Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout04-23-26 PACKET ROHNERT PARK PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING Thursday, April 23, 2026 Open Session: 6:00 P.M. MEETING LOCATION: CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBER Address: 130 Avram Avenue, Rohnert Park, California PUBLIC PARTICIPATION: The Rohnert Park Planning Commission welcomes your attendance, interest, and participation at its regular meetings scheduled on the Second and Fourth Thursday of each month at 6:00 p.m. in the Council Chambers. Members of the public are encouraged to observe the meeting on Cable Channel 26 by visiting meeting central on our website https://www.rpcity.org/city_hall/city_council/meeting_central PUBLIC COMMENTS: Provides an opportunity for public comment on items not listed on the agenda, or on agenda items if unable to comment at the scheduled time. Speakers are encouraged to complete a Public Comment card and submit it to the Secretary at the time of the meeting. This helps ensure an orderly and efficient meeting, but it is not required. Members of the public may also provide advanced comments by email at Planning@rpcity.org. Comments are requested by 5:00 p.m. on the day of the meeting. Email comments must identify the Agenda Item Number in the subject line of the email. The emails will not be read for the record but will be provided to the Planning Commission. Please note that all emails sent to the Planning Commission are considered to be public records and subject to disclosure under the California Public Records Act. Planning Commission agendas and minutes may be viewed at the City’s website: www.rpcity.org NOTE: If you challenge the nature of the proposed action in court, you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing(s) described in this agenda, or in written correspondence delivered to the City of Rohnert Park at, or prior to the public hearing(s). RIGHT TO APPEAL: Pursuant to Rohnert Park Municipal Code Article XII, Any person may file an appeal of the Planning Commission’s action on agenda items within ten (10) calendar days. When the period for an appeal ends on a weekend or city holiday, the last day to file the appeal shall be extended to the next working day. 1. REGULAR MEETING CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL 2. READING OF THE LAND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT The City of Rohnert Park acknowledges Indigenous Peoples as the traditional stewards of the land. Let it be acknowledged that the City of Rohnert Park is located within the traditional homeland of the Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria, comprised of Coast Miwok and Southern Pomo peoples. 3. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 4. PUBLIC COMMENT – Persons who wish to speak to the Commission on any Consent Calendar item or an item that is not on the agenda may do so at this time. Each speaker will be allotted three minutes. Please see page 1 for details on how to submit public comments. 5. CONSENT CALENDAR – All items on the Consent Calendar will be considered together by one or more action(s) of the Commission, whichever is applicable, unless any Commission Member or anyone else interested in a consent calendar item has a question about the item. Commissioner Motion/Vote: (Lam___ Campbell___ Austin-Dillon___ Epstein___ Orloff___) 5.1 Approval of the Draft Minutes of the Planning Commission Regular Meeting of April 9, 2026 (This action is not a Project under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA)) 6. REGULAR ITEMS 6.1 Study Session #2, Review Draft Objective Design Standards (CEQA Status: Not a Project) No action is required at this time. 7. ITEMS FROM THE PLANNING COMMISSION 8. ITEMS FROM THE DEVELOPMENT SERVICES STAFF 9. ADJOURNMENT NOTE: Time shown for any particular matter on the agenda is an estimate only. Matters may be considered earlier or later than the time indicated, depending on the pace at which the meeting proceeds. If you wish to speak on an item under discussion by the Commission that appears on this agenda, please refer to page 1 for more details on submitting a public comment. Any item raised by a member of the public that is not on the agenda and may require Commission action shall be automatically referred to staff for investigation and disposition, which may include placing on a future agenda. If the item is deemed to be an emergency or the need to take action arose after posting of the agenda within the meaning of Government Code Section 54954.2(b), the Commission is entitled to discuss the matter to determine if it is an emergency item under said Government Code and may take action thereon. AGENDA REPORTS & DOCUMENTS: A paper copy of all staff reports and documents subject to disclosure that relate to each item of business referred to on the agenda is available for public inspection at City Hall, 130 Avram Avenue, Rohnert Park, California 94928. Electronic copies of all staff reports and documents subject to disclosure that relate to each item of business referred to on the agenda are available for public inspection at https://www.rpcity.org/city_hall/city_council/meeting_central. Any writings or documents subject to disclosure that are provided to all, or a majority of all, of the members of the Planning Commission regarding any item on this agenda after the agenda has been distributed will be made available for inspection at City Hall and on our website at the same time. Any writings or documents subject to disclosure that are provided to the Planning Commission during the meeting will be made available for public inspection during the meeting and on our website following the meeting. AMERICAN DISABILITY ACT ACCOMMODATIONS: Any member of the public who needs accommodations should email the ADA Coordinator at adacoordinator@rpcity.org or by calling 707-588-2224. The ADA Coordinator will use their best efforts to provide reasonable accommodations to provide as much accessibility as possible while also maintaining public safety in accordance with the City's procedure for resolving reasonable accommodation requests. Information about reasonable accommodations is available on the City website at: https://www.rpcity.org/city_hall/departments/human_resources/a_d_a_and_accessibility_resources CERTIFICATION OF POSTING OF AGENDA I, Clotile Blanks, Community Development Technician for the City of Rohnert Park, declare that the foregoing agenda was posted and available for review on April 17, 2026, at Rohnert Park City Hall, 130 Avram Avenue, Rohnert Park, California 94928. The agenda is available on the City of Rohnert Park’s website at www.rpcity.org. Signed this 17th day of April 2026, at Rohnert Park, California. Clotile Blanks Minutes of the Planning Commission Meeting of the City of Rohnert Park Thursday, April 9, 2026 6:00 P.M. 130 Avram Avenue, Rohnert Park 1. CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL Chairperson Fanny Lam called the regular meeting to order at 6:02 p.m. Present: Fanny Lam, Chairperson Tim Campbell, Vice Chairperson Matt Epstein, Commissioner Marc Orloff, Commissioner Absent: Tramaine Austin-Dillon, Commissioner 2. READING OF THE LAND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Read by Chairperson Lam 3. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Led by Chairperson Lam 4. PUBLIC COMMENT None 5. CONSENT CALENDAR – ADOPTION OF MINUTES 5.1 Approval of the Draft Minutes of the Planning Commission Regular Meeting of March 12, 2026 ACTION: Moved/Seconded (Orloff/Epstein) to approve the Minutes of the Planning Commission Regular Meeting of March 12, 2026. Motion carried by the following 4-0-1 roll call vote: AYES: Lam, Campbell, Epstein, Orloff; ABSTAIN: None; ABSENT: Austin-Dillon 6. REGULAR ITEMS 6.1 Conduct a Public Hearing to Consider Adopting Resolution 2026-05 approving a Sign Program for Edgeway Plaza located at 7301 Camino Colegio and East Cotati Avenue, (143-340-061 & 158-270-065), File No. PLSI24-0026 (Categorically exempt under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), Class 1 Exemption under Section 15301: Existing Facility) Planning Consultant Christina Ratcliffe presented the proposed Sign Program for Edgeway Plaza and responded to questions from the Planning Commission regarding monument signs and the overall sign program. Applicant Nalin Wangel-Komisar of FastSigns provided information regarding the sign application and responded to questions from the Commissioners concerning the proposed Edgeway Plaza sign program. Commissioner Epstein moved to approve the sign program for PLSI24-0026, including all signage except for the third (3rd) monument sign, and to modify Condition No. 5 to amend the wording so that the building permits for the monument signs can be issued either prior to or concurrently with other sign permits. Commissioner Orloff seconded the motion. ACTION: Moved/Seconded (Epstein/Orloff) to approve Resolution 2026-05 with Exhibit and to rephrase Condition 1 of the Resolution to state: “except that the third (3rd) monument sign that is not constructed shall be removed from the sign program.” And that Condition No. 5 be amended so that the building permits for the monument signs can be issued either prior to or concurrently with other sign permits. Motion carried by the following (4-0-1) roll call vote: AYES: Lam, Campbell, Epstein, Orloff; NOES: None; ABSENT: Austin-Dillon 7. ITEMS FROM PLANNING COMMISSION Commissioner Epstein asked to include design standards for wildland deterrent construction, where feasible, in the Objective Design Standards. Chairperson Lam indicated that she would have work commitments and would be unavailable for the April 23, 2026, Planning Commission Meeting. 8. ITEMS FROM DEVELOPMENT SERVICES STAFF Planning Consultant Ratcliffe stated that there will be a Planning Commission Meeting on April 23, 2026, for the second workshop on the Objective Design Standards. 9. ADJOURNMENT Chairperson Fanny Lam adjourned the Planning Commission Meeting at 6:49 p.m. _____________________________ ________________________________ Fanny Lam, Chairperson Clotile Blanks, Recording Secretary 1 City of Rohnert Park Planning Commission Report Meeting Date: April 23, 2026 Item No: 6.1 Prepared by: Planning Consultant (M-Group); Tom Ford and Lorrin French Agenda Title: Study Session #2, Review Draft Objective Standards (CEQA Status: Not a Project) RECOMMENDED ACTION Receive a staff presentation on the Draft Objective Design Standards (Attachment 1) and provide comments and direction in response to the staff questions included in the Recommended Action section below. No action is required at this time. BACKGROUND Recent changes in State housing law require jurisdictions to establish a ministerial (“by-right”) development review process for qualifying housing development projects as defined in California Government Code Section 65589.5(h)(2). Under a ministerial process, applications must be reviewed using objective, measurable standards rather than subjective design guidance or discretionary judgment. Rohnert Park’s adopted Housing Element commits the City to adopting Objective Design Standards to support its housing goals in compliance with State law. At the December 11, 2025 Planning Commission meeting, the City’s planning consultant, M- Group, conducted a study session to solicit input on the objective standards, and the Planning Commission identified the following focus areas: • Fire Safety and Wildland-Urban Interface. Commissioners emphasized a need for fire- safe and fire-resistant design as a top priority, citing recent wildfire events and the City’s location within the wildland-urban interface. • Site Design and Public Safety. Commissioners raised concerns related to site access and circulation, including pedestrian and vehicle conflicts, ingress and egress from adjacent uses and properties, and pedestrian safety along major thoroughfares. 2 • Community Character and General Plan Consistency. Commissioners highlighted the importance of maintaining community character as articulated in the General Plan, including preservation of views toward the Petaluma Hills, use of native and drought- tolerant landscaping, and requiring fire-resistant building materials. Since the December Planning Commission meeting, M-Group has prepared a draft Objective Design Standards document for the Planning Commission’s consideration. FIRE SAFETY STANDARDS Fire safety emerged as a key priority during the Planning Commission’s discussion. In response, the consultant team conducted additional research and developed the following standards: • Standard 5.2: Defensible Space Establishes defensible space requirements for site landscaping, including irrigation of all landscape features, and limiting plant height and tree canopies near buildings. • Standard 9.3: Enclosed Eaves and Gutters Requires all eaves and gutters to be enclosed to prevent accumulation of wind-borne embers. • Standard 9.4: Roof and Attic Vents Requires ember-resistant roof and attic vents in compliance with California Building Code Chapter 7A. • Standard 11.3: Prohibited Glazing Prohibits the use of reflective window glazing due to concerns identified by the Commission regarding its potential to act as an ignition source. • Standard 12: Enclosed Projections Requires all decks, balconies, patios, and other architectural projections to be fully enclosed from the underside to prevent accumulation of wind-borne embers. • Standard 13.2: Fire Resistant Building Materials Requires all exterior building materials and components to have a Class-A fire-resistance rating as defined in the California Building Code. OBJECTIVE DESIGN STANDARDS DOCUMENT M-Group developed the Objective Design Standards document to address a variety of design topics, centered around two primary categories: site design and building design. The document is structured and summarized as follows: 3 Introduction This section establishes the ministerial review process for housing development projects, which are defined in California Government Code Section 65589.5(h)(2) as: • A project with residential units only • Mixed-use housing projects with at least two-thirds of the project’s gross square footage designated for residential use • Transitional housing or supportive housing • Farmworker housing, as defined in the Health and Safety Code Definitions This section defines terms used in the standards that are not otherwise defined in Chapter 17.04 of the Zoning Code. Site Design This section establishes standards for how buildings, circulation, open space, and site infrastructure are arranged within a development to support a pedestrian-oriented public realm. 1. Building Placement and Orientation Requires buildings to orient their front façade toward a public street, common open space, or designated pedestrian walkway, with additional standards governing frontage features such as entries and openings. 2. Vehicular Access and Parking Areas Establishes standards for the location and design of vehicular access and surface parking areas to limit curb cuts, reduce vehicle–pedestrian conflicts, and minimize visual impacts along public streets through requirements for placement, screening, landscaping, and internal circulation. Landscape screening and lighting requirements are internally consistent with Chapter 17.16.100 of the Rohnert Park Municipal Code (RPMC). 3. Pedestrian Access and Circulation Establishes standards for pedestrian walkways and internal circulation to ensure safe and convenient connections between buildings, parking areas, open spaces, and public sidewalks while minimizing conflicts with vehicles. 4. Open Space Augments the minimum requirements in RPMC Chapter 17.10.020 by establishing additional standards for the design and usability of common and private open space. 5. Landscaping Establishes standards for landscape coverage, defensible space for fire safety, plant selection, and site lighting. 6. Utility Facilities and Service Areas Establishes standards for the location, screening, and design of utility equipment and service areas, including mechanical equipment, meters, transformers, and trash and recycling enclosures. 4 Building Design Establishes standards for building form, façade organization, architectural elements, and materials to create clear architectural hierarchy and articulation, reduce perceived mass, and reinforce a consistent relationship between buildings and the street. 7. Façade Articulation Establishes standards for façade organization through vertical and horizontal articulation to reduce perceived mass and create a consistent architectural rhythm. Vertical articulation divides façades into a base, middle, and top to establish hierarchy, while horizontal articulation breaks long façades into modules and bays to introduce variation and visual interest. 8. Massing Establishes standards to limit building length and require massing features, such as towers, step-backs, projections, or recesses; to break up large volumes and reduce perceived scale. 9. Roof Design Establishes roof articulation standards that require variation to reinforce façade organization. Regulates dormer size and placement, allows limited eave encroachments, and requires ember-resistant vents and enclosed eaves consistent with Chapter 7A of the California Building Code for fire safety. 10. Ground Floor Design Establishes standards for ground-floor height, transparency, frontage placement, and frontage types to strengthen the relationship between buildings and the street. Requirements include usable interior space, adequate transparency and entries along public-facing façades, and frontage types such as stoops, porches, patios, galleries, and shopfronts that create active, pedestrian-oriented street frontages. 11. Fenestration Establishes standards for the design and placement of windows and openings to provide architectural detail, maintain privacy between adjacent buildings, and prohibit reflective glazing. 12. Enclosed Projections Requires decks, balconies, patios, and similar projections to have fully enclosed undersides to comply with Chapter 7A of the California Building Code and reduce the risk of ignition from wind-borne embers. 13. Building Materials Establishes standards for the use and arrangement of exterior building materials by limiting the number of materials and colors, requiring appropriate transitions between materials, and requiring compliance with Class A fire-resistance standards in the California Building Code. 5 RECOMMENDED ACTION Staff recommends that the Planning Commission discuss the following topics and provide any necessary direction for the Objective Design Standards: 1. Fire Safety Staff requests that the Planning Commission input on the following fire safety considerations: • Should fire safety standards apply citywide, or be limited to projects within designated Wildland–Urban Interface (WUI) areas? A map of Rohnert Park’s WUI is provided in Attachment 2. • Does the Planning Commission have concerns regarding the potential cost implications associated with requiring Class A materials? The conclusion of a Fall 2025 report, provided as Attachment 3, indicates this requirement may increase construction costs by approximately 2 percent. 2. Site Design Staff requests that the Planning Commission provide direction on the following site design considerations: • Should the required landscape buffer between buildings and pedestrian walkways be reduced when a building faces the walkway? If so, what minimum buffer is appropriate? Standard 3.4(b) currently requires a minimum 5- foot landscape buffer for ground floor residential frontages. 3. Building Design Staff requests that the Planning Commission provide direction on the following building design consideration: • Should façade organization requirements apply to buildings of three stories or less, or be limited to taller buildings? Standard 7 requires buildings to incorporate horizontal and vertical articulation to visually organize building façades. NEXT STEPS: Planning Commission Hearing – Public Draft Objective Design Standards (Spring/Summer 2026) City Council Review and Adoption (Summer 2026) ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS: Not a project under CEQA. PUBLIC NOTIFICATION: Not a public hearing; no notice required. 6 Attachments: 1. Draft Objective Design Standards 2. Council Resolution 987 Wildland-Urban Interface Map 3. Construction Costs for Wildfire-Resistant Homes Fall 2025 City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards Attachment 1 Contents Introduction ....................................................................................................................................................... 2 Definitions .......................................................................................................................................................... 3 Site Design.......................................................................................................................................................... 4 1. Building Orientation ............................................................................................................ 4 2. Vehicular Access and Parking Areas .................................................................................... 4 3. Pedestrian Access and Circulation ...................................................................................... 7 4. Open Space ......................................................................................................................... 8 5. Landscaping ......................................................................................................................... 9 6. Utility Facilities and Service Areas .................................................................................... 11 Building Design ............................................................................................................................................... 14 7. Façade Articulation ........................................................................................................... 14 8. Massing ............................................................................................................................. 16 9. Roof Design ....................................................................................................................... 19 10. Ground Floor Design ..................................................................................................... 20 11. Fenestration .................................................................................................................. 32 12. Enclosed Projections ..................................................................................................... 33 13. Building Materials ......................................................................................................... 33 City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 2 Introduction Purpose The purpose of these Objective Design Standards is to establish requirements for qualifying multi-family housing projects that result in high-quality design outcomes and support a pedestrian-oriented public realm. This document is intended to provide design direction for property owners, applicants, and City staff with standards that are uniformly verifiable and involve no personal or subjective judgment, in compliance with State law. California Government Code Section 65589.5(h)(2) defines a housing development project to consist of any of the following: • A project with residential units only • Mixed-use housing projects with at least two-thirds of the project’s gross square footage designated for residential use; as conditioned by subsections (B)(i) through (iii). • Transitional housing or supportive housing • Farmworker housing, as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 50199.7 of the Health and Safety Code Applicability Where a housing development project is subject to ministerial design review pursuant to State law, the objective standards in this document shall serve as the criteria for project evaluation. These standards may also inform the evaluation of projects subject to discretionary review. All other applicable development standards shall continue to apply, including but not limited to the following: • City of Rohnert Park General Plan • City of Rohnert Park Municipal Code • Central Rohnert Park PDA Plan – Residential Guidelines • Design Guidelines for Commercial, Residential, and Multi-Family Buildings • Downtown District Amenity Zone Overlay District Standards • SOMO Village Design Guidelines • SOMO Village Development Standards • University District Design Guidelines • Wilfred Dowdell Specific Plan Development Standards and Guidelines Organization Objective design standards are organized into two primary sections: Site Design and Building Design. Site Design includes standards addressing building orientation and placement; vehicular access and parking; pedestrian access and circulation; open space; landscaping; and utility City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 3 facilities and service areas. Building Design includes standards addressing building massing; roof design; façade articulation; ground-floor design; material use; and fenestration. Conflicts Where a conflict exists between the objective standards contained in this document and any uniformly verifiable development standards applicable to a Planned Development District, Overlay District, and/or Special Area, in Chapter 17.06 in the Code of Ordinances, the development standard(s) applicable to that district or area shall prevail. Definitions Terms and words used in this document are defined pursuant to Rohnert Park Municipal Code Chapter 17.04, unless otherwise defined by this section. Building, front: The façade of a building designated as the building front by the project applicant. Building, length: The maximum horizontal dimension of a building measured parallel to the building front, side, or rear; measured across projections, recesses, or changes in plane along the façade. Building, side: Any façade of a building that is not the building front or building rear. Projections, recesses, or changes in plane along a façade do not constitute additional building sides. Building, rear: The side of a building opposite the building front. Bulkhead: A low, solid wall at the base of a storefront window. Corner, inside: The junction of two building façade planes forming an interior (concave) angle. Designated Pedestrian Walkway: A public or private sidewalk, path, or marked walkway provided as part of a development project intended exclusively for pedestrian travel. Drive Aisle: An internal vehicular travel lane within a parking area that provides access to parking spaces, garages, or loading areas and is not a public or private street. Floor, finished: The top surface of a completed floor, including the finished flooring material. Frontage type: A classification of the ground-floor building frontage based on its physical form and relationship to the adjacent street, designated pedestrian walkway, or common open space. Oriented to, toward: Positioned such that an unobstructed view is maintained to or from a specified feature or location. City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 4 Private Street: A privately owned and maintained vehicular circulation route that provides access to lots, buildings, or dwelling units and includes sidewalks or pedestrian pathways. A private street is not considered a parking lot drive aisle. Site Design Site design standards establish how buildings and site elements are positioned and connected on a project site. 1. Building Orientation The front of any building shall be oriented to a public street, private street, or designated pedestrian walkway. The side or rear of a building shall not front a public right-of-way, except on corner lots, where the side of any building fronting a public right-of-way shall not exceed sixty (60) feet in length. Figure 1: Building Orientation 2. Vehicular Access and Parking Areas 2.1. Vehicular Access Vehicular access points shall meet all of the following requirements. Access points used exclusively for emergency vehicle access are exempt from these standards. For redevelopment projects, existing vehicular access points can be retained; however, City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 5 retained access points shall count toward the maximum number of vehicular access points permitted by this section. a. The maximum number of vehicular access points along a public right-of-way shall comply with Table 2.1.a. Table 2.1.a: Maximum Vehicular Access Points Lot Frontage Access Points 0 to 150 feet 1 150 feet to 299 feet 2 Each additional 300 feet beyond 299 feet 1 b. A minimum separation of thirty (30) feet shall be provided between vehicular access points on the subject property and any vehicular access points on adjacent properties, measured from the outside edge of curb cut to the outside edge of curb cut. c. Any vehicular access point shall be located a minimum of seventy-five (75) feet from the nearest street corner, defined as the intersection of the projected extensions of the sidewalk edges, measured along the sidewalk to the nearest edge of the curb cut. 2.2. Surface Parking Areas a. Surface parking areas exceeding six (6) parking stalls shall not be located between the front of a building and a public right-of-way. b. Individual surface parking areas shall not exceed ten thousand (10,000) square feet and shall be separated by at least thirty (30) feet. c. No more than six (6) consecutive parking stalls shall be permitted without a tree well or tree well finger extending from a landscape strip. Tree wells and tree well fingers shall have a minimum dimension of four (4) feet. 2.3. Surface Parking Screening and Landscaping Surface parking areas adjacent to a public right-of-way and/or common open space shall be screened from view with a landscaped area that meets all of the following requirements. a. Provide landscaping that reaches a minimum mature height of three (3) feet, unless otherwise specified for defensible space in Standard 5.2. City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 6 b. For non-residential parking areas, provide perimeter planting areas with a minimum width of ten (10) feet where adjacent to a residential zoning district and five (5) feet where adjacent to all other zoning districts. c. Provide screening along at least sixty (60) percent of the length of any surface parking area perimeter that faces a public right of way, exclusive of drive aisles and vehicular access points. d. Provide trees in all perimeter landscaping areas with a clear height of no less than ten (10) feet and spaced at intervals of no greater than thirty (30) feet, unless the landscape area is otherwise specified as defensible space in Standard 5.2. e. Provide a minimum tree canopy shade coverage of forty (40) percent of the area occupied by parking stalls at tree maturity. Carport structures with solar panels that provide shade may be used as an alternative to this requirement. f. Trees shall be provided in parking areas at a minimum ratio of one (1) tree for every four (4) parking stalls. Figure 2.3: Surface Parking Screening and Landscaping City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 7 2.4. Garage Access and Placement Attached and detached garages serving individual units shall be located at the side or rear of a building and accessed from an internal driveway, drive aisle, or alley. Garages shall be set back at least ten (10) feet from the front façade on any building. 3. Pedestrian Access and Circulation 3.1. Walkway Width Any designated pedestrian walkway shall maintain a minimum clear width of four (4) feet. 3.2. Walkway Connectivity In projects with five (5) or more units, designated pedestrian walkways shall form a continuous internal network connecting all buildings, primary pedestrian entrances, common open spaces, and parking areas. The network shall provide a direct pedestrian connection to a public sidewalk for all units through a primary building entry or individual unit entries. 3.3. Vehicle Conflicts Where a designated pedestrian walkway intersects with a drive aisle and/or surface parking area, a pedestrian crossing shall be provided that meets the following requirements: a. The pedestrian crossing shall have a minimum width of six (6) feet. b. The pedestrian crossing shall be demarcated with decorative paving materials or paint colors contrasting with the vehicular circulation material. Decorative paving materials can include brick, patterned or colored concrete, stone blocks, and pavers. c. At minimum, for every one-hundred and eighty (180) linear feet of vehicle circulation area and/or surface parking frontage, a pedestrian crossing shall be provided. 3.4. Pedestrian Buffer Zones Pedestrian buffer zones shall only be required for ground floor frontages with a residential use. a. Designated pedestrian walkways abutting a public street shall include a landscaped buffer between the sidewalk and the street. The buffer shall have a minimum depth of four (4) feet and shall be raised a minimum of six (6) inches above the adjacent street grade. City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 8 b. When a building is oriented toward a designated pedestrian walkway, a minimum of five (5) feet of landscaping shall be provided between the building and the walkway. Figure 3: Pedestrian Access and Circulation 4. Open Space The minimum open space requirement is provided in the Development Standards Table in Chapter 17.10.020 of the Municipal Code. To meet this requirement, open space shall be usable and designed and improved for active or passive outdoor use by residents and/or the public. The open space requirement can be met with common open space, private open space, or both. 4.1. Common Open Space Common open space is defined an open area within a residential or commercial development reserved for the exclusive use of the residents or employees of the development and guests. Common open space can include courtyards, greens, plazas, paseos, rooftop decks, or similar areas designed for active or passive use. Common open space shall meet the following requirements: a. At least sixty (60) percent of a common open space area shall be free of permanent weather protection or overhead human-made encroachments. Tree canopy or foliage is not considered an overhead encroachment. City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 9 b. Common open spaces shall include passive recreational features such as benches, tables and chairs, trails, social gathering areas, and children’s play areas. c. Elevated common open space, including rooftop decks and podium courtyards located above the first habitable floor, shall not be oriented toward adjacent single- family-zoned lots and shall be located a minimum of eighty (80) feet from any lot line shared with an adjacent single-family-zoned lot. The combined area of all elevated common open space on a single building shall not exceed fifty (50) percent of the rooftop area. This standard shall not apply in the Downtown District Amenity Zone (DDAZ) Overlay District. d. Lighting for common open space shall be shielded and downlit and shall not exceed three (3) footcandles measured at grade. 4.2. Private Open Space Private open space is defined as a usable open space adjoining and directly accessible to a dwelling unit, reserved for the exclusive use of residents of the dwelling unit and their guests. Private open space includes balconies, patios, and porches and shall meet the following requirements: a. Private open space shall have a minimum area of forty (40) square feet and a minimum clear dimension of five (5) feet any each direction. b. All private open space shall be outdoors. 5. Landscaping 5.1. Landscape Coverage Any required landscape areas or unused site areas shall consist of at least forty (40) percent living plant material. Non-vegetated surfaces such as decorative gravel, decomposed granite, bark, or hardscape shall not be counted toward the minimum vegetation coverage. Bare ground is not permitted. 5.2. Defensible Space For fire safety purposes, all landscape planting shall be irrigated. Vegetation within five (5) feet of any building façade shall not exceed eighteen (18) inches in height at maturity. A minimum horizontal separation of ten (10) feet shall be provided between any tree canopy at maturity and any portion of a building. City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 10 Figure 5.2: Defensible Space 5.3. Plant Species The use of artificial plants or turf, and plants identified as invasive by the California Invasive Plant Council is prohibited. 5.4. Lighting Lighting shall be provided for all parking areas and structures, designated pedestrian walkways, drive aisle and pedestrian intersections, and service areas, including waste enclosures. Light fixtures shall meet the following requirements: a. All lighting, reflective surfaces or any other sources of illumination shall be utilized in a manner that produces no glare on public streets or on any other parcel. b. Any lighting provided for a public street shall follow the City’s manual of standards. c. Light fixtures mounted on poles or building façades shall not exceed a maximum mounting height of twenty (20) feet above finished grade. d. All light fixtures shall be fully shielded and downlit, with the light source directed no more than thirty (30) degrees below the horizontal plane. Lighting shall be oriented to prevent direct illumination onto adjacent residentially zoned properties. City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 11 e. Lighting used to illuminate landscaped areas shall not exceed a maximum fixture height of thirty-six (36) inches above finished grade. f. Low-pressure sodium lamps, standard mercury vapor lamps, and light sources with a color temperature exceeding three thousand five hundred (3,500) Kelvin (K) are prohibited. g. Uplighting of trees and building façades is prohibited. h. Permanent lighting within trees is prohibited. i. For regulations regarding the illumination of signage, please refer to the sign ordinance. Figure 5.4: Lighting 6. Utility Facilities and Service Areas 6.1. Location Exterior utility facilities and service areas shall not be located between the front of a building and property lines along a public right-of-way unless screened by vegetative landscaping or a barrier with a height at least equal to the height of the equipment being screened. Exterior utility facilities and mechanical equipment shall include the following: City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 12 a. Garbage, compost, and recycling areas or receptacles b. Utility boxes, electric and gas meters, transformers, and similar equipment. c. Rooftop mechanical equipment, not including solar panels or other green infrastructure that relies on access to the sun or wind for power generation. d. Air conditioning units, heat pumps, and similar equipment. e. Water or sewer lifts, pumps, and/or back-flow preventers 6.2. Utility and Mechanical Equipment Screening All exterior utility facilities and mechanical equipment shall be fully screened from public view by architectural features and/or landscaping. Visibility shall be evaluated from the following vantage points: a. For rooftop equipment, visibility shall be evaluated from a point five (5) feet above finished grade at a horizontal distance of two hundred (200) feet from the building; and b. For ground-level equipment, visibility shall be evaluated from a point five (5) feet above finished grade at a horizontal distance of fifty (50) feet from the equipment. (Continued on next page) City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 13 Figure 6.2: Utility and Mechanical Equipment Screening 6.3. Trash and Recycling Collection Areas An enclosure for waste, compost, and recycling collection shall be provided and screened for all multiple family, commercial and industrial uses. The enclosure shall meet the following requirements. a. The walls of the trash enclosure structure shall be constructed of solid masonry material with a decorative exterior surface finish matching the primary exterior wall material of the main structure(s). The trash enclosure walls shall be a minimum six (6) feet in height, and the minimum dimensions shall be adequate for the size and number of dumpster units and recycling bins. b. The trash enclosure structure shall have solid heavy gauge metal gates. c. The trash enclosure shall feature a floor and approach that is paved with a durable all-weather surface approved by the city engineer. d. Trash receptacles shall be covered or a cover structure shall be constructed above the enclosure so as to protect its contents from the elements. e. A trash enclosure for residential developments shall be designed to allow walk-in access by residents without requiring the main enclosure gates to be opened. f. Signage identifying the types of recyclable materials accepted for collection at the trash enclosure shall be posted within the enclosure. g. The trash enclosure shall be designed so that adverse impacts such as noise, odor, vectors, or glare are minimized through the use of adequate separation, fencing, landscaping, or other means. City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 14 h. If visible from public view, the perimeter of the trash enclosure structure shall be planted with landscaping, including a combination of shrubs and/or climbing evergreen vines. i. No trash enclosure shall be located in any required streetside setback area. Building Design 7. Façade Articulation Building facades shall be organized using a two-step system of vertical and horizontal articulation to establish an organizational framework. For buildings that are three (3) or more stories in height, all facades shall be vertically divided into a base, middle, and top to establish hierarchy between the ground floor and upper portions of the building. Buildings less than three (3) stories shall only be required to establish a base. Any building front, side, or rear greater than eighty (80) feet in length shall be horizontally divided along the building’s length into modules and bays to reduce perceived building mass and provide consistent architectural rhythm. 7.1. Vertical Façade Articulation To meet this requirement, vertical façade articulation shall be established with a base, middle, and top as defined below and illustrated in Figure 7.1. a. Base. The base is the ground floor of a building. The floor-to-floor height of the base shall be equal to or greater than the floor-to-floor height of the middle or top. The base shall be visually differentiated from the middle through a continuous horizontal façade element, such as molding or trim, and/or a change in material, that extends the full length of the building. b. Middle. A building’s middle includes all floors that are between the base and the top. The number of floors in the middle shall be greater than the number of floors in either the base or the top. c. Top. The highest floor and/or roof of a building. Where the top includes a habitable floor, the floor-to-floor height of that floor, measured exclusive of roof height, shall not exceed the floor-to-floor height of the base. The top shall be visually differentiated from the middle through a continuous horizontal façade element, such as molding or trim, and/or a change in material, extending the full length of the building. City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 15 Figure 7.1: Vertical Façade Articulation 7.2. Horizontal Façade Articulation To meet this requirement, the building length shall be horizontally divided along into a system of modules and bays, as defined below and illustrated in Figure 7.2. a. Module. A module is a vertical division in a building façade along its horizontal length, defined by a vertical break extending the full height of the building façade, excluding the base. The width of a module shall be at least nine (9) feet and no greater than eighty (80) feet. A module shall include no more than nine (9) bays, as defined in Standard 7.2.b. Individual modules shall be differentiated by incorporating at least two (2) of the following features: • A change in primary wall or finish material • A change in module width • A change in bay width • A change in frontage typology, as provided in Standard 10.5 • A change in window pattern • A change in eave or parapet height of at least two (2) feet • A recess or projection that is at least two (2) feet in depth b. Bay. A bay is a subdivision of a module that repeats the same material and opening pattern within the corresponding module. A bay shall meet all the following requirements: • Shall have a minimum width of six (6) feet and a maximum width of thirty (30) feet. Bays are not required to be equal in width. • At least twenty-five (25) percent of the bay façade area located above the ground floor shall consist of transparent glazing. City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 16 • Openings within a bay shall be vertically aligned on a common center axis. • No blank wall within a bay shall exceed twenty (20) feet in linear length. • Openings and materials can vary between the base, middle, and top. Figure 7.2: Horizontal Façade Articulation 8. Massing 8.1. Maximum Building Length The horizontal length of any building front, side, or rear shall not exceed one-hundred and eighty (180) feet. City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 17 Figure 8.1: Maximum Building Length 8.2. Massing Features Massing features shall be provided along the horizontal length of any building front, side, or rear exceeding eighty (80) feet in compliance with Table 8.3. Massing features shall not encroach into the setback. Projecting balconies and bay windows shall not be considered massing features but can be incorporated within a massing feature. Table 8.3: Massing Features Building Length Minimum Massing Features Required Allowable Massing Features* Up to 80 feet None • Tower • Step back • Projection • Recess Greater than 80 feet, up to 120 feet 1 Greater than 120 feet, up to 160 feet 2 Over 160 feet 3 *Allowable massing features are defined below. (Continued on next page) City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 18 Figure 8.3: Massing Features Allowable massing features are defined as and shall meet the following requirements. a. Tower. A tower is a portion of a building that projects vertically above the roofline. A tower shall meet all the following requirements. • Provide a minimum width of ten (10) feet, maximum of thirty (30) feet • A tower can exceed the maximum building height up to a maximum of ten (10) feet. • The tower shall include at least one (1), and a maximum of three (3), bays. b. Step Back. A step back is a portion of the building above the ground floor that reduces the upper story footprint in comparison to the ground floor. A step back shall meet all the following requirements: • Depth. Minimum depth of five (5) feet, maximum of ten (10) feet • The step back shall be provided for the full length of at least four (4) continuous bays and located above the building’s base. c. Projection or Recess. A projection or recess is a portion of a building façade that extends outward from or is set back from the primary wall plane. A projection or recess shall meet all the following requirements. • Provide a minimum depth of one (1) foot. • Vertically extend through the entire middle and optionally through the base and/or top. • Include at least one (1), and a maximum of three (3) bays. • Provide a corresponding change in roof form in compliance with Standard 9.1. City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 19 9. Roof Design 9.1. Articulation Within individual module boundaries along the building façade, horizontal eaves shall be broken using at least one (1) of the following strategies: a. Gables; b. Building projection or recess for a minimum depth of two (2) feet; c. Change in façade or roof height of at least two (2) feet; d. Change in roof pitch or form; e. Inclusion of dormers, parapets, and/or varying cornices. Figure 9.1: Roof Articulation 9.2. Dormers The combined width of all dormers on a building side shall not exceed fifty (50) percent of the total building length along that same building side. Dormer width shall be measured at the fascia board at the widest horizontal dimension of the dormer. City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 20 9.3. Eaves and Gutters Eaves may encroach into required setbacks by up to two (2) feet. For fire safety, the underside of eaves shall be enclosed and all gutters shall be covered in compliance with Chapter 7A of the California Building Code. 9.4. Vents All ventilation provided for roof and attic spaces shall be ember-resistant in compliance with Chapter 7A of the California Building Code. 10. Ground Floor Design 10.1. Height and Finish Level The ground floor height and finish level of any building shall meet the following requirements: a. The height of a residential ground floor shall be a minimum of ten (10) feet, up to a maximum of twelve (12) feet, measured floor-to-floor. The finish floor height shall be a minimum of one (1) foot, up to a maximum of five (5) feet, above the exterior finished grade. b. The height of a non-residential ground floor shall be a minimum of twelve (12) feet, up to a maximum of sixteen (16) feet, measured floor-to-floor. The finish floor height shall be flush with the adjacent sidewalk or any publicly accessible frontage, as provided in Standard 10.5. 10.2. Habitable Depth Buildings with ground-floor frontage facing a public street, common open space, or designated pedestrian walkway shall provide interior habitable space that meets the following requirements: a. The minimum habitable depth of a ground-floor residential unit shall be fifteen (15) feet, measured from the exterior building façade. b. The minimum habitable depth of a ground-floor non-residential unit shall be twenty (20) feet, measured from the exterior building façade. 10.3. Façade Transparency Transparency shall be provided on the ground floor façade with window and door openings as follows: a. Residential ground floors shall provide at least twenty-five (25) percent transparency of the façade area. City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 21 b. Non-residential ground floors shall provide at least sixty (60) percent transparency of the façade area. Figure 10.3: Façade Transparency (Residential) 10.4. Frontage Placement At least seventy-five (75) percent of any street-facing building frontage, measured along the ground floor, shall be located on, or within ten (10) feet of the applicable minimum front setback. 10.5. Frontage Types The frontage types in this section may be applied to residential and non-residential ground floors, except where specifically excluded. Table 10.5 identifies which frontage types are allowed, not allowed, or required based on the interior ground-floor use. The following provisions apply to all frontage typologies. • All ground-floor units (residential or non-residential) shall incorporate at least one (1) frontage type. • Frontage types can be combined. • Where a publicly accessible frontage is provided, it shall be considered the sidewalk for the purposes of measuring finish floor height. • Frontages can encroach beyond the applicable front setback up to a maximum of five (5) feet unless otherwise specified below. • Frontage encroachments into the public right-of-way shall require an encroachment permit in compliance with Rohnert Park Municipal Code Chapter 12.04. City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 22 Table 10.5: Summary of Frontage Types Frontage Type Residential Ground Floor Non-Residential Ground Floor Common Entrance Allowed Allowed Forecourt Allowed Allowed Gallery Allowed Allowed Gateway Allowed Allowed Patio Allowed Allowed Porch Allowed Allowed Shopfront Not Allowed Required Stoop Allowed Not Allowed Terrace Allowed Allowed a. Common Entrance. A common entrance provides entry for multiple units and shall meet the standards in Table 10.5.a. Table 10.5.a: Common Entrance Requirements Minimum Maximum Residential Non- Residential Residential Non- Residential Depth 18 inches 2 feet 4 feet 8 feet Width 5 feet 8 feet 12 feet 15 feet Height (Clear) 8 feet 10 feet 12 feet 16 feet More than one common entrance can be provided if at least one (1) common entrance is located at the front of the building. A common entrance shall be oriented to a street, designated pedestrian walkway, and/or common open space. City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 23 A common entrance shall be articulated with at least three (3) of the following architectural features. • Provide accent materials that are distinct from the primary façade material • Provide awnings, excluding membrane and vinyl materials • Provide sidelights or accent lighting at the entrance • Provide arches framing the entrance • Provide columns or pilasters defining the entrance • Provide façade insets surrounding the entrance door • Provide windows located above or to the sides of the entrance door • Incorporate a porch or stoop frontage • Provide recessed doorways set back from the wall plane at least six (6) inches Figure 10.5.a: Common Entrance City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 24 b. Forecourt. A forecourt is an open-air space on the building frontage with primary entrances oriented to the courtyard interior. A forecourt shall meet the standards in Table 10.5.b. Table 10.5.b: Forecourt Requirements Minimum Maximum Residential Non- Residential Residential Non- Residential Depth (Clear) 15 feet 20 feet 40 feet 50 feet Width (Clear) 15 feet 30 feet 40 feet 50 feet Height (Landing) None 3 feet Figure 10.5.b: Forecourt City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 25 c. Gallery. A gallery is a one- or two-story structure that projects from the building façade to provide cover for a sidewalk and/or seating area. A gallery can extend beyond the applicable front setback for its full depth and can encroach into the public right-of-way, subject to approval of an encroachment permit. A gallery shall meet the standards in Table 10.5.c. Table 10.5.c: Gallery Requirements Minimum Maximum Residential Non- Residential Residential Non- Residential Depth (Clear) 6 feet 10 feet 16 feet 20 feet Height (Clear) 10 feet 12 feet 12 feet 16 feet Height (Stories) 1 Story 2 Stories Setback from Curb 2 feet None A gallery shall maintain a consistent depth at the front façade. A gallery shall occupy at least 50% of the façade on buildings over 50’ wide The ground floor of a gallery shall be covered entirely with a roof. Lighting is required within the gallery. Figure 10.5.c: Gallery City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 26 d. Gateway. A gateway is a covered, open-air passage that connects the sidewalk through the ground floor of a building to an interior courtyard. A gateway can include a vertical change in grade from the sidewalk and shall consist of three (3) parts in succession: a portal, a passageway, and a courtyard. A gateway shall meet the standards in Table 10.5.d. Table 10.5.d: Gateway Requirements Minimum Maximum Portal (into Passageway) Width (Clear) 8 feet None Height (Clear) 10 feet None Passageway (into Courtyard) Depth (Clear) 10 feet 40 feet Height (Clear) 10 feet None Interior Courtyard Depth (Clear) 15 feet None Width (Clear) 25 feet None Lighting is required within the passageway. Figure 10.5.d: Gateway City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 27 e. Patio. A patio is a private space outside of an entry that is defined by a low wall or hedge extending from the façade. A patio shall meet the standards in Table 10.5.e. Table 10.5.e: Patio Requirements Minimum Maximum Residential Non- Residential Residential Non- Residential Depth (Clear) 5 feet 8 feet 8 feet 20 feet Width (Clear) 15 feet 20 feet 24 feet 40 feet Height (Landing) None 1 foot At Grade Height (Fence/Wall) 2 feet 4 feet Where provided, an individual patio shall provide direct access to no more than two (2) residential units. Figure 10.5.e: Patio City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 28 f. Porch. A porch is a fully covered structure that projects from or is included as part of the main building façade. A porch shall meet the standards in Table 10.5.f. Table 10.5.f: Porch Requirements Minimum Maximum Residential Non- Residential Residential Non- Residential Depth 8 feet 12 feet 15 feet 24 feet Width (Landing) 10 feet 20 feet 15 feet 40 feet Width (Stairs) 4 feet 8 feet 8 feet 16 feet Height (Landing) 1 foot None 6 feet 3 feet Height (Clear) 8 feet 10 feet 12 feet 16 feet A porch shall be covered entirely with a roof. Direct, ADA*-compliant access to a sidewalk shall be provided for any non- residential porch. For the purpose of measuring ground floor height, the porch landing shall be considered the sidewalk. *Americans with Disabilities Act Figure 10.5.f: Porch g. Shopfront (Non-Residential Use). A shopfront is an exclusively non-residential frontage that has an entrance, clear glazing, signage, and framing elements to City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 29 provide visual transparency from interior uses onto the sidewalk. A shopfront shall meet the standards in Table 10.5.g. Table 10.5.g: Shopfront Requirements Minimum Maximum Distance (Openings) None 2 feet Depth (Entry) 1 foot 5 feet Height (Bulkhead) None 2 feet Transparency Minimum 60% of façade area between two (2) and ten (10) feet above the sidewalk. A shopfront can include canopies and awnings. Operable doors and windows that open onto the sidewalk are allowed. A shopfront shall be allowed only on non-residential ground floors. Figure 10.5.g: Shopfront City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 30 h. Stoop (Residential Use). A stoop is a small, raised entry, exclusively for residential ground floors. A stoop shall meet the standards in Table 10.5.h. Table 10.5.h: Stoop Requirements Minimum Maximum Depth (Clear) 3 feet 9 feet Width (Total) 4 feet 10 feet Width (Clear) 4 feet 8 feet Height (Clear) 8 feet 10 feet Height (Landing) 1 foot 5 feet Weather protection shall be provided with an awning or recession that is at least two (2) feet in depth. Where provided, an individual stoop shall provide direct access to no more than two (2) residential units. A stoop shall be allowed only on residential ground floors. Figure 10.5.h: Stoop City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 31 i. Terrace. A terrace is an elevated area for pedestrian circulation along the façade that typically provides access to multiple building entrances. Access to the landing is provided from a stair and/or ramp. A terrace shall meet the following requirements in Table 9.5.i. Table 10.5.i: Terrace Requirements Minimum Maximum Residential Non- Residential Residential Non- Residential Depth (Clear) 6 feet 8 feet 15 feet 24 feet Height (Landing) 1 foot None 4 feet 3 feet Distance (Openings) 8 inches 1 foot 4 feet 2 feet Distance (Between Stairs) None 25 feet Any ground floor unit fronting the terrace shall provide direct access onto the terrace. Figure 10.5.i: Terrace City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 32 11. Fenestration 11.1. Opening Depth and Trim All windows, doorways, and garage openings shall provide the following details at minimum: a. The opening shall be recessed at least two (2) inches from the exterior wall plane. b. The opening shall be framed on at least three (3) sides with trim elements that are at least one (1) in height and two (2) inches in depth. c. Windowsills shall project at least two (2) inches from the surrounding exterior wall plane. Figure 11.1: Opening Depth and Trim 11.2. Window Privacy Windows within thirty (30) feet of an adjacent building’s windows shall maintain a five (5) foot horizontal offset, measured between the edges of the facing window openings. City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 33 Figure 11.2: Window Privacy 11.3. Glazing Reflective glazing is prohibited. Opaque glazing or window treatments shall not be permitted, except for bathroom windows. 12. Enclosed Projections All decks, balconies, patios, and other architectural projections shall be constructed with fully enclosed undersides in compliance with Chapter 7A of the California Building Code to prevent the accumulation and ignition of wind-borne embers. 13. Building Materials 13.1. Variation and Transitions The use and transition of building materials shall meet the following requirements: a. Individual building façades shall use no more than three (3) colors and three (3) materials; window trim, molding dividing floors, and fascia are excluded from this limit. b. Heavier façade materials shall be placed beneath lighter materials. c. Changes in building materials shall occur horizontally or at the inside corner of a building façade. City of Rohnert Park April 23, 2026 Administrative Draft – Objective Design Standards 34 Figure 13.1: Material Variation 13.2. Fire Resistance All exterior building materials and components shall have a Class-A fire-resistance rating as defined in the California Building Code. 13.3. Prohibited Materials Use of the following materials shall be prohibited. a. Single-coat stucco or plaster b. Plywood siding panels (T1-11 or similar) c. Aluminum siding d. Vinyl ORDINANCE NO. 987 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ROHNERT PARK, CALIFORNIA, ADOPTING THE FIRE HAZARD SEVERITY ZONE MAP AS PUBLISHED BY THE CALIFORNIA STATE FIRE MARSHAL FOR THE CITY OF ROHNERT PARK WITHOUT MODIFICATION AND FINDING THIS ACTION IS EXEMPT FROM CEQA WHEREAS, Government Code Section 51178 requires the California State Fire Marshal to identify areas within the state as "moderate," "high," and "very high" Fire Hazard Severity Zones ("FHSZ") using consistent statewide criteria, including fuel loading, slope, fire weather, and other relevant factors; WHEREAS, the State Fire Marshal has completed the mapping process and published an official FHSZ Map for the City of Rohnert Park dated February 24, 2025, a true and correct copy of which is attached as Exhibit A; WHEREAS, the FHSZ Map identifies several areas within the City of Rohnert Park as "moderate" hazard zones and does not include any areas designated as "high" or "very high"; WHEREAS, the City of Rohnert Park, as a local agency, is required under Government Code Section 5 l l 79(g) to make the published map available to the public; WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Rohnert Park has reviewed the FHSZ Map and finds that it accurately reflects the conditions within the City and satisfies the State's requirements for public disclosure and hazard identification; and WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Rohnert Park intends this ordinance to substantially conform to the model ordinance of the State Fire Marshall and, thereby, is in compliance with the requirements of Government Code Section 51179. NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ROHNERT PARK DOES ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Recitals. The above recitations are true and correct and are incorporated herein by reference as findings. Section 2. Findings for the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA"). The City Council finds that the adoption of this ordinance is exempt from CEQA review pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Sections 153 78 and 15061 (b )(3), as it can be seen with certainty the adoption of this ordinance will not have a significant effect on the environment. Section 3. Adoption. The City Council hereby finds that the Fire Hazard Severity Zone Map for the City of Rohnert Park, as published by the California State Fire Marshal and attached hereto as Exhibit 1, accurately assesses the risk of fire hazard within the City's jurisdictional boundaries and, therefore, adopts the map as published. Section 4. Public Availability. The City of Rohnert Park shall make the adopted FHSZ Map available to the public in accordance with Government Code Section 51179. Attachment 2 Section 5. Severability. The City Council hereby declares that every section, paragraph, sentence, clause, and phrase of this ordinance is severable. If any section, paragraph, sentence, clause or phrase of this ordinance is for any reason found to be invalid or unconstitutional, such invalidity, or unconstitutionality shall not affect the validity or constitutionality of the remaining sections, paragraphs, sentences, clauses, or phrases. Section 6. Effective Date. This ordinance shall be in full force and effective thirty 30) days after its adoption. Section 7. Publication. The City Clerk is directed to cause this ordinance to be published in the manner required by law. This ordinance was introduced by the City Council of the City of Rohnert Park at its regular meeting on May 13, 2025, and was duly and regularly adopted on May 27, 2025, by the following roll call vote: AYE S: Courtilmembu-s P% 15t E1wa'- , R..r+ 5vc2., V1c, Mc ur sanb, n.` Gr Ca ; c NOES: vn ABSENT: tJo ABSTAIN: Nave- CI 1' OF` • HNC' 1 ARK Ard ki/0 erard Guid..-, Mayor APPROVED: Elizabeth Machado, Assistant City Clerk AP OV T RM Michelle Marchetta Kenyon, City Attorney Attachment: Exhibit A— Fire Hazard Severity Zone Map of the City of Rohnert Park Ordinance No. 987 Page 2 of 2 City and County boundaries as of 10/ 22/ 24 (CA Board of Equalization) CAL FIRE State Responsibility Areas (SRA25_1) CAL FIRE Fire Hazard Severity Zones (FHSZSRA23_ 3, FHSZLRA_25_1) Data Sources: Daniel Berlant, State Fire Marshal, CA Department of Forestry and Fire Protection Joe Tyler, Director/ Fire Chief, CA Department of Forestry and Fire Protection Wade Crowfoot, Secretary for Natural Resources, CA Natural Resources Agency Gavin Newsom, Governor, State ofCaliforniaTheState of California and the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection make no representations or warranties regarding the accuracy of data or maps. Neither the State nor the Department shall be liable under any circumstances for any direct, special, incidental, or consequential damages with respect to any claim by any user or third party on account of, or arising from, the use of data or maps. and other relevant factors including areas where winds have been identified by the Office of the State Fire Marshal as a major cause of wildfire spread. statewide criteria and based on the severity of fire hazard that is expected to prevail in those areas. Moderate, high, and very high fire hazard severity zones shall be based on fuel loading, slope, fire weather, Government Code section 51178 requires the State Fire Marshal to identify areas in the state as moderate, high, and very high fire hazard severity zones based on consistent Federal Responsibility Area ( FRA) Unzoned LRA Incorporated City Projection: NAD 83 California Teale Albers Scale: 1:29,000 at 11" x 17" 0 12Km 01Mi High Moderate Moderate Fire Hazard Severity Zones (FHSZ) in Local Responsibility Area (LRA), as Identified by the State Fire Marshal Rohnert Park 101 8NINC2RP2RATED S2N2MA C2. C2TATI February 24, 2025 As Identified by the State FireMarshalLocalResponsibility Area Fire Hazard Severity Zones CITY OF ROHNERT PARK – SONOMA COUNTY Fire Hazard Severity Zones in State Responsibility Area (SRA), Effective April 1, 2024 Construction Costs for Wildfire-Resistant Homes A comparison between California Wildland-Urban Interface Code (CWUIC) Part 7, IBHS Wildfire Prepared Home Base, and IBHS Wildfire Prepared Home Plus Fall 2025 Attachment 3 Construction Costs for Wildfire-Resistant Homes Fall 2025- 2 - Construction Costs for Wildfire-Resistant Homes A comparison between California Wildland-Urban Interface Code (CWUIC) Part 7, IBHS Wildfire Prepared Home Base, and IBHS Wildfire Prepared Home Plus Authors Kimiko Barrett, Ph.D. | Sr. Wildfire Research & Policy | kimi@headwaterseconomics.org Steve Hawks | Sr. Director for Wildfire | shawks@ibhs.org This report was produced by Headwaters Economics with generous support from the USDA Forest Service and private foundations. This organization is an equal opportunity provider. The recommendations in this document are general suggestions aimed at reducing the risk of wildfire damage to a single-family home. Implementing these suggestions does not guarantee the prevention of damage. Every property and situation is unique, and we recommend consulting with local fire authorities or professionals for advice tailored to specific conditions. The organizations that produced this report are not liable for any damages or losses that may occur by following these recommendations. P.O. Box 7059 | Bozeman, MT 59771 https://headwaterseconomics.org Construction Costs for Wildfire-Resistant Homes Fall 2025- 3 - Table of Contents Table of Contents 2 Executive Summary 4 Methods & Assumptions 6 Roof 7 Under-Eave Area 7 Exterior Walls 8 Windows & Doors 8 Attached Deck 9 Zone 0 (Near-Home Landscaping) 9 Conclusion 10 Appendix: Cost and Materials Tables 11 Construction Costs for Wildfire-Resistant Homes Fall 2025- 4 - Executive Summary In January 2025 the County and City of Los Angeles was devastated by catastrophic wildfires that destroyed more than 16,000 structures. As rebuilding efforts begin, constructing homes to wildfire-resistant standards is essential to strengthening long-term community resilience and reducing future wildfire losses. California, a leader in wildfire mitigation, enforces some of the nation’s most comprehensive building regulations through its Building Code Chapter 7A (Materials and Construction Methods for Exterior Wildfire Exposure), which outlines materials and construction methods for exterior wildfire exposure in the higher wildfire hazard areas of the state. Homeowners and builders can comply through prescriptive or performance- based approaches, offering flexibility in achieving wildfire resistance. On January 1, 2026, Chapter 7A will become Part 7 (Title 24) of the California Wildland-Urban Interface Code (CWUIC). Complementing state efforts, the Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS) has developed the Wildfire Prepared Home (WFPH) program—along with its enhanced Wildfire Prepared Home Plus (WFPH Plus) designation—to standardize mitigation practices nationwide. The IBHS Wildfire Prepared program provides a systems-based approach to wildfire risk reduction through mitigations to the structure and defensible space that reduces the risk of home ignition from embers (WFPH Base) and flames/radiant heat (WFPH Plus). This study provides detailed wildfire-resistant building material cost estimates for constructing homes that meet these standards, with specific pricing for key components such as roofing, eaves, siding, windows/ doors, decks, and landscaping within the critical 0-5 foot noncombustible zone. The three different wildfire- resistant scenarios are compared to building material costs for a home constructed with “traditional” non- wildfire resistant building materials. Analyzing the costs for wildfire-resistant measures beyond five feet from the home, such as the surrounding defensible space, and the space between homes was beyond the scope of this project. However, these areas also require attention. Reducing fuels between homes, including vegetation, outlying buildings, and fencing, disrupts pathways for fire and embers to spread between neighbors. Ultimately, home and property wildfire mitigation strategies are most effective when every home in the neighborhood participates. Outcomes from this analysis suggest that wildfire-resistant building material costs for a one-story, 1,750-square- foot, single-family home (with an estimated total construction cost value of $500,000) do not significantly increase the costs relative to traditional non-wildfire-resistant home construction (i.e., homes not subject to CWUIC Part 7). Key findings from this analysis include: • Building to IBHS WFPH Base standards yields a potential savings of more than $4,000 compared to CWUIC Part 7 due to no gutter guard requirement, open eave building material considerations, and non- tempered windows. • Building to WFPH Plus adds approximately $2,000 in wildfire-resistant materials over CWUIC Part 7. For a 1,750 SF single-level home, added features include enclosed eaves, noncombustible soffits, and double- tempered windows. • Building to CWUIC Part 7 adds about $13,000 over traditional construction costs due to features like flame- and ember-resistant vents, open eave building material considerations, metal gutter systems, fire- rated wallboard for exterior walls, dual-paned single tempered windows, and a 0-5 foot noncombustible zone (rock mulch and metal fence). When constructing a new home, many wildfire-resistant building material costs are comparable to non- wildfire resistant material costs. As indicated with previous studies, some of the most effective strategies to Construction Costs for Wildfire-Resistant Homes Fall 2025- 5 - reduce structure vulnerability to wildfire are relatively affordable. Risk-reduction strategies such as removing flammable materials from on top of and under the deck, clearing gutter systems, removing vegetation and debris from the roof, ensuring a 0-5 foot noncombustible zone, and relocating flammable materials from underneath the home are critical maintenance tasks with little to no cost to the homeowner. Analysis from this study is explicit to wildfire-resistant building materials and did not capture the full building material costs for constructing an entire home. Values are based on a representative home in Altadena, California with a total estimated construction cost of around $500,000. In other words, there are many other additional components and assemblies within a home that are not required for wildfire-resistant construction and are therefore not included in this analysis. Similarly, there are building materials indicative of home construction preferences in Altadena, California that were assumed in this analysis. For example, common building material assemblies and design practices for this area in southern California include a tiled roof covering, fiber-cement siding, and concrete pour-on-grade patio. Additionally, since the model home was a pour-on-grade foundation, no foundation vents are included in the analysis. The estimated costs for constructing a wildfire-resistant home are derived from a detailed analysis of a specific model home (see Methods& Assumptions section), which provides a clear, standardized baseline for evaluating material and design upgrades. While these figures are highly tailored to the size, layout, and features of that model home, findings from this research offer valuable insights into the broader cost implications of adopting wildfire-resistant practices for a variety of structure types. Differences in individual home components – for example, open eave construction versus enclosed eave construction – will influence associated cost considerations. Many of the expenses for improved wildfire resistant construction, such as wildfire resistant roofs, gutter systems, siding, venting, and a noncombustible zone—can be reasonably extrapolated to larger or more complex homes, though actual costs will vary depending on scale, architectural complexity, site-specific conditions, and materials selected. Assembly Component Traditional CWUIC Part 7 IBHS WFPH Base IBHS WFPH Plus Roof Subtotal: $25,321 $26,311 $26,311 $26,311 Eaves Subtotal: $1,900 $4,284 $3,681 $5,253 Exterior Walls Subtotal: $11,461 $13,569 $13,578 $13,591 Windows/Doors Subtotal: $8,431 $11,391 $8,431 $12,241 Deck Subtotal: $1,968 $1,968 $1,968 $1,968 Zone 0 Subtotal: $1,106 $3,742 $3,742 $3,742 TOTAL (+18% inflation): $59,223 $72,293 $68,099 $74,465 Comparison to Traditional $- $13,070 $8,876 $15,242 Comparison to CWUIC Part 7 $- $- $(4,194) $2,172 Construction Costs for Wildfire-Resistant Homes Fall 2025- 6 - Methods & Assumptions Reducing home ignitions from wildfire requires understanding the different types of fire exposures a home might face. Homes burn down in three ways: • Wind-blown embers traveling ahead of a wildfire can land on combustible material and ignite spot fires. Direct and indirect ember ignition scenarios are the most common cause of ignitions. • Radiant heat from a nearby fire can ignite combustible materials. The effect of radiant heat depends upon the duration of the exposure, distance, and the intensity of the heat. • Direct flame contact occurs when flames spread to touch a building or combustible material. The three standards used in this analysis address one or more of the three types of fire exposure. While IBHS WFPH Base primarily addresses ember exposure, CWUIC Part 7 and IBHS WFPH Plus are intended to reduce vulnerability from all three types of ignition exposure. The cost analysis for this study was based on a representative typical one-story, 1,750-square-foot, single-family home (footprint specifications measuring approximately 35 feet by 50 feet) in Altadena, California. Estimated costs are provided for constructing the home’s roof, under-eave area, exterior walls, windows and doors, deck, and near-home landscaping (also known as Zone 0 or the 0-5 foot noncombustible zone) to wildfire-resistant standards. Suggested building materials considered southern California-specific housing trends, general homeowner material and design preferences, and structure and property characteristics. Mitigation measures for broader property management at the parcel level and minimizing fuels between homes, while critical in reducing wildfire risk to the primary structure, were beyond the scope of this project. These measures include maintaining defensible space and modifying sheds, outlying buildings, and other potential vulnerabilities.1 Findings are adapted from results originally published in Headwaters Economics’ report, Construction Costs for a Wildfire-Resistant Home: California Edition (2022) and Building to Wildfire-Retrofitting a Home for Wildfire Resistance: Costs and Considerations (2024).2 Building materials were selected based on their local availability and when possible, costs were verified with a national database (RS Means, 2023) for standard construction costs. Construction costs for building materials were calculated as a per-unit value. For instance, costs to replace individual windows, including glass and frame, were calculated and reported separately from the cost of an exterior wall. An inflation adjustment of 18% was added to total costs for each scenario to account for building material cost data collected in 2023. Because of extensive variability in site conditions, composition, design, and building materials of home construction, it is difficult to assign an explicit cost for a single structure or group of structures. This research is therefore intended to provide an estimate of building materials for improved wildfire resistance. The subsequent sections of this report provide an overview of the primary exterior home components most vulnerable to fire exposure and estimated costs for related wildfire-resistant building materials. It is important to note the estimates do not include contractor markup costs such as labor, overhead, and profit, which can significantly increase baseline building material costs. Residents and homeowners should consult local contractors for accurate, place-based construction costs. 1 Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety. (2023). IBHS Early Insights: Lahaina Fire – 2023. Retrieved from https://ibhs.org/wp-con- tent/uploads/IBHSEarlyInsights-LahainaFire.pdf 2 Barrett K and Quarles SL. (2024). Retrofitting a Home for Wildfire Resistance: Costs and Considerations. Headwaters Economics. Retrieved from https://headwaterseconomics.org/natural-hazards/retrofitting-home-wildfire-resistance/ Construction Costs for Wildfire-Resistant Homes Fall 2025- 7 - Building Material Costs Roof Roofs are highly vulnerable to ignition due to their relatively large horizontal surface area. Many Class A fire- rated roof covering options are available with the most common being asphalt fiberglass composition shingled roof. Two vulnerable features of the roof edge can affect the vulnerability of the roof to ignition. These include roof covering profiles where a gap exists between the roof covering and roof sheathing (i.e., the roof deck) and gutters at the roof edge where vegetative debris can accumulate. For this analysis, a tiled roof was assumed for all four scenarios and is the preferred roof covering for Altadena, CA. For the wildfire-resistant homes (CWUIC, WFPH Base, WFPH Plus), flame- and ember-resistant vents, metal flashing for roof valleys, and a fire-resistant underlayment were included in the cost analysis. Assembly Component Traditional CWUIC Part 7 IBHS WFPH Base IBHS WFPH Plus Roof Roof covering Tile Tile Tile Tile Flashing None Metal Metal Metal Underlayment Felt Synthetic/Fire-resistant Synthetic/Fire-resistant Synthetic/Fire-resistant Roof gaps/openings Bird stopping Bird stopping Bird stopping Bird stopping Roof vents (ridge)Plastic Flame/ember-resistant vents Flame/ember-resistant vents Flame/ember-resistant vents Subtotal: $25,321 $26,311 $26,311 $26,311 Under-Eave Area Eaves play an important role for building design but they also create vulnerabilities and pathways for the building to ignite. Embers can travel through vents in the eave into the attic or accumulate in gaps between blocking and rafters in open-eave construction. Should flames reach the under-eave area, open eaves can also trap heat. Once there is an ignition in the under-eave area, fire will spread laterally more quickly. Vents in the under-eave area allow air to enter the attic space. During a wildfire, vent openings can allow the entry of wind-blown embers into the interior attic space. If combustible materials in the attic ignite, the house can burn from the inside out. Newer vents have been designed to resist the intrusion of flames and embers. Best practices for ignition resistance of an under-eave area are to enclose the eave with noncombustible soffit material and install flame- and ember-resistant vents (“WUI” vents). For this analysis, an enclosed eave was assumed for WFPH Plus construction, including a continuous linear flame- and ember-resistant vent. For the other home scenarios, an open eave design was assumed with applicable building materials considerations for vents and soffit. Assembly Component Traditional CWUIC Part 7 IBHS WFPH Base IBHS WFPH Plus Eaves Design Open Open Open Enclosed Exposed roof deck Wood Noncombustible - fiber cement Wood N/A Soffit None None None Noncombustible - fiber cement Soffit vents Circular - resin Circular flame/ember-resistant Circular flame/ember-resistant Linear flame/ember-resistant Gaps/openings (vents)None Fire-rated caulk Fire-rated caulk Fire-rated caulk Gutters Vinyl Metal Metal Metal Gutter guard None Metal None Metal Drip edge None Metal Metal Metal Subtotal: $1,900 $4,284 $3,681 $5,253 Construction Costs for Wildfire-Resistant Homes Fall 2025- 8 - Exterior Walls Exterior walls and components in the wall assembly can be vulnerable if exposed to embers, flames, or prolonged radiant heat from burning items located close to the home. These exposures can ignite combustible siding and the resulting flames can spread vertically and laterally to other wall components such as windows and the under-eave area. Additional considerations for the exterior wall include exterior wall vents such as gable, forced air, and foundation vents. For this analysis, fiber-cement siding and trim were assumed for all four home scenarios and based on common building material preferences for Altadena, CA. Since the model home is a pour-on-grade foundation, no foundation vents were included in this analysis. Assembly Component Traditional CWUIC Part 7 IBHS WFPH Base IBHS WFPH Plus Ext Walls Siding Noncombustible - fiber cement Noncombustible - fiber cement Noncombustible - fiber cement Noncombustible - fiber cement Trim Noncombustible - fiber cement Noncombustible - fiber cement Noncombustible - fiber cement Noncombustible - fiber cement Wallboard None Gypsum Gypsum Gypsum Forced Air vents Vinyl Vinyl Vinyl w/ louver Metal w/ louver Subtotal: $11,461 $13,569 $13,578 $13,591 Windows and Doors The glass of the window is vulnerable to breaking from exposure to radiant heat or direct flame contact. When glass in a window breaks, the combustible materials inside the home can be more easily ignited from the flames and/or embers that enter into the home. Wood- and vinyl-framed windows can burn or melt when exposed to radiant heat or flames, allowing the glass to fall out of the frame and flames and/or embers into the home. Doors, including window glass set in doors, and door frames can fail for the same reasons as windows. Embers can accumulate in the small gaps between the door and frame, resulting in ignition of the door-framing and weather-sealing material including garage, pedestrian, and front doors. A variety of different windows were assumed for this analysis and based on assumptions of traditional home construction compared to wildfire-resistant (and energy efficiency) requirements. For both the traditional home and WFPH Base, a vinyl-framed, single hung, dual-paned window with non-tempered (annealed) glass was assumed. For compliance with CWUIC Part 7 and energy efficiency standards, a dual-paned, single-tempered casement vinyl-framed window was analyzed. For the highest wildfire-resistance to prolonged radiant heat (WFPH Plus), a dual-paned, double-tempered metal-clad casement window was priced out. Assembly Component Traditional CWUIC Part 7 IBHS WFPH Base IBHS WFPH Plus Windows Sliding glass window (48" x 36")Vinyl framed; dual-paned, non-tempered annealed glass (single hung) Vinyl framed; dual-paned, single tempered (casement)Vinyl framed; dual-paned, non-tempered annealed glass (single hung) Dual paned double tempered metal-clad glass window (casement) Doors Pedestrian Wood Wood - solid core Wood - solid core Wood - solid core Side door Wood Wood - solid core Wood - solid core Wood - solid core Sliding glass patio Vinyl Vinyl Vinyl Vinyl Garage Aluminium Aluminium Aluminium Aluminium Subtotal: $8,431 $11,391 $8,431 $12,241 Construction Costs for Wildfire-Resistant Homes Fall 2025- 9 - Attached Deck Similar to a roof, a deck has a large horizontal surface area and can be vulnerable to embers and under-deck flames. A burning deck can expose the side of the house to extended radiant heat and/or direct flame contact. The deck walking surface and structural support members, as well as what is stored on or below the deck, are therefore important considerations. Enclosing the under-deck area with metal mesh screening can minimize the accumulation of vegetative debris, vegetation, and other combustible materials. Most commonly used deck board products (including wood and plastic composite boards) are combustible. Decks with noncombustible walking surfaces include lightweight concrete or a flagstone product. Regardless of the walking surface, decks are typically supported by solid wood joists, beams, and columns that will be vulnerable to ignition if nearby combustible materials ignite. For purposes of this study and based on homeowner preferences for the Altadena area in southern California, a concrete pour-on-grade patio was assumed for all four home scenarios. A pour-on-grade patio eliminates consideration of a structural support system including joists, beams, and columns that are required for an elevated decking assembly and are not included in this analysis. Assembly Component Traditional CWUIC Part 7 IBHS WFPH Base IBHS WFPH Plus Deck Decking surface Concrete pour-on-slab patio Concrete pour-on-slab patio Concrete pour-on-slab patio Concrete pour-on-slab patio Subtotal: $1,968 $1,968 $1,968 $1,968 Zone 0 (0-5 foot noncombustible zone) Landscaping makes the home vulnerable when it ignites and allows fire to burn directly to the home. Ignition of near-home combustible materials (e.g., mulch, plants, fencing, vegetative debris and other combustible materials) from embers allows flames to touch the home regardless of how well broader vegetation management (defensible space) has been implemented and maintained. Eliminating fuels within five feet of the home is an important mitigation strategy. The type of vegetation, mulch, and other near-home landscaping features and combustible materials in this zone including fencing, will affect the home’s vulnerability to ember ignitions and the potential for radiant heat and direct flame contact. This analysis considers mulch and fencing in the material selection within the 0-5 foot noncombustible zone. For the traditional home, bark mulch and a wood fence (including posts) were evaluated. For the three wildfire- resistant home scenarios, rock (pea gravel) mulch and a metal fence were analyzed. While there are many types of fencing, materials included in this study were for privacy fencing (versus a boundary fence such as wrought iron). Assembly Component Traditional CWUIC Part 7 IBHS WFPH Base IBHS WFPH Plus Zone 0 Mulch Cedar bark Gravel Gravel Gravel Fencing Wood Metal Metal Metal Subtotal: $1,106 $3,742 $3,742 $3,742 Construction Costs for Wildfire-Resistant Homes Fall 2025- 10 - Conclusion In conclusion, this analysis reinforces that incorporating wildfire-resistant building materials—whether through California Wildland-Urban Interface Code (CWUIC) or the IBHS Wildfire Prepared Home (WFPH) standards—can be achieved at a relatively modest increase in cost compared to traditional construction. For a one-story, 1,750-square-foot mid-range home valued at $500,000, building to WFPH Base increases total construction costs by 2% over a traditional home (and by 3% for WFPH Plus). The estimated costs for building a wildfire-resistant home are based on a detailed assessment of a specific model home, providing a standardized baseline for evaluating material and design upgrades. Although tailored to that home’s unique size and features, the findings offer broader insight into the potential costs of adopting wildfire- resistant construction across different types of homes. Variations in design elements—such as open versus enclosed eaves—affect overall expenses. Many fire-resistant upgrades, including roofing, siding, vents, gutters, and a 0-5 foot noncombustible zone, can be extrapolated to larger or more complex homes, though actual costs will vary with scale, design complexity, site-specific conditions, and building materials. These investments provide meaningful protection against wildfire risks, especially when paired with simple, low-cost maintenance actions like clearing debris and maintaining a noncombustible zone. While this study focused on building materials, it also highlights the broader importance of community-wide mitigation, including managing defensible space and reducing fuel continuity between neighboring properties. As wildfire threats intensify across the West, the findings here suggest that building wildfire-resistant homes is both feasible and financially practical—an essential step toward safeguarding communities in high-risk areas. Construction Costs for Wildfire-Resistant Homes Fall 2025- 11 - Appendix: Cost and Materials Tables Wildfire-Resistant Construction & Costs (2025)Data TablesCost Estimates 2023-2024 ABOUT THE DATA Pricing is from local suppliers and RSMeans,a national database of construction materials, labor, and contractor O&P costs. Findings are adapted from results originally published in Headwaters Economics’ report, Construction Costs for a Wildfire-Resistant Home: California Edition (2022) and Building to Wildfire-Retrofitting a Home for Wildfire Resistance: Costs and Considerations (2024). RSMeans is updated quarterly, includes average construction cost indices from more than 970 cities, and uses the latest negotiated labor costs for average wages in 30 major cities. Prices include the cost of material as installed (i.e., material plus estimated labor and contractor overhead and profit costs). In some cases, pricing was not available through RSMeans and costs were derived from building subject matter expert, supplier, or local distributors. Pricing includes analyzed building material costs available locally (e.g., at Home Depot and Lowes) and when possible, verified costs with a national database for standard construction costs. In most cases, demolition, labor, and contractor overhead are not included in building material costs.   COLUMN DEFINITIONS Assembly: major groupings, or systems, of features such as roof, eaves, exterior walls, windows/doors, and deck. Component: describes the part of the assembly that was priced. Traditional: building materials conventionally used in a non-wildfire-resistant home CWUIC Part 7: California Wildland-Urban Interface Code (CWUIC), Title 24 Part 7 for wildfire-resistant home construction IBHS WFPH Base: Minimum criteria to meet IBHS Wildfire Prepared Home designation, such as creating the 0–5 Foot Noncombustible Zone, upgrading building features, and maintaining the defensible space surrounding the parcel to 30 feet. IBHS WFPH Plus: Additional protective measures beyond the WFPH Base for key building features of the home, and to achieve enhanced wildfire-resistance to flame and radiant heat.   ABOUT HEADWATERS ECONOMICS Headwaters Economics is an independent, nonprofit research group. Our mission is to improve community development and land management decisions. https://headwaterseconomics.org PO Box 7059, Bozeman, MT 59771 Contact: Kimiko Barrett, kimi@headwaterseconomics.org, 406-224-1837 Construction Costs for Wildfire-Resistant Homes Fall 2025- 12 - Table 1: Building materials costs for wildfire-resistant standards Assembly Component Traditional CWUIC Part 7 IBHS WFPH Base IBHS WFPH Plus Roof Roof covering Tile Tile Tile Tile Flashing None Metal Metal Metal Underlayment Felt Synthetic/Fire-resistant Synthetic/Fire-resistant Synthetic/Fire-resistant Roof gaps/openings Bird stopping Bird stopping Bird stopping Bird stopping Roof vents (ridge)Plastic Flame/ember-resistant vents Flame/ember-resistant vents Flame/ember-resistant vents Subtotal: $25,321 $26,311 $26,311 $26,311 Eaves Design Open Open Open Enclosed Exposed roof deck Wood Noncombustible - fiber cement Wood N/A Soffit None None None Noncombustible - fiber cement Soffit vents Circular - resin Circular flame/ember-resistant Circular flame/ember-resistant Linear flame/ember-resistant Gaps/openings (vents)None Fire-rated caulk Fire-rated caulk Fire-rated caulk Gutters Vinyl Metal Metal Metal Gutter guard None Metal None Metal Drip edge None Metal Metal Metal Subtotal: $1,900 $4,284 $3,681 $5,253 Exterior Walls Siding Noncombustible - fiber cement Noncombustible - fiber cement Noncombustible - fiber cement Noncombustible - fiber cement Trim Noncombustible - fiber cement Noncombustible - fiber cement Noncombustible - fiber cement Noncombustible - fiber cement Wallboard None Gypsum Gypsum Gypsum Forced Air vents Plastic Plastic Vinyl w/ louver Metal w/ louver Subtotal: $11,431 $13,569 $13,578 $13,591 Windows Sliding glass window (48" x 36")Vinyl framed; single-paned, non-tempered annealed glass (single hung) Vinyl framed; dual-paned, single tempered (casement)Vinyl framed; single-paned, non-tempered annealed glass (single hung) Dual paned double tempered metal-clad glass window (casement) Doors Pedestrian Wood Wood - solid core Wood - solid core Wood - solid core Side door Wood Wood - solid core Wood - solid core Wood - solid core Sliding glass patio Vinyl Vinyl Vinyl Vinyl Garage Aluminium Aluminium Aluminium Aluminium Subtotal: $8,431 $11,391 $8,431 $12,241 Deck Decking surface Concrete pour-on-slab patio Concrete pour-on-slab patio Concrete pour-on-slab patio Concrete pour-on-slab patio Subtotal: $1,968 $1,968 $1,968 $1,968 Zone 0 Mulch Cedar bark Gravel Gravel Gravel Fencing Wood Metal Metal Metal Subtotal: $1,106 $3,742 $3,742 $3,742 TOTAL (+18% inflation): $59,223 $72,293 $68,099 $74,465 Comparison to Traditional $- $13,070 $8,876 $15,242 Comparison to CWUIC Part 7 $- $- $(4,194) $2,172 Construction Costs for Wildfire-Resistant Homes Fall 2025- 13 - Table 2: Minimum criteria to meet wildfire-resistant standards Component CWUIC Part 7 IBHS WFPH IBHS WFPH+ Roof covering and underlayment Requires a Class A fire-rated roof covering. Plug gaps at ends (i.e., bird-stopped, fire-stopped). A minimum 36-inch-wide mineral-surfaced asphalt fiberglass composition cap sheet must be installed under metal valley flashing. Where the roof profile results in a gap between the covering and the roof deck, a mineral- surfaced asphalt fiberglass composition cap sheet must be installed over the roof surface. Class A (cover or assembly)Class A (cover or assembly) Roof vents WUI vents on horizontal/ vertical planes or non-corrosive 1/16” to 1/8” screen on a sloped roof.WUI vents or vents covered with noncombustible, non-corrosive 1/16” to 1/8” screen on a sloped roof. WUI vents or vents covered with noncombustible, non-corrosive 1/16” to 1/8” screen on a sloped roof. Skylights (not included in analysis) Glass unit must be dual-paned, single tempered and protected with noncombustible, non-corrosive 1/16” to 1/8” screen. N/A Glass unit must be dual-paned, single tempered and protected with noncombustible, non-corrosive 1/16” to 1/8” screen. Eaves Soffited or open-eave allowed. If open-eave, nominal 2x material (or greater) is required as blocking and rafters. Exposed roof deck shall be constructed of a material that is noncombustible, or ignition-resistant, or tested for 10-minute direct flame contact, or have a one-hour fire rating on the exterior side of the framing. N/A Noncombustible soffit for enclosed eave; Materials approved for 1 hour fire resistance, or 2-inch nominal dimension lumber). Eave/soffit vents WUI vents on horizontal/ vertical planes; non-corrosive 1/16” to 1/8” screen.WUI vents or vents covered with noncombustible, non-corrosive 1/16” to 1/8” screen. WUI vents or vents covered with noncombustible, non-corrosive 1/16” to 1/8” screen. Gutter System (downspouts, gutter, guard, drip edge) Noncombustible gutters and downspouts. Gutter cover material unspecified. Metal drip edge assumed.Noncombustible gutters and downspouts. No gutter guard req’d. Metal drip edge assumed. Noncombustible cover. Metal drip edge assumed. Siding Five options for compliance: 1) noncombustible material, 2) ignition-resistant material, 3) heavy timber construction, 4) log wall assembly, or 5) assembly complying with SFM 12-7. 6-inches of noncombustible material on the base of the wall (cover). Noncombustible covering Gable vents WUI vents on horizontal/ vertical planes. WUI vents or vents covered with noncombustible, non-corrosive 1/16” to 1/8” screen. WUI vents or vents covered with noncombustible, non-corrosive 1/16” to 1/8” screen. Dryer vents N/A Louver required over vent opening Louver required over vent opening Foundation vents WUI vents on horizontal/ vertical planes. (Not included in this analysis due to pour-on-grade foundation) WUI vents or vents covered with noncombustible, non-corrosive 1/16” to 1/8” screen. WUI vents or vents covered with noncombustible, non-corrosive 1/16” to 1/8” screen. Windows Four options for compliance: 1) multipaned glazing with a minimum of one tempered pane, 2) glass block units, 3) fire-resistance rating of not less than 20 minutes, or 4) meeting performance requirements of SFM 12-7A-2. N/A Dual-paned; double tempered glass or fire-resistance rating of not less than 20 minutes. Doors Noncombustible; ignition-resistant covering; or 20 minute fire rated door; or solid core; weather stripping req’d for gaps in the door and door opening (>1/8”). N/A Noncombustible; ignition-resistant covering; or 20 minute fire rated door; or solid core. Decking surface Noncombustible; Ignition resistance materials, fire treated wood.N/A Noncombustible Mulch Noncombustible Noncombustible Noncombustible Fencing Noncombustible within 5 feet.Noncombustible within 5 feet.Noncombustible within 5 feet. No parallel (back-to-back) combustible fences within 5 feet of each other (5-30 feet from house).