biological resource impacts related to riparian habitat and sensitive natural communities, protected wetlands, wildlife movement corridors, conflicts with local policies or ordinances, and conflicts with a Habitat Conservation Plan or Natural Community Conservation Plan would be less than significant, and no mitigation measures are required. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.3-21 through 4.3-27 of the Draft EIR. Energy (inefficient use of energy, and conflicts with energy efficiency plans) The project would comply with regulatory requirements related to energy efficiency, including requirements for construction vehicle use, diversion of solid waste, and installation of energy efficient fixtures and appliances. The project would comply with City land use policies related to energy efficiency, and would not obstruct a State or local plan for renewable energy or energy efficiency. Therefore, impacts related to energy would be less than significant. FINDING The City Council of Rohnert Park finds that, based upon substantial evidence in the record, the project’s energy impacts related to inefficient use of energy, and conflicts with energy efficiency plans would be less than significant, and no mitigation measures are required. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.5-14 through 4.5-25 of the Draft EIR. Geology and Soils (fault rupture, seismic ground-shaking, liquefaction, landslides, soil erosion, unstable soils, expansive soils, and paleontological resources) Adherence to the California Building Code, Rohnert Park Municipal Code, and goals and policies of the 2040 General Plan would reduce potential impacts related to rupture of a known earthquake fault, strong seismic ground shaking, or seismic related ground failure including landslide, lateral City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 12 spreading, subsidence, liquefaction, or collapse. Additional compliance with Clean Water Act requirements would reduce impacts related to erosion and loss of topsoil. Compliance with California Building Code, Rohnert Park Municipal Code, and goals and policies of the 2040 General Plan in addition to proposed subsoil preparation, drainage, and foundation design would reduce impacts related to geology and soils to less than significant. Adherence to 2040 General Plan policies and implementation programs would reduce potential impacts to paleontological resources to less than significant. FINDING The City Council of Rohnert Park finds that, based upon substantial evidence in the record, the project’s geology and soils impacts related to fault rupture, seismic ground-shaking, liquefaction, landslides, soil erosion, unstable soils, expansive soils, and paleontological resources would be less than significant, and no mitigation measures are required. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.6-17 through 4.6-22 of the Draft EIR. Hazards and Hazardous Materials (routine transport, use, or disposal of hazardous materials; reasonably foreseeable upset; emissions within 0.25 mile of a school; Government Code Section 65962.5 listed sites; and interfere with an emergency response or evacuation plan) Development facilitated by the proposed project may generate additional amounts of hazardous waste and result in an increase in routine transport, use, and disposal of hazardous materials within the Plan Area. Compliance with applicable regulations related to hazardous materials and 2040 General Plan goals and policies would minimize risk of releases and exposure to hazardous materials. Compliance with existing regulatory requirements would minimize risks to schools and students and reduce risks associated with development on contaminated sites. Maintenance of a local hazard mitigation plan and emergency access implementation would reduce conflicts with emergency response and/or evacuation plans. Therefore, impacts related to hazardous materials would be less than significant. FINDING The City Council of Rohnert Park finds that, based upon substantial evidence in the record, the project’s hazards and hazardous materials impacts related to routine transport, use, or disposal of hazardous materials; reasonably foreseeable upset; emissions within 0.25 mile of a school; Government Code Section 65962.5 listed sites; and interfere with an emergency response or evacuation plan would be less than significant, and no mitigation measures are required. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.8-10 through 4.8-20 of the Draft EIR. CEQA Findings of Independent Judgment Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations 13 4922-9711-1443 v1 Hydrology and Water Quality (water quality, decrease groundwater supplies, alter the drainage pattern, release pollutants during inundation, and conflicts with a sustainable groundwater management plan) Development facilitated by the project would be subject to state and local requirements related to water quality impacts during construction and operation. With adherence to the Rohnert Park Municipal Code, the 2004 Water Policy Resolution, and 2040 General Plan goals and policies, projects implemented under the proposed project would not substantially decrease groundwater supply or interfere with groundwater recharge such that the project would impede sustainable groundwater management of the Santa Rosa Plan Basin. With adherence to the 2040 General Plan goals and policies, as well as compliance with Rohnert Park Municipal Code regulations, development facilitated by the proposed project would not result in erosion or siltation on- or off- site; would not increase the rate or amount of surface runoff which would result in flooding on- or off-site; would not substantially alter the existing drainage pattern of the sites in a manner which would contribute runoff water which would exceed the capacity of existing or planned stormwater drainage systems; and would not impede or redirect flood flows. Adherence with the Rohnert Park Municipal Code that governs development in flood hazard areas and implementation of the 2040 General Plan goals and policies would limit the potential for inundation of development by flooding. With adherence to State and local regulations and the 2040 General Plan goals and policies, development under the proposed project would not interfere with the objectives and goals of the Basin Plan. These impacts would be less than significant. FINDING The City Council of Rohnert Park finds that, based upon substantial evidence in the record, the project’s hydrology and water quality impacts related to water quality, decrease groundwater supplies, alter the drainage pattern, release pollutants during inundation, and conflicts with a sustainable groundwater management plan would be less than significant, and no mitigation measures are required. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.9-16 through 4.9-28 of the Draft EIR. Land Use and Planning (divide an established community, and conflicts with land use plans) The proposed project would promote orderly development in the Plan Area and the urban growth boundary by encouraging growth in designated focused areas, implementing transitional design features, and providing guidelines for each land use designation. The proposed project contains goals and policies that would promote consistency with land use plans and consistency with the recently adopted Housing Element. Additionally, the majority of new developments resulting from the proposed project would involve strategic locations within Special Area Plans intended to ensure consistency with goals and policies, zoning requirements, and land use designations. Implementation of the proposed project would be generally consistent with applicable adopted plans, regulations, or policies, including Plan Bay Area 2050 and Sonoma County General Plan 2020. Therefore, impacts would be less than significant related to land use and planning. City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 14 FINDING The City Council of Rohnert Park finds that, based upon substantial evidence in the record, the project’s land use and planning impacts related to dividing an established community, and conflicts with land use plans would be less than significant, and no mitigation measures are required. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.10-9 through 4.10-18 of the Draft EIR. Noise (operational noise) The continued regulation of on-site noise, consistent with the Rohnert Park Municipal Code, and implementation of goals and policies in the 2040 General Plan would minimize disturbance to adjacent land uses, and traffic noise increases would not exceed significance thresholds. Impacts from new, permanent noise sources would be less than significant. FINDING The City Council of Rohnert Park finds that, based upon substantial evidence in the record, the project’s noise impacts related to operation would be less than significant, and no mitigation measures are required. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.11-12 through 4.11-15 of the Draft EIR. Population and Housing (substantial unplanned population growth, and displacement of people or housing) The proposed project accommodates population growth. However, the proposed project is intended to accommodate and plan for population growth and includes policies to manage growth and development. The proposed project would facilitate the development of new housing in accordance with State and local housing requirements, while preserving existing residential neighborhoods. Therefore, impacts related to population and housing would be less than significant. FINDING The City Council of Rohnert Park finds that, based upon substantial evidence in the record, the project’s population and housing impacts related to substantial unplanned population growth, and displacement of people or housing would be less than significant, and no mitigation measures are required. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.12-5 through 4.12-8 of the Draft EIR. Public Services and Recreation (fire protection, police protection, schools, parks, other public facilities, use of neighborhood and regional parks, and construction of recreational facilities) Development facilitated by the project would be required to comply with policies in the 2040 General Plan, the SOMO Village Project, and the Public Facilities Fee Program. The dedication of CEQA Findings of Independent Judgment Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations 15 4922-9711-1443 v1 parkland or payment of fees pursuant to Quimby Act and Rohnert Park Municipal Code would be required prior to development of individual projects. Adherence to 2040 General Plan policies and payment of impact fees and/or property taxes related to new development would contribute to new or expanded schools and/or public facilities, as needed. Therefore, impacts related to public services would be less than significant. FINDING The City Council of Rohnert Park finds that, based upon substantial evidence in the record, the project’s public services and recreation impacts related to fire protection, police protection, schools, parks, other public facilities, use of neighborhood and regional parks, and construction of recreational facilities would be less than significant, and no mitigation measures are required. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.13-7 through 4.13-15 of the Draft EIR. Transportation and Traffic (conflicts with circulation plans, increased traffic hazards, and emergency access) With implementation of applicable goals, policies, and implementation programs, the pedestrian and bicycle circulation system will become more convenient, resulting in an improvement in quality of service for users of existing and proposed facilities, improved access, and improved safety for bicyclists and pedestrians. The proposed project is a program-level plan that does not directly address project-level design features. Roadway improvements and site access measures would be designed and reviewed in accordance with City standards. The proposed project identifies circulation improvements and policies that support emergency access throughout the City. Therefore, impacts related to transportation would be less than significant. FINDING The City Council of Rohnert Park finds that, based upon substantial evidence in the record, the project’s transportation and traffic impacts related to conflicts with circulation plans, increased traffic hazards, and emergency access would be less than significant, and no mitigation measures are required. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.14-18 through 4.14-33 and 4.14-38 through 4.14-41 of the Draft EIR. Utilities and Service Systems (water, wastewater, stormwater, electric power, natural gas, telecommunication facilities, and solid waste) Development facilitated by the proposed project would occur in developed areas of the City where electric power, natural gas, telecommunication, and stormwater drainage facilities already exist. Compliance with 2040 General Plan policies would reduce potential impacts related to increased demand. The City has adequate water supply to provide for development facilitated by the proposed project during normal, dry, and multiple dry years. Adherence to 2040 General Plan policies would reduce needs for relocation or construction of new and expanded water facilities and water supplies would be adequate to support new development. The proposed project would increase demand for wastewater treatment and increase the generation of solid waste, however, City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 16 the existing wastewater treatment plant and local infrastructure serving the City have sufficient capacity for future development. Therefore, impacts related to utilities and service systems would be less than significant. FINDING The City Council of Rohnert Park finds that, based upon substantial evidence in the record, the project’s utilities and service systems impacts related to water, wastewater, stormwater, electric power, natural gas, telecommunication facilities, and solid waste would be less than significant, and no mitigation measures are required. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.16-13 through 4.16-23 of the Draft EIR. Wildfire (impair an adopted emergency response plan or evacuation plan, exacerbate wildfire risks, and expose people or structures to wildfire risk) Implementation of 2040 General Plan policies and actions associated with emergency planning and response, in addition to adherence to Local Hazard Mitigation Plan Mitigation Actions and Fire Services Division review, would ensure that potential impacts from implementation of the proposed project on emergency response and evacuation would be less than significant. The proposed project does not include plans to extend the City’s sphere of influence or City limits into the adjacent eastern fire hazard severity zones, but may include infill development on wildland-urban interface borders, which is the area of the City most susceptible to wildfire. However, prevailing wind patterns, slope, lack of greenfield development, and compliance with the Rohnert Park Municipal Code and 2040 General Plan would ensure that development facilitated by the proposed project would not exacerbate existing wildfire risks, expose residents or business occupants to a significant risk of loss, injury or death, or to pollutants from a wildfire beyond existing conditions. Maintenance of fire access roads could generate temporary or ongoing impacts related to noise and vegetation removal. These impacts would be less than significant because maintenance would be infrequent and limited to areas immediately next to fire access roads. Additionally, maintenance of these fire access roads would reduce the potential for severe or catastrophic wildfires, rather than exacerbate them. Therefore, impacts related to wildfire would be less than significant. FINDING The City Council of Rohnert Park finds that, based upon substantial evidence in the record, the project’s wildfire impacts related to impair an adopted emergency response plan or evacuation plan, exacerbate wildfire risks, and expose people or structures to wildfire risk would be less than significant, and no mitigation measures are required. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.17-11 through 4.17-18 of the Draft EIR. Less Than Significant with Mitigation Impacts These topical areas contain impacts of the 2040 General Plan that are reduced to a less-than- significant level through the implementation of mitigation measures. Pursuant to PRC Section 21081(a)(1) and CEQA Guidelines Section 15091(a)(1), as to each impact, the City, based on the CEQA Findings of Independent Judgment Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations 17 4922-9711-1443 v1 evidence in the record before it, finds that changes or alterations incorporated into the 2040 General Plan mitigate, avoid, or substantially lessen to a level of insignificance these environmental impacts of the project. The basis for the finding for each impact is set forth below. Biological Resources (special-status species) Impact BIO-1 Development facilitated by the proposed project would have the potential to modify habitat that could affect special-status species during construction and operation. Impacts would be less than significant with mitigation. MITIGATION MEASURE BIO-1 PRE-CONSTRUCTION BIRD SURVEYS, AVOIDANCE, AND NOTIFICATION For construction activities initiated during the bird nesting season (February 1 – August 31) involving removal of vegetation or other nesting bird habitat, including abandoned structures and other man- made features, a pre-construction nesting bird survey shall be conducted no more than three days prior to initiation of ground disturbance and vegetation removal activities. If a lapse in project- related work of seven days or longer occurs, another survey shall be conducted before project work can be reinitiated. The nesting bird pre-construction survey shall be conducted on foot and shall include a 500-foot buffer around the construction site. The survey shall be conducted by a biologist familiar with the identification of avian species known to occur in northern California Bay Area communities (i.e., qualified biologist). If nests are found, an avoidance buffer shall be determined by a qualified biologist dependent upon the species, the proposed work activity, and existing disturbances associated with land uses outside of the site, which shall be demarcated by the biologist with bright orange construction fencing, flagging, construction lathe, or other means to demarcate the boundary. All construction personnel shall be notified as to the existence of the buffer zone and to avoid entering the buffer zone during the nesting season. No ground disturbing activities shall occur within the buffer until the biologist has confirmed that breeding/ nesting is completed, and the young have fledged the nest. Encroachment into the buffer shall occur only at the discretion of the qualified biologist on the basis that the encroachment will not be detrimental to an active nest. A report summarizing the pre-construction survey(s) shall be prepared by a qualified biologist and shall be submitted to the City prior to the commencement of construction activities. Proposed project site plans shall include a statement acknowledging compliance with the federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act (MBTA) and California Fish and Game Code (CFGC) that includes avoidance of active bird nests and identification of Best Management Practices to avoid impacts to active nests, including checking for nests prior to construction activities during February 1 to August 31 and what to do if an active nest is found so that the nest is not inadvertently impacted during grading or construction activities. MITIGATION MEASURE BIO-2 ROOSTING BATS Prior to tree removal, a qualified biologist shall conduct a focused survey of all trees to be removed or impacted by construction activities to determine whether active roosts of special status bats are present on site. If tree removal is planned for the fall, the survey shall be conducted in September to ensure tree removal will have adequate time to occur during seasonal periods of bat activity (March 1 to April 15, September 1 to October 15, or when evening temperatures rise above 45 degrees City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 18 Fahrenheit and/or no more than 0.5 inch of rainfall within 24 hours occurs, as described below). If tree removal is planned for the spring, then the survey shall be conducted during the earliest possible time in March, to allow for suitable conditions for both the detection of bats and subsequent tree removal. Trees containing suitable potential bat roost habitat features shall be clearly marked or identified. If day roosts are found to be potentially present, the biologist shall prepare a site-specific roosting bat protection plan to be implemented by the contractor following the City’s approval. The plan shall incorporate the following guidance as appropriate: ▪ When possible, removal of trees identified as suitable roosting habitat should be conducted during seasonal periods of bat activity, including the following: 1. Between September 1 and about October 15, or before evening temperatures fall below 45 degrees Fahrenheit and/or more than 0.5 inch of rainfall within 24 hours occurs. 2. Between March 1 and April 15, or after evening temperatures rise above 45 degrees Fahrenheit and/or no more than 0.5 inch of rainfall within 24 hours occurs. ▪ If a tree must be removed during the breeding season (April 15 to August 31) and is identified as potentially containing a colonial maternity roost, then a qualified biologist shall conduct acoustic emergence surveys or implement other appropriate methods to further evaluate if the roost is an active maternity roost. Under the biologist’s guidance, the contractor shall implement measures similar to or better than the following: 1. If it is determined that the roost is not an active maternity roost, then the roost may be removed in accordance with the other requirements of this measure. 2. If it is found that an active maternity roost of a colonial roosting species is present, the roost shall not be disturbed during the breeding season (April 15 to August 31). ▪ Potential colonial hibernation roosts shall only be removed during seasonal periods of bat activity. Potential non-colonial roosts that cannot be avoided shall be removed on warm days in late morning to afternoon when any bats present are likely to be warm and able to fly. Appropriate methods shall be used to minimize the potential harm to bats during tree removal. Such methods may include using a two-step tree removal process. This method is conducted over two consecutive days and works by creating noise and vibration by cutting non-habitat branches and limbs from habitat trees using chainsaws only (no excavators or other heavy machinery) on day one. The noise and vibration disturbance, together with the visible alteration of the tree, is very effective in causing bats that emerge nightly to feed to not return to the roost that night. The remainder of the tree is removed on day two. MITIGATION MEASURE BIO-3 CONDUCT PRE-CONSTRUCTION CROTCH’S BUMBLE BEE SURVEYS AND IMPLEMENT AVOIDANCE MEASURES For construction activities located in vacant or undeveloped areas containing open grasslands, shrublands, or chaparral, a habitat assessment for Crotch’s bumble bee shall be performed by a qualified biologist knowledgeable and experienced with Crotch’s bumble bee and the habitat in which they occur. If the biologist determines that suitable habitat for Crotch’s bumble bee is present, a focused survey shall be performed during the species’ active flight period for Crotch’s bumble bee and peak blooming period of nectar and pollen sources (May 1 through July 31). The Crotch’s bumble bee survey shall be conducted on foot and shall encompass the entirety of a project site and focus on areas that allow for the highest probability of detection, such as high abundance nectar or pollen sources and rodent burrows that may be used for breeding and nesting. If Crotch’s bumble bee is determined to be present, the project proponent shall map the locations CEQA Findings of Independent Judgment Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations 19 4922-9711-1443 v1 of the observed bumble bee, areas of abundant nectar or pollen sources, and any active nesting sites. A report summarizing the results of the habitat assessment and focused survey (if required) shall be prepared by the qualified biologist and shall be submitted to the City prior to the commencement of construction activities. Further, consultation with the CDFW will be necessary in the event Crotch’s bumble bee was observed within a project site and an Incidental Take Permit, in accordance with the California Endangered Species Act, may be required prior to initiating any ground disturbance on the site. FINDING The City finds that with incorporation of Mitigation Measures BIO-1, BIO-2, and BIO-3, which would require a project applicant to conduct pre-construction bird surveys, focused surveys for roosting bats, and pre-construction surveys for Crotch’s Bumble Bee, impacts to biological resources would be reduced to a less than significant level. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15091 (a)(1), changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the proposed project that avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect to the extent feasible. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.3-16 through 4.3-20 of the Draft EIR. Cultural Resources (historical resources, archaeological resources, and human remains) Impact CR-1 Development facilitated by the proposed project would have the potential to impact historical resources. Following the implementation of proposed General Plan policies, impacts would be less than significant with mitigation. MITIGATION MEASURE CR-1 HISTORICAL, CULTURAL, AND ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCE DATABASE The City shall conduct a study to establish and maintain an archaeological, cultural, historical, and architectural resource database. The study shall be aimed at the protection of buildings, structures, and sites that are more than 50 years old and have demonstrated cultural, historical, or architectural significance. This measure shall be added as an implementation program in the General Plan Resource Conservation Element. FINDING The City finds that with incorporation of Mitigation Measure CR-1, which would require the City to conduct a study to establish and maintain an archaeological, cultural, historical, and architectural resource database, impacts to cultural resources would be reduced to a less than significant level. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15091 (a)(1), changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the proposed project that avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect to the extent feasible. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.4-10 through 4.4-12 of the Draft EIR. City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 20 Impact CR-2 Development facilitated by the proposed project would have the potential to impact archaeological resources, although implementation of applicable 2040 General Plan policies and implementation programs, would minimize potential adverse impacts to archaeological resources. This impact would be less than significant with mitigation. MITIGATION MEASURE CR-2 REQUIREMENT FOR ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESOURCES STUDY The City shall require all discretionary projects to investigate the potential to disturb archaeological resources. If preliminary reconnaissance suggests that archaeological resources may exist on a proposed project site, a Phase I archaeological resources study shall be performed by a qualified professional meeting the Secretary of the Interior’s (SOI) Professional Qualification Standard (PQS) for archaeology (NPS 1983). A Phase I archaeological resources study shall include a pedestrian survey of the project site and sufficient background research and, as necessary, field sampling to determine whether archaeological resources may be present. Archival research shall include a records search at the Northwest Information Center (NWIC) and a Sacred Lands File (SLF) search with the Native American Heritage Commission (NAHC), and consultation with the Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria (FIGR), including a request to FIGR to conduct a tribal registry records search and an invitation to FIGR to provide a cultural monitor for the survey. The Phase I technical report documenting the study shall include recommendations to avoid or reduce impacts on archaeological resources. The project sponsor shall implement the recommendations. This measure shall be added as an implementation program in the General Plan Resource Conservation Element. Implementation of this program may require additional recommendations to avoid and/or reduce impacts to archaeological resources which would be determined on a project-by-project basis. FINDING The City finds that with incorporation of Mitigation Measure CR-2, which would require all discretionary projects to investigate the potential to disturb archaeological resources and may require preparation of a Phase I archaeological resources study, impacts to cultural resources would be reduced to a less than significant level. Mitigation Measures TCR-1, TCR-2, and TCR-3 (provided under Tribal Cultural Resources, below) would also be required. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15091 (a)(1), changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the proposed project that avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect to the extent feasible. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.4-12 through 4.4-14 of the Draft EIR. Impact CR-3 Ground-disturbing activities associated with development facilitated by the proposed project could result in damage to or destruction of human burials, although compliance with existing regulations on human remains would minimize impacts. These impacts would be less than significant with mitigation. CEQA Findings of Independent Judgment Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations 21 4922-9711-1443 v1 MITIGATION MEASURE CR-3 SENSITIVE LOCATION OF HUMAN REMAINS For any development facilitated by the project where human remains are expected to be present based on the results of tribal consultation and/or as identified by a qualified archaeologist, the City shall consult with FIGR and other local California Native American tribe(s) as applicable on the decision to employ a canine forensics team. If a canine forensics team is employed, the City shall require the team to attempt to identify human remains in a non-invasive way (e.g., non-excavation). Any requirements for the use of a canine forensics team shall be documented in the tribal cultural resources treatment plan prepared under Mitigation Measure TCR-2. The tribal cultural resources treatment plan may require revisions to the design of development facilitated by the project or an addendum to the treatment plan in the event that human remains are identified, with avoidance as the preferred recommendation, as set forth in Mitigation Measure TCR-1. For any development facilitated by the project, regardless of whether Native American remains or burials are expected to be present, in the event of an inadvertent discovery of tribal cultural resources or Native American remains or burials, the City shall consult with FIGR to determine the appropriate treatment, with a priority for avoidance as set forth in TCR-1. FINDING The City finds that with incorporation of Mitigation Measure CR-3, which would require projects where human remains are expected to be present based on the results of tribal consultation and/r a qualified archaeologist, to consult with FIGR and other local California Native American tribe(s) to determine the appropriate treatment, impacts to cultural resources would be reduced to a less than significant level. Mitigation Measures TCR-1, TCR-2, and TCR-3 (provided under Tribal Cultural Resources, below) would also be required. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15091 (a)(1), changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the proposed project that avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect to the extent feasible. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.4-14 through 4.4-16 of the Draft EIR. Noise (vibration) Impact N-3 Construction of individual projects facilitated by the proposed project could temporarily generate groundborne vibration, potentially affecting nearby land uses. Policies in the 2040 General Plan would limit vibration disturbance and reduce high vibration levels during working construction hours to the extent feasible. However, construction vibration from pile-drivers may disturb people or damage buildings. Impacts would be less than significant with mitigation. MITIGATION MEASURE N-2 CONSTRUCTION VIBRATION REDUCTION MEASURES The following measures to minimize exposure to construction vibration shall be included as standard conditions of approval for applicable projects involving construction: 1. Building Examination. The pre-existing condition of any buildings within 25 feet of any construction activities shall be recorded in order to evaluate damage from project-related construction. Fixtures and finishes within a 25-foot radius of construction activities susceptible City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 22 to damage will be documented (photographically and in writing) prior to construction. All damage will be repaired back to its pre-existing condition. 2. Stationary Equipment. All vibratory stationary construction equipment shall be placed as far as possible from the nearest sensitive receptors. 3. Equipment Staging Areas. Equipment staging shall be located in areas that will create the greatest distance feasible between construction-related vibration sources and noise-sensitive receptors. FINDING The City finds that with incorporation of Mitigation Measure N-2, which requires construction vibration reduction measures, impacts from construction vibration would be reduced to a less than significant level. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15091 (a)(1), changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the proposed project that avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect to the extent feasible. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.11-15 through 4.11-17 of the Draft EIR. Tribal Cultural Resources Impact TCR-1 Development facilitated by the proposed project would involve land disturbance, which has the potential to disturb natural communities, expose buried cultural resources and by extension impact tribal cultural resources. These impacts would be less than significant with mitigation. MITIGATION MEASURE TCR-1 AVOIDANCE OF TRIBAL CULTURAL RESOURCES When feasible, development facilitated by the project shall be designed to avoid known tribal cultural resources. The feasibility of avoidance of tribal cultural resources shall be determined by the City and applicant in consultation with FIGR, as required by State law. MITIGATION MEASURE TCR-2 TRIBAL CULTURAL RESOURCE PLAN A Tribal Cultural Resources (TCR) Plan shall be required for development occurring in areas identified as potentially sensitive for tribal cultural resources during consultation with FIGR. If the project includes ground disturbance, the TCR Plan shall include a TCR treatment plan to be implemented in the event an unanticipated archaeological resource that may be considered a tribal cultural resource is identified during construction. In the event of an inadvertent discovery of tribal cultural resources or a Native American remain or burial, the TCR Plan shall require consultation with FIGR. The treatment plan shall include any necessary monitoring requirements, suspension of all earth-disturbing work in the vicinity of the find, avoidance of the resource or, if avoidance of the resource is infeasible, the plan shall outline the appropriate treatment of the resource in consultation with FIGR and, if applicable, a qualified archaeologist. Examples of appropriate treatment for tribal cultural resources include, but are not limited to, protecting the cultural character and integrity of the resource, protecting traditional use of the resource, preservation in place, protecting the confidentiality of the resource, or heritage recovery. CEQA Findings of Independent Judgment Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations 23 4922-9711-1443 v1 The TCR Plan and treatment plan shall be reviewed and approved by the City and FIGR to confirm compliance with this measure prior to construction. MITIGATION MEASURE TCR-3 NATIVE AMERICAN MONITORING For development occurring in areas identified as potentially sensitive for tribal cultural resources through consultation with FIGR, the project applicant shall retain a FIGR tribal monitor to observe all ground disturbance, including archaeological excavation, associated with development facilitated by the project. Monitoring methods and requirements shall be outlined in a tribal cultural resources treatment plan prepared as described above under Mitigation Measure TCR-2. In the event of a discovery of tribal cultural resources, the steps identified in the TCR treatment plan prepared under Mitigation Measure TCR-2 shall be implemented. MITIGATION MEASURE TCR-4 SENSITIVE LOCATION OF HUMAN REMAINS For any development facilitated by the project where human remains are expected to be present based on the results of tribal consultation and/or as identified by a qualified archaeologist, the City shall consult with FIGR and other local California Native American tribe(s) as applicable on the decision to employ a canine forensics team. Ifa canine forensics team is employed, the City shall require the team to attempt to identify human remains in a noninvasive way (e.g., non-excavation). Any requirements for the use of a canine forensics team shall be documented in the TCR treatment plan prepared under Mitigation Measure TCR-2. The TCR treatment plan may require revisions to the design of development facilitated by the project or an addendum to the treatment plan in the event that human remains are identified, with avoidance as set forth in TCR-1 as the preferred recommendation. For any development facilitated by the project, regardless of whether Native American remains or burials are expected to be present, in the event of an inadvertent discovery of tribal cultural resources or Native American remains or burials, the City shall consult with FIGR to determine the appropriate treatment, with a priority for avoidance as set forth in TCR-1. FINDING The City finds that with incorporation of Mitigation Measures TCR-1, TCR-2, TCR-3, and TCR-4, which require avoidance of tribal cultural resources, preparation of a tribal cultural resource plan, native American monitoring, and consultation for the sensitive location of human remains, impacts related to tribal cultural resources would be reduced to a less than significant level. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15091 (a)(1), changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the proposed project that avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect to the extent feasible. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.15-4 through 4.15-7 of the Draft EIR. Significant and Unavoidable Impacts The City Council, having reviewed and considered the information contained in the Final EIR and the record of proceedings, and pursuant to PRC Section 21081(a)(3) and CEQA Guidelines Section 15091(a)(3), makes the following findings with respect to impacts of the project that are significant and unavoidable. The City Council hereby finds that mitigation measures identified in the EIR that have been required in or incorporated into the project would lessen the following significant City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 24 environmental impacts but not to a less than significant level. These findings are based on the discussion of impacts in the detailed impact analyses in Section 4 of the Draft EIR as well as relevant responses to comments in the Final EIR. The findings below are for impacts where implementation of the project may result in the following significant, unavoidable environmental impacts, even with the implementation of mitigation measures. Greenhouse Gas Emissions (generate emissions, and conflict with greenhouse gas emission reduction plans) Impact GHG-1 Development facilitated by the proposed project would make progress towards achieving State goals but may not meet State 2030 or 2045 goals. Implementation Programs CC-A and CC-B would result in development of a Climate Action Plan (CAP) and implementation of CEQA greenhouse gas (GHG) thresholds; however, development facilitated by the proposed project is unlikely to meet the 2030 and 2045 goals until a CAP is developed and adopted. Therefore, this impact would be significant and unavoidable. FINDING With the implementation of General Plan Policies C-3.1, C-3.2, C-3.3, C-3.4, C-3.5, C-9.1, C-9.2, CD- 3.4, CD-3.5, CD-7.2, CD-7.3, PFS-3.3, PFS-3.4, PFS-3.7, C-5.1, C-6.4, CC-2.6, and C-8.2; and General Plan Implementation Programs CC-A and CC-B, development facilitated by the 2040 General Plan would be consistent with State emissions goals, once the CAP and CEQA thresholds are adopted. However, individual projects that may occur before Implementation Programs CC-A and CC-B are completed and fully implemented; therefore, development facilitated by the project would not be guaranteed to be consistent with State emissions goals, nor are exact emissions reductions known at the time of adoption of the 2040 General Plan. There are no reasonable or feasible mitigation measures that would ensure the completion of Implementation Programs CC-A and CC-B prior to new development allowed by the proposed project occurring within the city. Until the CEQA GHG thresholds are adopted and the CAP is developed, as required by General Plan Implementation Programs CC-A and CC-B, implementation of the proposed project would not be consistent with Bay Area Air District GHG thresholds, nor would it be consistent with State GHG reduction plans. There are no additional feasible mitigation measures that could reduce this potentially significant impact. Therefore, this impact would remain significant and unavoidable. The City finds that no mitigation measures or alternatives are feasible that would reduce this impact to less than significant levels. Since no feasible mitigation measures or project alternatives have been found to reduce the impact to a less than significant level, this impact remains significant and unavoidable. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.17-13 through 4.17-19 of the Draft EIR. CEQA Findings of Independent Judgment Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations 25 4922-9711-1443 v1 Noise (construction noise) Impact N-1 Construction of individual projects facilitated by the proposed project would temporarily generate increased noise levels, potentially affecting nearby noise-sensitive land uses. Provisions in the Rohnert Park Municipal Code and 2040 General Plan policies would limit noise disturbance to the extent feasible. However, construction noise may still exceed noise standards and impacts would be significant and unavoidable. Mitigation Measure N-1 below has been developed to address this potential impact. MITIGATION MEASURE N-1 CONSTRUCTION NOISE REDUCTION MEASURES The following measures to minimize exposure to construction noise shall be included as standard conditions of approval for applicable projects involving construction: 1. Mufflers. During excavation and grading construction phases, all construction equipment, fixed or mobile, shall be operated with closed engine doors and shall be equipped with properly operating and maintained mufflers consistent with manufacturers’ standards. 2. Stationary Equipment. All stationary construction equipment shall be placed so that emitted noise is directed away from the nearest sensitive receptors. 3. Equipment Staging Areas. Equipment staging shall be located in areas that will create the greatest distance feasible between construction-related noise sources and noise-sensitive receptors. 4. Smart Back-up Alarms. Mobile construction equipment shall have smart back-up alarms that automatically adjust the sound level of the alarm in response to ambient noise levels. Alternatively, back-up alarms shall be disabled and replaced with human spotters to ensure safety when mobile construction equipment is moving in the reverse direction FINDING Implementation of 2040 General Plan Policy HS-6.2, Rohnert Park Municipal Code requirements, and Mitigation Measure N-1 would reduce construction noise over ambient noise levels. However, implementation of Mitigation Measure N-1 would not ensure that all construction-related noise impacts would be reduced enough to not be considered a substantial increase in noise. No mitigation is available that would reduce impacts to a less than significant level. While implementation of Mitigation Measure N-1 would reduce impacts to the extent feasible, some project-specific impacts may be unavoidable. Therefore, the City finds that despite incorporation of Mitigation Measure N-1, which would require construction noise reduction measures, impacts related to construction noise would remain significant and unavoidable. The City finds that no other mitigation measures or alternatives are feasible that would reduce this impact to less than significant levels. Since no feasible mitigation measures or project alternatives have been found to reduce the impact to a less than significant level, this impact remains significant and unavoidable. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.11-10 through 4.11-12 of the Draft EIR. City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 26 Transportation and Traffic (vehicle miles traveled) Impact TRA-2 Roadway capacity improvements designed to accommodate development and population growth facilitated by the proposed project would increase VMT in Rohnert Park. In addition, development facilitated by the proposed project would increase VMT in the Plan Area and VMT per service population would not be 15 percent below the Citywide VMT per service population. Therefore, the proposed project would be inconsistent with CEQA Guidelines Section 15064.3(b). Impacts would be significant and unavoidable. FINDING While the implementation of 2040 General Plan goals, policies, and implementation programs (including implementation of Program C-E) may reduce Total VMT per Service Population, the City of Rohnert Park may not achieve the overall VMT reduction level required to reduce impacts as the effectiveness of VMT reductions strategies is not certain at this time. Disruptive changes to transportation such as transportation network companies (i.e., Uber, Lyft), increased delivery services (Amazon, UPS, FedEx, food, etc.), and autonomous vehicles may increase Total VMT per Service Population beyond forecast levels. There are no reasonable or feasible mitigation measures that could increase the effectiveness or guarantee the anticipated effectiveness of 2040 General Plan policies and programs that would reduce VMT. There are no additional feasible mitigation measures that could reduce this potentially significant impact. Therefore, this impact would remain significant and unavoidable. The City finds that no mitigation measures or alternatives are feasible that would reduce this impact to less than significant levels. Since no feasible mitigation measures or project alternatives have been found to reduce the impact to a less than significant level, this impact remains significant and unavoidable. SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE Pages 4.14-33 through 4.14-38 of the Draft EIR. Findings Regarding Alternatives Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations 27 4922-9711-1443 v1 4 Findings Regarding Alternatives CEQA requires that an EIR include an analysis of a reasonable range of feasible alternatives to a project capable of avoiding or substantially lessening any significant adverse environmental impact associated with the project. The discussion of alternatives is required to include the “No Project” alternative. CEQA requires further that the City identify an environmentally superior alternative. If the “No Project” alternative is the environmentally superior alternative, an environmentally superior alternative must be identified from among the other alternatives (CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.6). However, “CEQA did not require the City to choose the environmentally superior alternative. It simply required the City to consider environmentally superior alternatives, explain the considerations that led it to conclude that those alternatives were infeasible, weigh those considerations against the environmental harm that the Plan would cause, and make findings that the benefits of those considerations outweighed the harm” (California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Cal.App.4th 957, 1005-1006). Whether to reject or approve any of the alternatives is a decision only for the decision-makers. “They may reject alternatives that are undesirable from a policy standpoint as well as alternatives that fail to meet project objectives” (Ocean Street Extension Neighborhood Assn. v. City of Santa Cruz [2021] 73 Cal.App.5th 985, 1016). “While it is up to the EIR preparer to identify alternatives as potentially feasible, the decision-making body ’may or may not reject those alternatives as being infeasible‘ when it comes to project approval. Rejection by the decision-makers does not undermine the validity of the EIR's alternatives analysis” (California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz [2009] 177 Cal.App.4th 957, 999; 99 Cal.Rptr.3d 572, 602). Alternative 1: No Project Alternative Alternative 1 is comprised of a land use pattern that reflects the land use identified in the existing 2020 General Plan. Under this alternative, the proposed 2040 General Plan would not be adopted and the existing 2020 General Plan, including the land use map and all existing goals and policies, and the current 2023-2031 Housing Element, would remain in place through the horizon year of 2040. Thus, any new development in Rohnert Park would occur consistent with the existing land use designations and the allowed uses within each designation. Similarly, any new infrastructure in Rohnert Park would occur as envisioned in the 2020 General Plan. Development under this alternative compared to the proposed project provides less infill residential development and less dense residential development on infill or undeveloped properties within the City. This alternative would not include the Business Park (B-P) land use designation and the existing Industrial (I-L), and Regional Commercial (C-R) land use designations would remain in the northwest portion of the city, as shown on Figures 2-3 and 2-4 in Section 2, Project Description, of the Draft EIR. This alternative would not modify existing land use designations. Because this alternative would not include the higher density and infill residential development within developed areas of the city or the minor modifications to existing land use designations, overall development and anticipated growth would be reduced compared to the 2040 General Plan. Overall growth would be similar to that anticipated under the current 2020 General Plan with a potential buildout of approximately 6,031 dwelling units, a population of approximately 15,679, non-residential development of 2.4 million square feet, and 5,728 new jobs by the year 2040 (refer to Table 6-1 in Section 6, Alternatives, of the Draft EIR). This would be a reduction in overall development and growth City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 28 compared to the 2040 General Plan which anticipates a potential buildout of approximately 6,127 dwelling units, a population of approximately 15,844, non-residential development of 2.6 million square feet, and 6,165 new jobs by the year 2040 (refer to Table 6-1 in Section 6, Alternatives, of the Draft EIR). Finding Alternative 1 (No Project) assumes that the proposed 2040 General Plan would not be implemented. Future development would follow the existing 2020 General Plan, and no land use changes would occur. Significant and unavoidable impacts from GHG emissions, construction noise, and VMT would remain. However, the lack of policies reducing GHG emissions and construction noise in the 2020 General Plan compared to the proposed project would result in increased GHG and noise impacts. Alternative 1 would not achieve the VMT thresholds described in Section 4.14, Transportation and Traffic, of the Draft EIR. Additionally, Alternative 1 would not fulfill any Project Objectives because no General Plan update would be adopted, resulting in no changes to the land use plan and policies governing future development in the city. The City rejects Alternative 1 as infeasible because it would not achieve the objectives of the proposed project. Furthermore, Alternative 1 would result in greater impacts to air quality, biological resources, energy, GHG emissions, hazards and hazardous materials, land use and planning, noise, and transportation and traffic, as compared to the proposed project. Furthermore, Alternative 1 would not reduce any of the significant and unavoidable impacts of the 2040 General Plan to a less than significant level. The findings for the proposed project set forth in this document and the overriding social, economic and other considerations set forth in the Statement of Overriding Considerations provide support for the proposed project and the elimination of this alternative from further consideration. Supportive Evidence Pages 6-3 through 6-10 of the Draft EIR. Alternative 2: Environmental Conservation Alternative 2 would change the land use designations of property located north of Golf Course Drive West and west of Dowdell Avenue to “Environmental Conservation.” Existing rural residential uses would remain as non-conforming uses. This alternative would result in adoption of the 2040 General Plan; however, the total potential buildout by 2040 under this alternative would be reduced compared to the proposed project. This alternative would result in the following land use modification from the proposed 2040 General Plan land use designations: ▪ Add the Environmental Conservation (E-C) land use designation to approximately 33 acres in the northwest portion of the city, which would replace Business Park (B-P) land use designations north of Golf Course Drive West and west of Dowdell Avenue. All modified land uses from the proposed project land use designations are shown in Figure 6-1 in Section 6, Alternatives, of the Draft EIR. Under this alternative, development would occur over a smaller area as compared to the proposed project, with a reduced buildout potential of non-residential uses. Alternative 2 would allow for less development potential compared to the proposed project. Findings Regarding Alternatives Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations 29 4922-9711-1443 v1 Finding Alternative 2 (Environmental Conservation) would implement the proposed 2040 General Plan with reduced land uses in the northwest area of the City. Under this alternative, the significant and unavoidable impacts from GHG emissions, noise, and VMT would remain significant and unavoidable. However, the reduced overall development would reduce impacts related to noise and VMT. Overall, Alternative 2 would be considered the environmentally superior alternative, as most impacts are slightly reduced as a result of less overall development. Alternative 2 would not fulfill the Project Objectives to the same extent as the proposed project because the development potential under this alternative would provide a smaller amount of economic growth and population growth potential in the city. The City rejects Alternative 2 as infeasible because while it would fulfill some of the Project Objectives, it would do so to a lesser extent than the proposed project because the development potential under this alternative would provide a smaller amount of economic growth and population growth potential in the city. However, Alternative 2 would be consistent with proposed policies to support Racial, Social and Environmental Justice (by supporting adjacent tribal land use practices), Climate Change (by reducing emissions from development and enhancing resilience through land conservation) and Resource Conservation. The findings for the proposed project set forth in this document and the overriding social, economic and other considerations set forth in the Statement of Overriding Considerations provide support for the proposed project and the elimination of this alternative from further consideration. Supportive Evidence Pages 6-11 through 6-18 of the Draft EIR. Alternative 3: Workforce Housing Program Alternative 3 includes the proposed 2040 General Plan and associated land use changes described in Section 2, Project Description, in addition to a General Plan and Zoning Code change that would implement a Workforce Housing program throughout the City. The program would allow for the development of workforce housing, targeting lower income groups, on any site with a non- residential zoning designation, outside of the approved Specific Plan, Planned Development and Priority Development Areas, with no additional approvals required beyond the standard approvals for development per existing zoning designations. Practically, the City expects this Alternative would result in additional housing developed along Rohnert Park Expressway, west of Highway 101 and along Redwood Boulevard. This alternative would result in the future construction of approximately 400 workforce housing units throughout the city. These units are anticipated to be constructed on vacant land or under- utilized parking lots in existing commercial and industrial areas. The intent of this alternative is to provide additional housing options for low to median income earners and to provide more flexibility for meeting the City’s Regional Housing Needs Allocation. Alternative 3 would result in a greater residential unit count and population increase as the proposed project. Alternative 3 could result in a reduction in non-residential square footage and job count but for the purposes of analysis it is conservatively assumed that these will be same as the proposed project. City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 30 Finding Alternative 3 (Workforce Housing Program) would result in 400 additional housing units of low and median income housing in existing non-residential areas. While this alternative would result in increased residential development throughout the city, it would result in lower VMT per capita as the new residences would be on vacant land or under-utilized parking lots in existing commercial and industrial areas (e.g. along Rohnert Park Expressway west of Highway 101), which would result in reduced VMT per capita by approximately 1.3 percent as compared to the CEQA baseline. Under this alternative, the significant and unavoidable impacts from GHG emissions, noise, and VMT would remain significant and unavoidable, with GHG impacts remaining the same, noise impacts slightly increased due to the overall increase in development potential, and VMT impacts slightly decreased due to the decrease in VMT per capita. In general, Alternative 3 would have a similar impact to the majority of the remaining impact sections, as compared to the proposed project. Alternative 3 would fulfill all of the Project Objectives and provide additional options for meeting the RHNA allocation for the City of Rohnert Park. Development would occur within the same general areas where development would occur under the proposed project, with additional workforce housing units throughout the city in existing commercial and industrial areas, as described above. Alternative 3 would allow for increased development potential compared to the proposed project. Alternative 3 would fulfill all of the Project Objectives and provide the City with more flexibility to meet its Regional Housing Needs Allocation. The City rejects Alternative 3 as infeasible. Although this alternative creates additional housing opportunities, the proposed project already identifies a sufficient supply of sites to meet the City’s RHNA. Alternative 3 would reduce the available land supply for job and revenue creating uses, which is an important project objective. Alternative 3 would result in greater impacts to noise, as compared to the proposed project. Furthermore, Alternative 3 would not reduce any of the significant and unavoidable impacts of the 2040 General Plan to a less than significant level. The findings for the proposed project set forth in this document and the overriding social, economic and other considerations set forth in the Statement of Overriding Considerations provide support for the proposed project and the elimination of this alternative from further consideration. Supportive Evidence Pages 6-18 through 6-26 of the Draft EIR. Alternative 4: “Missing Middle Housing” West of Highway 101 Alternative 4 would replace the proposed 2040 General Plan land use changes for the Northwest and Wilfred Dowdell Specific Plan Areas (described in Section 2, Project Description, of the Draft EIR) with high density (R-H) residential zoning. This proposed change is shown in Figure 6-3 in Section 6, Alternatives, of the Draft EIR. Alternative 4 was assumed to include up to 450 new residential units and a reduction of 643,697 square feet of commercial/industrial development. Alternative 4 assumes that the 450 additional housing units are developed under the City’s current municipal code requirements, which would ensure 15 percent of the housing is affordable to lower-income households and that parkland is provided at a standard of 5 acres per 1,000 residents. Findings Regarding Alternatives Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations 31 4922-9711-1443 v1 The intent of this alternative is to provide additional “missing middle” housing options and to provide more flexibility for meeting the City’s Regional Housing Needs Allocation. Alternative 4 would result in a greater residential unit count and population increase as the proposed project and would result in a reduced non-residential square footage and job count compared to the proposed project. Development would occur within the same general areas where development would occur under the proposed project. Finding Alternative 4 (“Missing Middle Housing” West of Highway 101) would result in 450 additional housing units within the Northwest and Wilfred Dowdell Specific Plan Areas. While this alternative would result in increased residential development in specific plan areas and a reduction in non- residential development, it would result in lower VMT per capita of approximately 1.0 percent as compared to the CEQA baseline, as residents would be located closer to commercial services. Under this alternative, the significant and unavoidable impacts from GHG emissions, noise, and VMT would remain significant and unavoidable, with GHG impacts remaining the same, and noise and VMT impacts reduced due to the decreases in VMT per capita. In general, Alternative 4 would have a similar impact to the majority of the remaining impact sections, as compared to the proposed project. Alternative 4 would allow the City to focus its economic development and job creation resources on its two Priority Development Areas (Central Rohnert Park and SOMO Village), which may increase the effectiveness of those efforts. However, Alternative 4 would result in fewer sites for economic development activities overall. As such, Alternative 4 may not meet Project Objectives as well as the proposed project with respect to increased employment opportunities and economic development. The City rejects Alternative 4 as infeasible because it would result in greater impacts to population and housing, public services and recreation, and utilities and service systems, as a result of increased development. Furthermore, Alternative 4 would not reduce any of the significant and unavoidable impacts of the 2040 General Plan to a less than significant level. The findings for the proposed project set forth in this document and the overriding social, economic and other considerations set forth in the Statement of Overriding Considerations provide support for the proposed project and the elimination of this alternative from further consideration. Supportive Evidence Pages 6-26 through 6-34 of the Draft EIR. City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 32 5 Statement of Overriding Considerations CEQA requires the decision-making agency to balance the benefits of a project against its significant unavoidable impacts when determining whether to approve a project. If the benefits of the project outweigh its unavoidable adverse environmental effects, those effects may be considered acceptable (CEQA Guidelines Section 15093[a]). CEQA requires the agency to state in writing the specific reasons for considering a project acceptable when significant impacts are not avoided or substantially lessened. Those reasons must be based on substantial evidence in the Final EIR or elsewhere in the administrative record (CEQA Guidelines Section 15093[b]). The General Plan Update, as proposed, could result in significant unavoidable impacts related to GHG emissions, construction noise, and vehicle miles traveled. These significant unavoidable impacts are identified and discussed in Section 3 of the Findings. The City adopts and makes this Statement of Overriding Considerations regarding the significant unavoidable impacts and the anticipated benefits of the Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan. The City finds that each of the benefits set forth below in this Statement constitutes a separate and independent ground for finding that the benefits of the Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan outweigh the risks of their potential significant adverse environmental impacts. The benefits of the Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan, which constitute the specific economic, legal, social, technological and other considerations that justify the approval of the Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan are as follows: ▪ The proposed project would emphasize sustainable growth through well-planned development that provides for the needs of Rohnert Park’s residents and businesses, makes efficient use of land and infrastructure, protects important environmental resources, promotes the health of the community, and maintains the unique character of the City. ▪ The proposed project would emphasize infill and reuse development within the City limits with a focus on increasing opportunities for housing development in Priority Development Areas, Specific Plan areas, and infill corridors of the City through mixed-use projects where appropriate while revitalizing underused land. ▪ The proposed project would encourage development in Priority Development Areas in an effort to create a more equitable and inclusive city for all residents. ▪ The proposed project would support implementation of proposed racial, social, and environmental justice policies and programs and would reduce barriers to opportunity while promoting social and economic resilience. ▪ The proposed project encourages infill in areas near transit encouraging alternative modes of transportation and strengthening retail centers through increased pedestrian activity. ▪ The proposed project avoids land use conflicts by focusing new development in planned residential and mixed-use growth areas and by maintaining appropriate transitions between residential neighborhoods and employment-serving districts, thereby minimizing the potential for incompatible land uses. The project protects industrial land from incompatible uses and retains significant areas for activity in the innovation economy. ▪ The proposed project provides for increased housing opportunities relative to the existing General Plan, allowing the City to meet its Regional Housing Needs Allocation and retain a legally compliant Housing Element. Statement of Overriding Considerations Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations 33 4922-9711-1443 v1 ▪ The proposed project would provide a well-connected transportation system that emphasizes improved connections between different modes of transportation, and enables safe access for all transportation modes, including pedestrians, bicyclists, motorists, and transit riders of all ages and abilities. ▪ The proposed project would promote fair and equitable access for all residents to employment, housing, parks, education, recreation, transportation, retail, and public services, including participation in governmental decision-making. ▪ The proposed project includes multiple commercial and industrial designations corresponding to different employment types, providing opportunities for businesses and jobs in all sectors of the economy. ▪ The proposed project responds to the changing nature of the retail and office markets and includes proactive measures to maintain the vibrancy of the City’s neighborhood commercial centers and create a new Downtown. ▪ The proposed project would generate substantial local employment opportunities, improving the City’s jobs-housing balance and supporting job opportunities for Rohnert Park residents. ▪ The proposed project would increase local tax revenues and economic output, thereby enhancing the City’s fiscal stability and its ability to fund public services and infrastructure. ▪ The proposed project would advance local economic development objectives by expanding the supply of land uses that support business retention, investment, and long-term competitiveness within the region. Rohnert Park would remain a competitive and innovative business destination. ▪ The proposed project supports continued partnerships and collaboration with Sonoma State University, as well as strengthened partnerships and coordination with the Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria. ▪ The proposed project would provide housing opportunities that meet the existing and future needs of all residents and the objectives of the State of California in promoting affordable housing. ▪ The project would provide for a city that improves the ability of individuals, communities, economic systems, and the natural and built environments to withstand, recover from, and adapt to changes from natural hazards, human-made disasters, climate change, and economic shifts. ▪ The proposed project was shaped by an extensive public outreach process that engaged the community and decision-makers. The City hosted a series of community workshops and forums, pop-workshops, online surveys, stakeholder interviews and meetings, and Planning Commission/City Council study sessions. The proposed project incorporates this input and represents the desires of the community as a whole in shaping the future of the City. ▪ The proposed project updates outdated policies in a manner that meets current legal requirements for General Plans. ▪ The proposed project incorporates recently adopted plans and programs such as the Active Transportation Plan and the Parks and Recreation Master Plan, as well as area plans and specific plans prepared since the last General Plan Update. City of Rohnert Park Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan 34 ▪ The proposed project provides a more user-friendly document that will make use of the General Plan easier for decision-makers, staff, and the public. On balance, the City finds that there are specific beneficial considerations associated with the Rohnert Park 2040 General Plan that serve to override and outweigh 2040 General Plan’s significant unavoidable effects. Therefore, pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15093(b), these adverse effects are considered acceptable.